ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

January 26, 2011 · Wayback capture · 3 flags

Strickland and the ‘Crash Tax’

[archived copy]Last year, Huntington Beach joined a handful of cities in imposing what has become known as a ‘crash tax.’ In short, it’s a fee levied to non-residents when they cause an accident in a given city. The tax is designed to offset the cost of emergency services, which are largely borne by residents.

Huntington Beach made news [Wayback copy, 29 May 2019] because the proposed tax was so exorbitant - up to $2,000 per incident – as to raise eyebrows.  Since then, a number of cities including Sacramento, have toyed with this idea (Huntington Beach also repealed the ordinance just 3 months later after recognizing the tourism impact).

Here’s the problem: the policy, if enacted en masse, exposes folks who commute to work or frequent destinations outside their area (read: SCV) to an increased risk of these fines.

Enter State Senator Tony Strickland.

He penned a largely overlooked Signal LTE [dead link: checked 12 November 2026. The archive holds a copy of this article; it is not yet published.] [Wayback copy, 14 December 2024] last weekend in support of his introduction of SB 49 [Wayback copy, 30 January 2011] late last year–legislation designed to outlaw city ‘crash tax’ ordinances. Mr. Strickland represents about 27% of Santa Clarita residents, portions of Ventura County and nearly all of Santa Barbara County.

The VeCo Star featured this quote from their report filed Monday [Wayback copy, 26 January 2011]:

“It’s nothing more than a double tax,” Strickland said, noting that local agencies are always eager to have out-of-towners visit or shop in their jurisdictions so that they can collect sales taxes and hotel bed taxes.

Strickland said such fees seem particularly onerous in suburban, commuter communities …. “In my district, most residents don’t work in the city they live in,” he said.

And a local TV station in Santa Barbara aired this report [Wayback copy, 29 January 2011] Tuesday:

While I wasn’t a fan of his failed “Tenther” attempt [archived copy] last year, this is a bill that makes a great deal of sense.

For one, assessing fault in accidents can be very difficult.  The practice would unfairly incentivize cities to place fault on non-residents. Then there’s the question of insurance – would this tax be covered by insurers? If so, wouldn’t that raise the cost of auto insurance?

And Mr. Strickland’s point above is well-taken: if we aligned all the costs with revenues incurred by citizens based on their residence, then sales tax oughtta get credited back too.

Let’s hope the bill gets a hearing soon.

Strickland and the ‘Crash Tax’

