ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

February 6, 2008 · Wayback capture · 2 flags

Who’s the most controversial among the most controversial?

You gotta love the annual SCV Newsmakers Award dinner. Put on by the SCV Press Club (which is a club just for Signal staffers apparently), the annual charity dinner hands out awards to community newsmakers in several different categories.

The categories range from “Newsmaker” to organization of the year, community service, behind the scenes newsmaker, most cooperative with the local press, and a few others. You can read all the nominees and some more information about the February 29 dinner here [dead link: checked 12 November 2026. The archive holds a copy of this article; it is not yet published.] [Wayback copy, 13 February 2008].

Though the banquet is a public charity event, it’s also yet another one of those insider SCV galas that’s attended by the 300-600 people who are in-the-know and really control the SCV. What’s more, the nominees for the various newsmaker categories are usually found among those same 300-600 people, making it a convenient one-stop shop for back-slapping and drinking, all for charity.

But there’s one category that’s different, and consequently, more interesting for you and me. A journalism instructor once told me that good journalism is about conflict. Man vs nature, man vs man (or little man vs THE MAN), man vs life itself. Carrying that even further, a well known local newswoman once told me that good journalism is about afflicting the comfortable and comforting the afflicted.

So, in that vein, let’s afflict the comfortable by taking a look at the most interesting category: the Most Controversial Newsmaker award.

The nominees (and their controversies along with how they fit into a journalism narrative) are:

  • TimBen Boydston, the maverick, bearded City Councilman and artiste who famously hinted that there was “collusion” between City Planning staff and lobbyists working on behalf of Mayo Hospital (Man vs Man)
  • David Gauny, the heretofore unheard of Valencia man who’s organized presentation (and sexy PowerPoint slides) focused the opposition to the hospital plan and lead to many a Marsha McLean sigh (little man vs City Hall)
  • Hart School Board, the five member panel who probably deserve a long stint in detention after continued delays of Castaic High, budget overruns at area high school construction projects, and misspent Measure V funds (Incompetent powerful man vs little Castaic men and women)
  • Roger Seaver, the captain, spokesperson, offensive and defensive coach of the Mayo Hospital expansion plan, who, while managing to modernize much of Henry Mayo has alienated many of his residential neighbors with his plans for ginormous 5 story Imperial Fortress office towers(the politically connected man vs little men)
  • Scott Wilk, the lobbyists’ lobbyist, the man who’s name pops up in SCV news and politics like Wack-a-Mole at the arcade, the man who managed to become an unelected public official at one SCV education institution while simultaneously lobbying other elected officials at another SCV educational institution. Darth Wilk is the genius behind the city’s open space measure flyers, which told SCVers that a vote against open space was a vote for brown-on-white crime and the SFVization of Santa Clarita. He’s the man who probably has compromising pictures of every mover and shaker in town. (THE MAN, period)

So how does one judge controversial-ness? I have no idea.

But I know I could (and did!) fill about a hundred different blog posts describing these different individuals and groups and their activities in the last year, so they’re definitely a good bunch to choose from.

It doesn’t really strike me as fair to say that David Gauny is controversial; from what I can tell, if Henry Mayo just left him alone and didn’t build anything near his Valencia Summit home, Gauny would slip back into obscurity, happy with his mortgage business. Usually, such people (little man fighting City Hall for home and hearth) aren’t controversial, they’re noble, sympathetic even.

TimBen’s comments, of course, were very controversial at the time and really brought in the hits on SCVTalk.com. He’s fair game for this award, especially since he named City staffers.

The remaining nominees are all controversial in their own right, especially the Hart Board, which tends to trip over its own two (ten?) feet without any help from the outside.

Seaver is a businessman. What more can you say?

Finally, there’s Scott Wilk. He doesn’t seek the limelight, so there’s always that “What’s he up to now?” factor that keeps you on your toes. I can’t wait to see what he’s got cooked up ahead of the City Council election.

So what do you say? Who’s the most controversial of the controversial? Opine in the comments below or in the poll to the right.

Who’s the most controversial among the most controversial?

Comments

6 · as published
  1. valleynewsgalFeb 6th, 2008 at 9:25 pm
    my vote is on the boydston. He’s definitely able to afflict the comfortable, providing a wide paddle with which he’s done some serious stirring.
  2. PoliticoFeb 6th, 2008 at 9:30 pm
    Boydston was just an appointed caretaker for Cameron’s old city council seat. Boydston let it all go to his head and got alittle full of himself, thinking he’s the master power broker and the grand savior for all the rest of us. I guess if that’s controversial, he wins!!!
  3. MorningstarrFeb 7th, 2008 at 6:31 am
    I think Boydston should win too. Not because Politico says that he is full of himself, but because he doesn’t march to the Council demands. I know it doesn’t take much to make Frank Ferry storm out of the meeting room, but kudos to Boydston for addressing unpopular issues!
  4. mikeFeb 7th, 2008 at 8:55 am
    Boydston, for sure. He’s shaken up the council, gone the vigilante route with enforcing the sign laws, and brought the ruckus to city hall, all without being elected. Love or hate, that’s controversy.
  5. Laurie EnderFeb 7th, 2008 at 9:21 am
    I think there should be a whole new category so we can nominate SCVTalkJeff! Anyone who can successfully use “wack-a-mole” in a story deserves an award.
  6. Pauline HarteFeb 7th, 2008 at 10:24 am
    I don’t think Scott or Roger will actually win this because The Signal is probably not aware of all their shady manipulating trying to get G&L’s bad-4-SCV garbage of a project approved even though they both know G&L never intended to build a hospital expansion. As for Scott not seeking the limelight, that is only true in one respect, the fact that he hides in shadows while pushing the G&L garbage project. One must wonder what Scott is so ashamed of, why he floats around the back of City Council when the project is before council but he is never vocal about why he thinks SCV should ignore the many lies and misrepresentations from G&L and Roger Seaver. (Scott is a “favorite” with candidates Lauri Ender and Maria Gutzeit, Scott is seen wispering in their ears while they jot down his every word). I don’t think Scott or Roger will win this category, but the fact that Scott and Roger were nominated at all in this category means they are finally being “recognized” for their utter lack of ethics, something I and many others (including even Tony and Rena Newhall) have complained about in front of City Council many times. Note to G&L rep that threatened me (in front of WAY too many witnesses)to stop writing on SCVTalk about the lies and misreprentations regarding the G&L Medical Office Building Project: when hell freezes over, fella!