ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

August 25, 2009 · Wayback capture · 3 flags

Attempted murder suicide in Valencia

Attributed to Jeff Wilson (editor-supplied)

Another day another attempted murder suicide:

A domestic dispute turned deadly Monday night when a man shot his ex-wife, then turned the gun on himself.

According to Lt. Brenda Cambra, at 7:10 p.m., the Santa Clarita Valley sheriff’s station received several 9-1-1 calls reporting gunfire in the area of the 23800 block of Del Monte Drive, in the Santa Fe condominium complex near McBean Parkway and Del Monte Drive in Valencia.

When deputies arrived, they heard what turned out to be the final gunshot and found a man lying on the ground of a parking lot, bleeding from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head. A handgun was found next to the man.

Residents in the complex then led deputies to a woman who had been shot multiple times. She had been removed from the common area of the complex near the mailboxes where the attack occurred and taken to a condo by neighbors to protect her and allow them to provide aid.

Both victims were transported to Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital for treatment of their injuries and the man died at the hospital.

Cambra said that the couple were divorced and it appeared that the fight was a domestic dispute. Their identities are being withheld until notifications can be made.

KHTS [Wayback copy, 28 August 2009]

This is the third major & deadly incident of domestic violence in the SCV in as many months. First a Canyon Country woman was beat to death by her husband, who then hung himself, then an 18 year old Bowman high student was allegedly strangled to death by her 22 year old boyfriend, and now this.

Fortunately in this case the victim appears to have survived, thanks in part to other heroic residents of the condo complex, who may have hidden the victim [Wayback copy, 28 August 2009] from the shooter.

I know the media reports this ad infinitum, but it bears repeating here. Domestic violence increases during economic downturns, at least according to the experts. Here’s a Boston Globe [Wayback copy, 20 April 2009] article from late last year:

Economic stresses often lead to more frequent abuse, more violent abuse, and more dangerous abuse when domestic violence already exists. Domestic violence programs report that victims experience an increase in abuse in part because out-of-work abusers have more opportunity to batter. Rhode Island, for example, has recently seen a 25 percent increase in felony-level domestic violence crimes. Victims end up with fewer opportunities to contact programs for help, attend support groups, or get away from the batterer.

Compounding the problem, domestic violence programs face a trio of economic factors - cuts in federal funding, increased demand for services, and decreased private donations as people lose their jobs or see a downturn in their personal finances. These budget constraints make it more difficult for local programs to meet the needs of their communities.

In 2007, the National Network to End Domestic Violence conducted its second annual 24-hour census of domestic violence shelters and programs across the nation. The census report found that in one day, more than 53,000 women, men, and children across the country received services from domestic violence programs. Over 25,000 of those individuals - more than half were children - found refuge in emergency domestic violence shelters or transitional housing.

I was glad to see our Domestic Violence center get attention in the media recently, thanks to Assemblyman Smyth’s efforts to fund it and other centers like it throughout the state. I was also happy to see that the center now has a PayPal link on their homepage, making it easy to donate funds if you care to do so.

