ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

January 6, 2008 · Wayback capture · 3 flags

Newhall Ranch “Mindless”, LA County “Insatiable Colossus”

Image not recoveredimg_2027-1.jpg

In a strongly worded op/ed [Wayback copy, 28 August 2008], the editor of the Ventura County Star calls Los Angeles County an “insatiable colossus” and decries the imminent, no-comments-allowed decision on the first phase of Newhall Land’s Newhall Ranch project, which will be built along the Los Angeles and Ventura county lines west of Santa Clarita.

Joe Howry, the editor of Ventura county’s largest daily, says the Santa Clara River valley is a place of “stunning beauty” in an otherwise “paved-over” Southern California. “Anyone who has driven Highway 126 can’t help but notice the lushness of the land, the variety of the crops, the anomaly of such rural beauty beneath the shadow of the Magic Mountain tower,” he says.

Howry then describes the project, the impressive statistics of which are already familiar to many in Santa Clarita: 21,000 new homes for an estimated 70,000 presumably new people, “not to mention all the businesses and services necessary to support” such a city. Howry says Newhall Ranch would be about the same size as the city of Camarillo.
He also describes Ventura County’s efforts to fight and mitigate the potential effects of the massive project and calls Los Angeles County’s approval process “heavy-handed and perhaps arrogant.”

As has been discussed here on SCVTalk, a decision on Landmark Village, the first phase of Newhall Ranch, was scheduled for December 22, just three days before Christmas. Local environmentalists Lynne Plambeck and Cam Noltemeyer protested the timing of the meeting and LA County’s Regional Planning Commission rescheduled it for January 9.

Howry says Ventura County recently submitted more concerns to Los Angeles County about the project, but hadn’t heard a response until Ventura learned that LA’s planning commission would discuss -and possibly approve- the first phase of the project this week.

He says that Ventura County is asking LA County to delay its decision.

Howry saves his strongest words to describe Newhall Ranch, Los Angeles County, and the meaning of the project:

The story of the Newhall Ranch development and its potential adverse impact on the Santa Clara River Valley is a familiar one in Southern California. It’s the story of L.A. County playing bully, running roughshod in an oblivious sort of way over every other interest to benefit its own. It is the same old mindless approach to growth that blindly ignores issues such as quality of life, preservation of beauty and heritage, neighborliness, and the reality of unintended consequences.

It is a mind-set that has cost Southern California much. Lifestyles have been torn asunder, natural beauty has been plundered and destroyed, and in its place is a dull, soulless metropolis whose only purpose is to serve itself.

So what do you make of this editorial? Are Howry and his readers in Ventura County narrow-minded NIMBYists who already have their stake in the Golden State and don’t want to share it with the millions of people expected to immigrate to this region in the coming decades? Even with the real estate slump of the last 12 months, I’ve only seen reports that the entire region will face/is facing a housing crunch, so perhaps its unfair to expect that even a beautiful place like the Santa Clara River valley will remain un-impacted.

On the other hand, Howry’s editorial calls to mind LA County’s long history of abuse of the rest of the state of California. From the time it pillaged and plundered the Owens Valley of water to the short-sighted way in which it has spread out into one of the largest cities in the world, Los Angeles’ leadership has always taken an ends-justify-the-means approach, and we’re paying for it today.

What do you think?

Link to Column [Wayback copy, 28 August 2008]

Newhall Ranch.net [Wayback copy, 19 January 2008] website with info on the project

Newhall Ranch “Mindless”, LA County “Insatiable Colossus”

