Our Congressman will give a press conference today about the failure of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, which was signed into law one year ago today. From his press release:
SANTA CLARITA, CA – One year ago tomorrow, Democrats passed a $862 billion stimulus bill that they claimed would immediately spur job creation and economic recovery. Since that time, the nation’s economic health has deteriorated and roughly 3.5 million jobs* have been lost. California’s unemployment rate is sitting at a painful 12.5%.
Businesses in individual communities across America are suffering. For instance, A-V Equipment Rentals, Inc. in Newhall has suffered greatly despite the “so-called” stimulus. Rather than invest in job producing initiatives, Democrats chose to inject millions of dollars in new programs leaving companies such as A-V Rental to lose half of its employees since the stimulus was passed.
What McKeon won’t tell you is that while he voted “No” on the ARRA, he put his own pork in it and has been more than happy to take credit for federal funding he voted against. For example:
- He helped secure $333,000 in the ARRA “to assist Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital in designing and building a helipad” LA TIMES
- The bill also included $167,000 he got for the Autry National center of the American West LA TIMES
- In January, Buck McKeon held a press conference in front of the South Valley WorkSource Center in Palmdale. He announced “that $100,000 in federal funds [have] been secured for the South Valley WorkSource Center.” That money was attached to the fall Omnibus Spending Bill, which McKeon also voted no on LINK [Wayback copy, 13 January 2010]
If he thought this bill would be such a failure, why did he load his own spending in it before voting no?
McKeon is also not likely to mention that the ARRA has directly benefited local government agencies and non profits during a terrible recession and massive state budget cuts. According to the Recovery.gov [Wayback copy, 17 February 2010] website, some $26 million has been distributed to local agencies and non profits including:
- $42,500 to the Santa Clarita Valley Boys and Girls Club
- $331,362 to the Santa Clarita Valley Committee on Aging
- $10.09 million to the City of Santa Clarita
- $8.9 million to the William S. Hart Union School District
- $353,780 to the Santa Clarita Community College District (COC)
- $140,000 for LARC Ranch
In addition, the Recovery.gov website says $630,351 in contract money has been awarded to local private firms, many of which are located in the Valencia Industrial Center.
Moreover, the stimulus act included nearly $300 billion in tax cuts for individuals and businesses [Wayback copy, 10 February 2010], something Republicans like McKeon always push as a solution to economic recession.
And it included the famous “Cash for Clunkers” program which was successful at driving auto sales locally so much so that Cheri Fleming of Valencia Acura [dead link: checked 12 November 2026; the Wayback Machine has no copy at this address] said, “Wow, we’re busy. We might be back in business.”
Has the ARRA worked as well as the Administration said it would? Obviously not. They sold it as a cure-all and they were either far too optimistic about its effects or they had vastly underestimated how deep the recession actually was.
But it’s undeniable that it has benefited local communities and softened the effect of the economic downturn. It has likely saved jobs in public agencies and non-profits and, as Vice President Biden said today, it’s not done yet as only half of the funds have been distributed.
All I’m asking for is a little honesty and nuance from Buck McKeon. We’re all in this recession together and it’s not over by a long shot. It sucks that AV Equipment is suffering through hard times, but just blaming the Democrats won’t solve the issue and it’s dishonest to claim that the stimulus has been a total failure.

Comments
94 · as published