Attempted murder suicide in Valencia

Comments

28 · as published
  1. cashAug 25, 8:39 AM
    Jeff, the domestic violence center is open. Please explain how an open center failed to help in this situation. Again, I am troubled that we spin these kinds of incidents to promote the need for additional tax dollars to support the DVC. If you can cite situations were the DVC turned people away which subsequently resulted in these kinds of terrible events, then I can support your position. Keep in mind, one of the reasons for the economic stress is because our state is broke and we are taxed to death. We have to find a smaller rain barrel, because the gnats ass will not stretch any wider. Save the children, but adults need to be a bit more responsible for their own actions.
  2. JeffAug 25, 8:45 AM
    How can I prove a negative? In other words, if a woman’s life was saved by staying at a DV center, then no crime occurred.
  3. Timothy MyersAug 25, 9:30 AM
    Cash Obviously not taxed enough, because you are still alive and kickin’! By the way, how did you ever get by the death panel?
  4. cashAug 25, 9:32 AM
    Jeff, that is not the point. These terrible situations are occurring and the response is that we need more money spent on DVC. If the DVC has its door open and the situations still occur, how do you make the connection. If you can verify that people are being turned away from the center and put in harms way, then I get it. But to make the claim that every occurrence of domestic violence is the fault of the taxpayer and the lack of DVC funding does not wash. It is hype and politics. In my view.
  5. cashAug 25, 9:36 AM
    Timmy, you lost me on the death panel. Do you mean the death panel that some believe is part of Obama care or are you asking me if I am a Jewish?
  6. Timothy MyersAug 25, 10:21 AM
    Cash: Just because there are not really death panels in the health care reform legislation doesn’t mean it is not a good idea!
  7. cashAug 25, 10:36 AM
    Never said DVC were not a good idea. I said that connecting every incident of violence that occurs to the lack of DVC funding is nothing more than hype. With respect to death panels, both of my parents passed and we did not need a death panel to help us with the decision making process. I guess there was a death panel of sort, but it was a panel of the family doctor my parents and siblings. No mandate by Obama required.
  8. lvogelAug 25, 10:45 AM
    I think that there may be a bit of ‘gun jump’n’ here…no pun intended. We don’t even know if this recent shooting was a domestic violence situation. We don’t know the whole story. Perhaps it was a depressed individual or someone high on something. Perhaps it was a disgruntled ex-employee. Perhaps a act of passion. Until we know the details (which we may never hear) we don’t know if this was domestic violence. There are many cases where a person kills another individual who has never laid a hand on another human prior to the act, right? You hear all the time where people just can’t believe the killer/attacker would do this. The DVC is very much needed for many women and children who find themselves threatened/abused on a daily basis, and need to get out. We don’t know if this was the case, here.
  9. lvogelAug 25, 11:16 AM
    On the subject of ‘hearing the whole story’, does anyone know the story behind the officer that shot herself at our Sheriff’s department? We didn’t get a follow-up to that story did we?
  10. cashAug 25, 11:21 AM
    Ivogel Good point!
  11. Timothy MyersAug 25, 12:16 PM
    lvogel: KHTS is reporting it was a 79 YEAR OLD guy shooting his ex-wife. (He’s dead.) What is with the seniors? The other murder/suicide was a guy in his 50’s. Sheesh!
  12. MaryAug 25, 12:24 PM
    Interesting comments on the shooting in Valencia. As President of the Domestic Violence Center of Santa Clarita Valley, I would like to point out a few facts: The shelter and Center have both a hotline for victims of dv to call when they feel threatened and counselors to help them when they decide they need to get out of relationships in which they and their children can be killed. Our hotline receives more than 1,000 calls per year. Our shelter is often filled to capacity with women and their children who have been stabbed, raped - and thats just the abuse we can talk about in polite company. However, if victims do not call the hotline, we cannot help them. The teenager who was strangled in SCV a few weeks ago did not call us. We do not go door to door looking for victims. Everyone on this blog likely knows someone who is in a violent relationship, whether that has been disclosed to you is another issue. DV effects all income levels, not just poor, uneducated people. People with good jobs, some well-known in the community are also victims and perpetrators, they just hide it more effectively. It is not about people being depressed or out of work, though the economy is not helpful. It is about power and control. Yes, The Domestic Violence Center has had 100% of its funds cut by the State of California. It severely effects our ability to reach out to teen girls before they become victims and boys before they decide to follow the abusive paths of their fathers or brothers. It will not, however change our mission or our dedication to the belief that women and children deserve to be in a peaceful place away from the horrors of abuse.
  13. cashAug 25, 12:32 PM
    Too bad the guy could not wait another year or two. Nature <or Obamba care, would have handle it for him. This may be more a case of senility than domestic violence. Terrble situation. Mary, thank you very much for your post. Can you tell us what is the center capacity? How many of the 1000 calls are repeat calls? Thanks.
  14. spineflower2Aug 25, 12:32 PM
    We didn’t get a follow-up to that story did we? The Signal is not big on “follow-up.” They try to stay away from that pesky “jernalizm” stuff.
  15. MaryAug 25, 1:15 PM
    The shelter can accommodate 3-4 families and their children. Few of our hotline calls are repeat calls.
  16. cashAug 25, 1:43 PM
    Thank you Mary. You have helped to put this issue in perspective.
  17. Bill ReynoldsAug 25, 2:29 PM
    These fellows may have been veterans and subjected to the VA’s “Death Book” where on pg 21 it practically urges you into the next life. Read this: http://www.werushdaily.com/forums/dittohead-stack-of-stuff/wsj-the-vas-death-book-for-veterans If you’re lucky enough to get out of the womb, the libs will come after later in life…
  18. cashAug 25, 3:07 PM
    Well Bill, at least it is not ethnic cleansing. They just want to kill all the old people, they know they are too old or damaged to riot in the streets.
  19. Timothy MyersAug 25, 5:43 PM
