Image not recoveredIMG_0709-1.jpg
Hello from Manhattan!
The crazy thing about Manhattan is that it works. Think about it. There are millions of people compressed on a tiny, elongated island living and working in really tall buildings. Millions of them.
Image not recoveredIMG_0743-1-213x300.jpg
In fact, there are some 8+ million people living in New York's five boroughs.Yet, it works.
Why?
Density! Yes. New Yorkers built up, rather than out like we did in Los Angeles. Facing physical constraints on the island of Manhattan, they decided to build skyscrapers rather than low-density industrial parks. They built apartments and condos rather than single family homes on a 10th of an acre of land.
Tonight I took a 10 mile round-trip subway ride in less than 20 minutes. Can anyone truthfully say the Newhall or Sepulveda pass works as reliably? I doubt it.
But here in New York, a long trip like that was a snap and only cost me $4 on the subway.
Image not recoveredIMG_0730-1-300x168.jpg
Clearly there are plusses and minuses to living in a place like New York City. And, to be honest, I miss the friendly people of the SCV, tree-lined McBean, motorists who are only a little bit rude (and not outright hostile) and nice, open green parks.But I've been in Manhattan for 24 hours now and I'm really glad I didn't rent a car. A car is a curse in a place like this, dooming the driver to look for parking spaces and committing him to a fight with traffic. In New York, you really don't need a car -or insurance, gasoline, and maintenance- and yet life is very livable. In Santa Clarita, the opposite is true. It's very difficult to conduct your daily affairs without a car in the SCV, and that's why we build ocean-sized parking lots and 55mph freeways masquerading as roads (Newhall Ranch).
And that's what the high density vs low density debate really boils down to: mobility. On the one hand, you sacrifice personal space and your timetable for the Metro by living in a high density place, or you pay through the teeth to enjoy personal freedom and fight everyone else's personal freedom in the form of traffic in a low density place like Santa Clarita.
Santa Clarita will never look like New York...of that much I am certain. But I hope it continues to offer some good alternatives to driving. We've already got the Metrolink, commuter bus service, some trails, and local transit, but it's not enough. We need more if we're going to survive a future in which gas prices are $4+ a gallon (if the 2008 gas price surge is any indication) and the population expands.
Check SCVTalk on Saturday when I'll be liveblogging John Stewart's and Stephen Colbert's rally in Washington DC!

Comments
24 · as published