ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

December 15, 2008 · Wayback capture · 3 flags

Happy Birthday Santa Clarita! Now about that General Law….

Attributed to Jeff Wilson (editor-supplied)

The City of Santa Clarita can legally imbibe as of today, December 15, which marks its 21st birthday and official entry into adulthood.

I totally forgot to mention the occasion in today’s Daily Brief, but a Yet Another New Citizen’s Group has sprung up to wish a happy birthday to the City and ask for…

An elected Mayor! Surprise!

Here’s what the group of five women (so far) from the Citizens for an Elected Mayor -established just last week!- have to say on their fancy new website/blog:

During a recent holiday gathering several amazing women began chatting about the possibility of an elected mayor with so many vital issues being juggled at any given time. Our city has matured and outgrown the “honorary” revolving one year term of mayor. Our mayors don’t have the opportunity at long range vision, planning and implementation. Time constrains their direct involvement with our wonderful city staff who are burdened to put together compact recommendations and evaluations on every issue before the council. We concluded that being Mayor of Santa Clarita is a full time job. We decided to see how many like minded residents would join us.

They’re asking for petition signatures and hope to have the issue on the next city-wide ballot in April 2010.

So how would it work?

If you didn’t know by now, Santa Clarita operates as a “General Law” city, which according to the League of California Cities [Wayback copy, 19 December 2008] means Santa Clarita’s organization and functioning are governed by general state laws. This has the advantage of giving such cities a stable foundation on which to operate (such laws have been litigated in the past and are acceptable state-wide).

In our General Law city, the five members of the City Council are elected at large (they have no districts and are voted on by all in the City) and the City’s Chief Executive is City Manager Ken Pulskamp. The City Manager is hired by the City Council, works full time, and earns a salary.

The Mayor of our city, in contrast, is selected anew every year from the current City Council. This position is largely a ceremonial one. Frank Ferry is the current Mayor.

Some 58% of American cities operate similarly to the City of Santa Clarita with a City Manager and City Council, according to the National League of Cities.

So would a potential ballot measure mean changing Santa Clarita from a General Law City to a Charter City, the other type of city in California? I don’t know for sure, but the League of California Cities says sweeping governance changes do require a ballot vote.

Wha twould be the advantages for Santa Claritans if we were to have an elected Mayor? I can think of a few, off the top of my head:

  • Directly accountable to all citizens, whereas the City Manager is accountable to elected representatives
  • A Legitimate office with legitimate powers
  • A full time mayor for a full time city job
  • Longer terms (4 years?)

And some strong disadvantages:

  • The politicization of the City’s Chief Executive. Say what you will about Ken Pulskamp, but he tends to steer clear of politics, especially during City Council meetings. A real Mayor, perhaps, would not
  • Campaign Contributors: Obviously an elected Mayor would receive campaign contributions from a variety of donors whereas a City Manager does not. Whether this is a good or bad thing is a matter of opinion
  • Longer terms than the current Mayoral position

Anyway, what Citizens for an Elected Mayor is proposing is an interesting idea. For some time, there have been those who wanted to see Santa Clarita change from an at-large City Council to a district City Council, where voters from Newhall would elect their own Councilmember. This is obviously quite different than that.

Overall, the group’s point is something to consider: with a population of 175,000 (and another 75,000 just over the freeways), big challenges ahead in infrastructure, healthcare, schools, roads, and safety, is it time for our sleepy burb to become a city with a real, full time Mayor?

I look forward to KHTS & The Signal fully developing this story in the weeks ahead and debating this idea in a public forum.

Happy Birthday Santa Clarita! Now about that General Law….