    Bill: How did you get away from the “Sandmen” I sent over? They were supposed to take you “Home.” (Let’s see how many get the references to dystopic 1970’s sci fi.)
  20. lvogelAug 25, 6:34 PM
    for 1000 Alec, um I mean Timothy Myers: What is Logan’s Run…..
  21. ReaderMamaAug 25, 8:29 PM
    I think that there has to be a distinction between “regular” domestic violence and a one-time desperate act which results in one or more deaths in a family. Not too long ago a man killed his entire family and then himself because he had lost his job and his home was in foreclosure. I don’t believe there was any history of abuse in that family. The man was simply unable to cope and went over the edge. I’m betting those kind of events and suicides do occur more frequently in bad economies. Likewise, I am sure that someone who is regularly abusive toward his family, might become even more frequently abusive in the face of job loss or foreclosure since those events are out of his control. I don’t know what the situation was between the latest couple in Valencia, but what a terrible way thing to have happen in one’s neighborhood, within bullet range of one’s children and loved ones. I hate to think of the impact on nearby parked cars. Having someone’s brains splattered on my car would certainly put a damper on my day.
  22. cashAug 25, 8:40 PM
    ReaderMama You were doing so well until the last sentence.
  23. Bill ReynoldsAug 25, 9:19 PM
    Dear Timmy, you are an amatuer. Try writing a meaningful Signal column for a change of pace… something people will actually read. Buh-bye.
  24. DeanAug 26, 8:03 AM
    Attempted murder suicide in Valencia In reading some of the comments related to this latest example of a fatal domestic violence incident in SCV, I’m struck with the reality of just how naïve some are to the aspects of DV. As some want to argue over minutia in an individual story or the what-ifs, the fact of the matter is that DV is prevalent in the SCV just as it is in every community, and we, as a civilized society, need to reach out or be available to those who are seeking help. Does anyone out there really believe that this incident of violence is the first act of domestic violence for this 79-year old man? I sincerely doubt it. The problem with DV is most victims suffer through this in silence for years, sometimes decades or a lifetime. The first thing an abuser does is attack the self esteem of the abused and isolate her to the point she believes there is no help out there. As Mary Ree pointed out, DV is about power and control, “not losing self-control or snapping.” It is not caused by alcohol or bad economic times. It is about a violent person using force, fear and/or intimidation to control another they are intimately involved with. DV usually follows a distinct pattern of escalating violence, both in its severity and frequency. The ultimate control is over someone’s life and in cases of DV related murder, the ultimate act of DV. Some comment, “Save the children but let the adults fend for themselves.” You cannot save the children without saving the adults in DV. DV is learned behavior. Male children who witness DV are very likely to become batterers and female children victims or batterers. Intervention is needed and that is what the Domestic Violence Center of the Santa Clarita Valley provides. They aid women and children and provide court mandated training for convicted offenders in the hopes of ending the cycle of violence. How does DV affect us as a community? We’re talking about it; we feel fear when it happens in our backyard. Our children are in schools, sitting next to children who are suffering silently with DV occurring in their homes. Those children are more likely to be violent and act out and when they get older, are more likely to abuse alcohol and drugs. And haven’t we read enough stories over the years about the man who enters a store mall or comes armed to a church picnic and opens fire into the crowd, trying to kill his ex? The DVCSCV needs our help to fund the before mentioned programs as well as fund outreach to children in our primary, middle and high schools. With the increase of teen girls reporting that they have been the victims of violence by their boyfriends, can we afford to let this organization fold? I think not! Our daughters deserve better and our sons need to know that it’s not okay to use power and control in intimate relationships. Dean Anderson LAPD (Retired) Former Board Member DVCSCV Former volunteer mentor and counselor to convicted DV perpetrators
  25. JeffAug 26, 9:39 AM
    Thank you for your comments Dean.
  26. cashAug 26, 9:40 AM
    Dean if your are going to quote me at least use the words I used. “Save the children, but adults need to be a bit more responsible for their own actions”. BTW, I have encountered more than one abusive woman in my life. I have also encounter women that have ulterior motives for using the DVC. It is not my intent to down play this serious matter, but I believe the whole story should be told. Additionally, I have donated to the center and was surprised to learn that the center has such a limited capacity.
  27. DeanAug 26, 5:00 PM
    Cash, You are right about the quote, it was more of a culmination of similar comments I’ve heard in the past. Sorry, I should have made that more clear. You’re also right that women some times batter. The last statistics I saw on this was that 85% of batterers are men and 15% are women. The difference is why men and women batter. Generally, men batter to gain power and control and women batter out of frustration. Neither is acceptable. When you have limited resources, you have to put those resources where you’ll hopefully get the most benefit. If a male victim of DV seeks help at DVCSCV, the staff there offers aid and referrals to larger organizations that have the staffing and financing. I’m not sure what you mean by being surprised to learn that the center has such a limited capacity. You may be referring the emergency shelter, which is a 30-day shelter for women and their children. After 30-days, if shelter is still needed, the women and children are transferred to transitional housing. The DVC also takes in approximately 1000 calls on their 24-hour hot line, as well as providing group and individual counseling for victims and batterers. For additional information, you and others can visit their web site at http://www.dvcsantaclarita.com/ Thanks for donating to the DVC in the past. Dean
  28. cashAug 26, 5:43 PM
    Thanks for the insight Dean. My capacity comment was based on the following from Mary. She was addressing my question. Mary The shelter can accommodate 3-4 families and their children. Few of our hotline calls are repeat calls.