Comments

4 · as published
  1. PubliusJan 6th, 2008 at 6:46 am
    I think the Ventura Couty Star is right.
  2. diggenJan 6th, 2008 at 11:48 am
    The Ventura County Star is definitely right, but as long as NL&F and Lennar own the L.A. County Board of Sups, particularly Mike Antonovich, Newhall Land and Lennar will continue to get anything they want approved from L.A. no matter how destructive to us and the environment their projects are. Anyone see NL&F spokesperson Marlee Lauffer’s comments in the Mag of SC? Marlee says: “Newhall Land celebrates our 125th anniversary in 2008 as a proud steward of the land!” “Our,” hmmmm. Oh sure, Marlee and NL&F, protectors of the environment. They are destroying what is left of our quality of life by giving us the Newhall Ranch Project and the Saugus Riverpark project, besides the never-ending NL&F developing going on beyond Decoro, but they toss in a couple of parks to their massive, ugly urban sprawl projects and call themselves “proud land stewards.” I guess NL&F was being a “proud land steward” when they got caught using illegal hazing machines over there in Valencia so they could get a project underway a few years ago without being troubled by endangered species for their EIR. NL&F spokesperson Marlee Lauffer was quoted in the Daily News defending NL&F’s ILLEGAL, UNAUTHORIZED USE of the hazing machines, but Fish and Game stated that hazing machines would never have been authorized to be used by NL&F. These “Proud land stewards” used illegal hazing machines to run out all the endangered species before the EIR process began so NL&F could “prove” in the EIR that there were no endangered species on their property! And you can bet the same kinds of devious tricks will be used for Newhall Ranch, with truckloads of plastic-smiled excuses/ruses for the public to swallow, like the recent Signal photo-ops of Marlee “teaching” school children how to be “proud land stewards” like NL&F while NL&F is “giving” us the massive Newhall Ranch project and Riverpark! As long as NL&F and Lennar continue to control city councils and County Supervisors, everyone, including the Ventura County Star, is just spitting into a black hole with complaints about all the massive over-development that is destroying this area, and California. Kudos to the Ventura County Star anyway, and I hope they keep it up, but at the same time, I believe their outrage may have come a little too late. And here in SCV, there will be little outrage at all. Such silence and support has been paid for by NL&F for years, from our NL&F controlled City Council, from all the boards of organizations NL&F puts their employees on, and from all their “hush-money” through financial support for various organizations. The outrage will not even begin here until the “new” traffic from the Newhall Ranch project begins adding more gridlock to our already clogged freeways. SCV commuters will finally voice their outrage about the worsening freeway gridlock that continually robs them of precious time with their families as they are forced to leave for work earlier and earlier and arrive home later and later. But all these complainers will still not understand that all their traffic complaints should be directed, should have been directed, to the “proud land stewards” called NL&F that gave our clogged freeways the massive Newhall Ranch project, turning everything into a permanent gridlock situation. And there is also the issue of water, anyone here think they might enjoy water rationing thanks to massive projects like Newhall Ranch?
  3. LitaJan 7th, 2008 at 12:33 pm
    I’m sorry to disagree, but Joe Howry has a lot of nerve to run his mouth…especially about quality of life and lifestyle issues. Ventura County has some of the most sharply-delineated socio-economic groups in the state, with very wealth elitists on one end and three families to a house or apartment immigrants on the other. For Pete’s sake, Oxnard is one of the biggest cesspools to blight our “beautiful” state; impoverished residents, gangs, burned-out buildings serving as havens for homeless (the indoor swapmeet on Saviers that STILL hasn’t been taken-over and torn down by the city or county), struggling schools who are filled with so many poverty-stricken children that they are mandated to just go ahead and give EVERYONE free lunches, and more. And you’ve got to love the complete joke that was Ventura’s Johnson exit-area 101 construction. One of my favorite is the ongoing contradiction between Ventura wanting more “local jobs” but then everyone whining about expansion. And how about the old plant ON THE BEACH SHORE leaching chemicals into the ground water…thereby posing a health threat to residents? And on “neighborliness?” Joe, you conjure-up images of an overbearing, agitated guy who starts freaking-out when his next-door neighbor wants to build a new deck in their backyard. But enough about them, let’s move on to OUR home: Santa Clarita. Santa Clarita is a BEAUTIFUL CITY full of resources for all ages and economic statuses, and the tax base from our inevitable growth and expansion is what helps support all these wonderful resources we have. Our residents - from the poorest to the richest - enjoy a quality of life still UNHEARD OF in a large portion of the United States. We have everything we need and most of what we want at our fingertips. We can take our children out and let them play safely. There are good jobs available both locally and in surrounding cities. There’s an abundance of health care - ranging form free/low-cost clinics to more plastic surgeons than we know what to do with. There’s a growing and very qualified set of emergency services. We have food from a wealth of sources (affordable farmers markets, grocery stores on just about every corner, high-end and “organic” selections, restaurants from every culture you can imagine, free meals for seniors, free food for the poor), excellent social welfare programs, retail establishments for every walk of life (Walmart and Target get US by every day, yet we still love to save our pennies for the latest and greatest at the more exclusive boutique shops, too), parks and city facilities for all, a large number of award-winning schools, Boys and Girls clubs at a large number of school sites for children from all walks of life to play safely until their parents get off work, nice bicycle paths for transportation and enjoyment, and YES, even huge spanses of outdoor space which are STILL THERE for the residents of our city to enjoy. It’s not perfect. There’s a lot of room for improvement, and I’ll agree that traffic is one of those areas needing attention, but with a continued focus on a developing commercial and retail presence - as well as telecommuting and other alternatives, more jobs continue to become available locally. I personally left my 1.5 hour-each-way commute in exchange for a job in the Santa Clarita Valley. I now have a mere 15 minute commute, I see my children longer, I’m more relaxed, and happier all-around! Santa Clarita is still a work in progress, but I’ve seen Newhall Land and the City of Santa Clarita learn from some of their mistakes. I’m glad to see them becoming at least a little more conscious about leaving open areas and thinking more about their impact on the natural environment. The city does appear to be doing more - including the banning of salt water softeners, riverbed clean-up, Towsley Canyon preservation, and more. Yes, it took the screaming and prodding of mindful residents, but that’s what we SHOULD be doing, right? We’ve come a long way, and we’ll continue to do so. Instead of whining and listening to some fools from OTHER areas, let’s do what we can do safeguard our community, contribute to responsible expansion while being our OWN “stewards of the land,” and give our children something to look back on when thinking “wow, our parents really thought of EVERYTHING.”
  4. PubliusJan 7th, 2008 at 1:39 pm
    Well, I see your point that Ventura has no right to complain, but I still don’t agree with the prosed Newhall Ranch project.