ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

June 20, 2008 · Wayback capture · 4 flags

A word about comments

Attributed to Jeff Wilson (editor-supplied)

Over the last two weeks, I’ve received many angry emails and comments posted on this website about the “Awaiting Moderation” message commenters receive when they attempt to submit a post on this site. I’ve changed the way comments are managed, click read more to find out why.

First of all, the mission of SCVTalk is to encourage intelligent and frank discussion about Santa Clarita news, politics, development, and other topics. Discussion is what this website is all about (it’s in the name afterall), so I had to think carefully before I limited and/or changed the way comments were posted.

Since the changeover to this new blog system in January, I’ve posted 240 stories and received 2,375 comments, an astounding average of almost 10 comments per story. So it’s obvious SCVTalk is somewhat useful to the community in that people feel welcome to discuss various topics.

That said, some comments were getting out of hand. I’ve received scores of complaints over the months about the content of specific comments. I’m not going to get into the specific complaints, but suffice it to say the volume increased as more and more people started commenting, so I decided I had to do something.

I have no desire to “censor” anyone, nor can I since I’m not a government agency. What I do desire, however, is good discussion. So, to that end, I decided to emulate the newspaper industry in how they deal with Letters to the Editor. A newspaper like The Signal receives tons of letters, but they only publish a handful. There’s an understanding between the newspaper and the letter writer that his letter may or may not be published. That’s just the way it is.

So I’ve done the same thing with this blog. No longer will comments simply appear under a blog post. If you want to comment on this website, frankly, you should put some thought into your post, because each one will have to be approved by me before it’s posted.

Things that will immediately disqualify a comment from being posted are racial terms, vicious personal attacks against other readers or public figures, carrying on a discussion over several days and in several different blog posts, and other items.

I don’t like having to do this, but it’s my site and I want to encourage good discussion.

The good news is that 95% of you already do just that. Since I turned on this moderation feature, I’ve allowed about 50 comments and denied maybe six. I think you’ll find I’m pretty liberal about what goes on the site.

If you’d like a more free-flowing place to talk about Santa Clarita or anything else you fancy, I’ve set up a discussion forum [Wayback copy, 19 February 2008] that is used by about 100 people.

Let me also take this opportunity to invite those of you who read the site alot and are familiar with Santa Clarita to think about writing occasional columns for SCVTalk. I’m more than open to accepting well-written commentaries, news items, or even humor posts from readers. You can always reach me at [email protected].

So that’s it. I hope you understand why I did this and I hope you’ll continue to read the website. I’m working on some pretty interesting stories that I think you’ll enjoy.

As always thanks for reading!

A word about comments

Comments

6 · as published
  1. navigatorJun 20, 10:18 AM
    Jeff, It’s your ball so you make the rules. I, for one, have no problem with that at all. I’ve had a few editings done to my posts and I haven’t made any comments about it. It’s your game. My concern was the posts that come up with the “awaiting moderation” note and it never goes away so I don’t know if my post is posted, edited, or otherwise disposed of.
  2. MikeJun 20, 10:38 AM
    I’ve had one or a couple held back, and while it may irk me in the moment, I see it like an opinion editor assembling an op-ed page, my letter just didn’t make the cut. I do take each comment more seriously and I think others have as well. Aside from the unavoidable delay and the confusion that causes, I think it’s a net plus. And just as the forums were getting friendly…
  3. BobJun 20, 1:17 PM
    Yes of course, this blog really should be all about friendliness and feelings, rather than about substantive opinions, afterall we do have to deal with limited space here on the Internet.
  4. CCJun 23, 5:48 AM
    Such is the way of open posting. Things can get out of hand rather quickly. I am glad you have taken this step, though the additional moderation must be tiresome. I certainly hope you don’t throw in the entire towel because I do appreciate your daily briefs and am amazed at the information you are able to put together.
  5. MikeJun 23, 7:11 AM
    You weren’t following what I was saying, but thank you for your substantive response.
  6. BobJun 23, 5:19 PM
    Oh yeah, the “Fairness Doctrine”. That’s exactly what we need! Hubba, Hubba!