Carole Lutness, no doubt on Frank Ferry's "malcontent" list, came to Tuesday's council meeting with several items on her mind. The liberal activist has lobbied for years for a "Clean Money for Better Government" campaign that she says would bring honesty and integrity back to local elections. She opened her statement by identifying herself as the chairman of that movement, as if she needed an introduction. Lutness said she had just read with alarm an article about rent price increases in Newhall. She noted that one family had seen its rent raised 69% from $800 to over $1400 in the span of just a few months. Lutness said the city's efforts to redevelop old town Newhall were having a detrimental effect on low-income renters who lived in the area. Not everyone could afford Valencia prices, she said, and the skyrocketing rents in Newhall spelled disaster for minorities and others who lived in one of the last affordable places in the SCV. "Where will these people go?" she asked the council, urging them to take action. Assistant City Manger Ken Striplin wasn't cowed in his response a few minutes later. His response was the routine, "The City has no control over free market prices," which is true as far as it goes. With Lutness' three minutes up, the Council moved on to other topics, the power and simultaneous futility of the public comments portion having been displayed. The article Lutness referenced was one I wrote in September 2006. I got word from several contacts on Walnut Street in Newhall that two real estate investment groups had purchased a few aging apartment buildings there. I wrote [archived copy]:
"Vacancies at 24857 Walnut Street are on the rise following Hollywood Carlton Properties’ purchase of the complex in July for $2.38 million. In August, tenants were notified of rent increases on all 18 units. The complex currently has 5 vacancies, and more residents plan to vacate by the end of September to avoid the rate increases. Theresa Rupp, 36, has lived at 24857 Walnut Street with her family for over twelve years. On average, she says, her rent was raised under 10% each year. She was shocked to learn that rent for her 23 year old two bedroom apartment was raised 69% by the new owner just weeks before the start of the school year.Rupp's rent went from $823 a month to $1395 per month. I'll be honest, I was angry when I wrote the article. The new owners were obviously intent on kicking out low-income residents at several of the apartment buildings. This wasn't part of Newhall redevelopment, technically, just greedy owners from Los Angeles intent on exploiting older properties populated by people with little influence and no voice. "Absentee landlords" somehow didn't describe these new owners well enough. They were slum lords. In my town. Exploiting my neighbors. What was particularly outrageous about the new owners was that they only gave their tenants 30 days written notice of the massive spike in rent prices, illegal per state law. Rupp and other residents, upset at being forced out of their homes after 12 years, didn't give up without a fight and "won" the additional 30 days extension due to them according to California law. And to add insult to injury, the change in rent prices was enacted just before the start of the school year, forcing parents in the area to remove their kids from local schools, separating them from friends and teachers. The whole affair was quite instructive: a highly localized lesson in ruthless free market capitalism. The residents of those buildings were simply pawns on a real life Monopoly board, and Walnut Street, one of the areas of the SCV I like for its diversity, occupied a "square" near the beginning of the board in the cheap properties. So what was the local reaction to the dozens of families affected by the massive rent increases and the illegal way in which they were informed? Silence. I had hoped my article would shine a bit of light on the situation there. I was optimistic the Signal or Daily News, both of which read my website at the time, might pick up on the story and offer a sympathetic ear to the residents on Walnut Street. Sometimes the job of a journalist is to "afflict the comfortable and comfort the afflicted," especially those who have no voice and little influence. If there was no legal recourse for these residents, I hoped the papers would at least highlight the nasty behavior of these slum lords. Embarass them for their greed even. But, I was too optimistic. That area, and others in Newhall, have long been ignored by our local press. It's populated mostly by Mexicans and day laborers afterall, and those people are best left unseen and unheard. Months later after my toothless "featured story" fell off the front page, a senior resident wrote a letter to the editor of the Signal. She complained that rents at several senior apartment complexes had risen by 10%. She was upset that residents at these apartments were being forced to pay an additional $70-100 a month to live at these complexes. Seniors there, she said, were being forced to choose between medical care and rent, between buying food and living in a comfortable apartment building. The Signal jumped into action. Within two or three days, an A-1 above-the-fold story highlighted the plight of seniors who had their rent raised $70. There were quotes from seniors, and the paper spoke with the city and the owners about the issue. The topic was brought up in city council meetings several times after seniors organized themselves. Councilmember Weste suggested that the city ought to look into new public/private parternships that would ensure cheap senior housing in the future. City Manager Pulskamp researched the issue, and while he said that the rent increases were legal, he offered sympathy to the seniors. Lesson number two. Seniors enjoy influence in all levels of government and politics, from local to national. A single, unconfirmed letter to the editor was enough to spark several news stories and an outcry while my article, complete with scanned documents, quotes from residents, and research got ignored. Sure, seniors usually have to live on a fixed income and have limited mobility and residential options. A rent increase hurts them. The topic deserved to be covered by the press. It was newsworthy. But so was the Newhall rent price increase story, which not only involved rent increases some 3-7 times the amount experienced by the seniors, but was done in a fashion that was illegal per state law. I'm not sure what the situation is like on Walnut Street now. I don't see many "For Rent" signs on the buildings I looked into last year, which leads me to conclude one of two things have happened: Either the owners found single family tenants to pay Valencia rates for Newhall apartments or multiple families have moved into single units, further exacerbating the overcrowding problems in Newhall and Canyon Country that everyone bitches about. I suspect the latter is true. I'm glad Lutness found my article and brought it up at Tuesday's meeting. Even though the story was ignored by just about everyone except the unfortunate tenants themselves, it deserved to be heard in front of everyone. Reflections on a Public Comment

Comments
2 · as published