Comments

8 · as published
  1. spineflower2Dec 15, 7:28 PM
    NO CHANGE to the mayor’s position until we ALSO have regional representatives on the Council. This at-large crap is why the power elite keeps getting re-elected with huge campaign funds.
  2. PubliusDec 16, 4:14 AM
    It seems that the talk of an elected mayor always comes back around when Frank Ferry is mayor.
  3. KellyDec 16, 8:37 AM
    Time for a real Mayor, we have almost of quarter of million people in our fair city. Towns with populations in the hundreds elect their mayor.
  4. spineflower2Dec 16, 9:41 AM
    Santa Clarita is also one of (of not THE) largest California city to NOT elect Councilmembers by District. Even the county’s local Town Councils do that! It’s all about power and money.
  5. JaneDec 16, 11:10 AM
    Ms. Keysor-Smith - How many years of being in the community spotlight does it take to erase years of toxic dumping?
  6. cashDec 16, 11:23 AM
    It is apparent that Newhall and Valencia seem to get all of the attention. Weste lives in Placerita Canyon, Ferry lives in Valencia, Kellar lives in Sand Canyon, McLean lives in Newhall, Ender lives with G&L reality (Valencia). It would be an improvement to the way the city is governed if the East side were truly represented. If not for Al Friedman and TimBen, the east would have a hollow voice. It would be great to see Al and TimBen run for a council seat. Both are critical thinkers, a much need skill currently lacking with three, perhaps four, of the sitting council members.
  7. Allan CameronDec 22, 1:40 PM
    This is an interesting “Basket” of an issue that has many different strands of various issues all interwoven. We dealt with all of them at length on the Santa Clarita City Formation Committee when the issue of a City for Santa Clarita was being considered. Several points of clarification may be helpful. Local government is still not taught in any California school. It should be. A local city councilperson has more power over the lives of local citizens than does the President of the United States. Santa Clarita does not have a “weak Mayor” versus a “strong Mayor” form of government at all. What Santa Clarita has is a City Council/City Manager form of Government. The role of a Mayor in a General Law City is so vastly different from what is found in many old charter cities, that the term “Mayor” itself shouldn’t even be used. A term far more descriptive of what the job actually is might be “Presiding Council Member”. All a Mayor in a General Law City does is preside over meetings. However, the role is not “Honorary”, nor does it in any way , nor could it, have any “CEO”, or executive or administrative powers. In the City Manager form of Government, by State law, the City Manager has all of those powers. Since local government isn’t taught in our State, it is very easy to think that City government is a structural smaller version of State or Federal government, with an executive, legislative, and judicial branch. I fuzzily thought this myself until 1982. City Governments with charters all are as unique as snowflakes. No two are alike. This is where the confusing concepts of “weak Major versus strong Mayor” applying to Santa Calrita orginate. Again the mayor in Santa Clarita is not in any way a CEO or adminintrator. According to State law, a General Law City Mayor has exactly the same power and authority as the other Council Members. There also is no clearly defined executive, legislative and judicial separation of powers in a General Law City. The City Council has both legislative and judicial powers, and the executive authority is vested in the office of the City Manager. However, the City Manager cannot appoint anyone to Policy making positions, such as commissions and so forth. That authority rests with the Council. There are really no useful analogies between the job of Mayor in a General Law City, with the job of the executive in other forms of government, even in other cities, if they are Charter Cities. That is why the name of the very job itself should probably be changed. Los Angeles County, several years ago began calling the Supervisor who presided over Board of Supervisor meetings, the “Mayor of Los Angeles County” This is yet another example of how a term can be used that is confusing. A Charter City, of course, can create any kind of hybrid structure imaginable. As far as each voter being able to elect all five of the people who govern, versus being able to elect one, that also is an issue that we exhaustively processed during the formation of the City. The voters were given the choice of being able to vote for all five, or to devide the City into five regions, and being able to vote for only one. The voters chose to have authority over all five of their representatives by electing them “at large”. While no system is ever absolutely perfect, the idea of voluntarily surrendering 80 percent of ones power over ones government by with drawing into a small area of our City as a district seems strange. There us a lot more to all of these issues. Call me on my mobile number if you wish at 818-634-8669, or send me an email at [email protected] . Have a blessed holaday-Allan Cameron
  8. Allan CameronDec 22, 1:58 PM
    ny email address is [email protected] , or ac(underscore mark)[email protected] Cameron