Comments

26 · as published
  1. JoeJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:00 am
    I have mixed thoughts on this. Part of me is okay with the crash tax. Commuting 40 miles for your job has a lot of direct costs (time, gas, car maintenance, etc) but there are also externalities that are imposed on society that the commuter doesn’t directly pay for (pollution, traffic congestion, wear and tear on roads, etc). I see this crash tax as a way of recovering some of those externalities. Overall I am against the crash tax, but I think it has some merit. Anything to get us away from this concept of bedroom communities (I work in the SCV, so I live in the SCV).
  2. navigatorJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:13 am
    Too bad Tony doesn’t author a bill outlawing the idiots that keep coming up with these crazy tax schemes.
  3. spineflower2January 26, 2011 at 9:19 am
    Adding a tax AFTER a community is designed is an unfair “rule change,” and only penalizes communters, not the idiot poiticians who created communities with mismatched business/housing… like Santa Clarita. The only time this makes sense is where it first started, in certain beach communities where 95% of the accidents are from careless and drinking tourists. But then the solution is a business tax on those businesses who draw the misbehaving tourists, not the residents who are not the root of the problem. If you look at the average housing prices and incomes and wages in the SCV, you would not want to impose a balance at this late stage by taxes. You would turn our communities into slums and halve the values of the homes almost overnight. Is that really what you want? Or maybe we should be sending city subsidies, not to low wage car dealerships, but into biotech, green energy, and other higher-paying industries. Balance it with the incentive, not a punishment on those already here.
  4. JoeJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:35 am
    The idea isn’t to penalize, but to match up costs with those who incur them. Put another way, just as we are subsidizing the low wage car dealerships by doing street beautification projects and lord knows what else, we are also subsidizing commuters by adding all of these additional lanes of traffic, having to put up with extra pollution, etc. Yeah, we should punish the politicians and the hack planners who thought bedroom communities were the greatest thing since sliced bread, but I am more focused on solutions out of this mess than handing out penalties. And maybe commuters need to realize the full cost of their decision? Not penalize them, but shift some of more of the cost of their life style on to them and away from the rest of society. I like the idea of investing in local higher-paying industries, regardless of if they are green or not. If the housing prices need to fall to match the incomes of those living and working here, I don’t understand why that would be such a bad thing for society at large and those wishing to relocate to the SCV to live AND work. The prices will come back up once higher paying jobs are here.
  5. spineflower2January 26, 2011 at 4:02 pm
    Adding the tax AFTER people move there is a penalty, plain and simple. You are trying to lock the barn after the horses are out. And letting the local equity of law-abiding property owners tumble because you think it is for the greater good is a recipe for class-action lawsuits making government buy out every resident! You will save nothing, and raise taxes to boot.
  6. Timothy Myers SRJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:49 am
    SP2: On the spectrum car dealerships are a relatively high wage enterprise (think mechanics and the sales side when they are actually selling cars). I find it more ironic that nearly 100% of car dealers are Republican and would probably tell you they are members of the Tea Party yet can’t wait to get in line to suck up every public subsidy on offer.
  7. hermanJanuary 26, 2011 at 11:29 am
    Heresay.
  8. Timothy Myers SRJanuary 27, 2011 at 10:57 am
    “Heresy?” “Hearsay?” or something that Frankenstein would say: Here say fire BAD!!!!
  9. hermanJanuary 28, 2011 at 7:30 am
    Deflection!
  10. Timothy Myers SRJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:40 am
    All so-called “user fees” are in essence double taxation. The citizenry kicks in money in the form of various taxes to cover the cost of fire protection, police, EMT etc. since we all benefit because their is someone there to take care of the problem. Then levying the charge on some citizen that actually deigns to use the service when required seems a bit disingenuous.
  11. JoeJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:45 am
    I don’t disagree. So maybe with every user fee tax we decrease general taxes (some combination of sales, income, property)? Taxes are not only designed to create revenue, but they are also designed to influence behavior. I am trying to argue we need to stop encouraging people to commute, which we are doing by having their costs covered by general taxes instead of user fees. Just throwing this out there. I am not sure I am completely sold on the ideas I am throwing out there, just trying to get a discourse going.
  12. Mr PerezJanuary 26, 2011 at 9:53 am
    So lets say a LA County Sheriff who doesn’t live in SCV but has to commute here for work gets into an accident while driving his personal vehicle to and fro. Are you saying it would be fair Joe, that he have to pay the fee if found at fault? In doing such you may scare off people who provide a service to a community, i.e. doctors who work out of several facilities. Just a thought.
  13. JoeJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:06 am
    I think it would be logical for someone who caused an accident and isn’t paying into the local tax base to pay an appropriate fee. I think there are different standards for fair/unfair and don’t find the term relevant when talking about tax policy. I am not supporting the use fee per se, but am supporting the concept of additional fees on commuters. People will continue to have a choice of commuting or of living and working in the same geographical area. All I am proposing is that commuter realize more of the cost of their decision. Doctors can move here and work here and Doctors that decide the extra cost of commuting isn’t worth it can instead practice in their own communities. It doesn’t make sense for society to bear these externalities when there is no benefits to society for this irrational behavior (made rational thanks to commuters not bearing the full cost).
  14. navigatorJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:25 am
    @Joe, I moved to the SCV in ’74 because it was an affordable alternative for a young couple looking to buy a house. Unfortunately, due to the fact that many of my clients are in LA, the SFV and points south and north, I couldn’t move my business to the SCV, as much as I wish I could have, without losing many clients. I would hate to be penalized for “taking care of business”.
  15. JoeJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:36 am
    When you pay for Internet for yours business (assuming you need it), do you consider it a penalty or a cost of doing business? Same would be true of cost shifting to commuters. This isn’t a penalty being imposed. And if the majority of your clients are in LA and the SFV, then maybe it would make more sense to locate yourself in the middle and reduce your average commute. However, it is a free market and if the cost is worth it, stay in the SCV. We have LESS of a free market when externalities aren’t properly charged back to the benefactors. And no, I am not saying do away with all public services, but we do need to start looking at is there a compelling case/benefit. I would argue there is not a compelling case/benefit to support commuters in the manner we currently are.
  16. SFC PerezJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:22 pm
    What definition do you use of “paying into the local tax base?” If I own a business here but reside in another city dont I still contribute to the locale with said business? And what about renters? They technically arent paying property taxes which fuel the salaries of the police and fire departments. And when an ambulance responds to transport you, they still do bill you as the individual so at what point do we discern true cost?
  17. Timothy Myers SRJanuary 27, 2011 at 9:26 am
    You think that landlords don’t price their rents to cover the cost of real estate taxes? Renters pay taxes through their rents.
  18. Mr PerezJanuary 29, 2011 at 11:39 am
    No, thats good and I agree but just wanted to establishment definition. Now if I rented a storefront business wouldnt that qualify said me under said definition since the property owner pays taxes?
  19. Mr PerezJanuary 29, 2011 at 10:02 pm
    -the initial “said”
  20. navigatorJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:00 am
    Look at it this way…. If I travel to Santa Ana for work (or San Fernando for that matter) and have an accident which requires fire/police/emt assistance I would be billed for that. If my counterpart comes from there to Valencia and incurs the same expenses he would be billed for it. Meanwhile we BOTH pay fees into our own areas for the exact same services. DOUBLE TAXATION! Eliminate those local costs from my taxes and I’ll be happy to pay for them elsewhere when required. What if I crash and use them in the SCV? No taxes, I’ll pay for them here as well. There is your solution. It won’t convince me to not commute but as long as I remain a safe driver it’ll lower my taxes.
  21. Timothy Myers SRJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:45 am
    The other “lie” about user fees is that it is very difficult (impossible) to isolate a marginal cost. If EMT’s, police and fire are not responding to an accident it is not like the municipality can “turn off” the costs associated with those public goods.
  22. JoeJanuary 26, 2011 at 10:59 am
    Yeah, that could be a real *itch. Instead of marginal you could do fractional, so if budget is $6million and on average you have 200,000 incidents a year, then $30 per qualifying incident. Another option is to do tolls on the major express ways. I don’t know how I feel about that. Another option is to look who is getting a W2 from your city and compare that with the home address. If it doesn’t match up you get charged a fee to make up for city services you consume but don’t pay for because you aren’t paying property tax in the city. Hmm…starting to have second thoughts about all of this now. Anyone out there agree with any of this?
  23. hermanJanuary 26, 2011 at 11:32 am
    Wouldn’t my insurance pay for it anyway?
  24. NickelDimeJanuary 26, 2011 at 11:53 am
    Not necessarily. And if they did, and if this started to become commonplace, you can bet premiums will rise accordingly. And you can can also bet the crash taxes would rise precipitously…
  25. hermanJanuary 26, 2011 at 5:06 pm
    I don’t can can, that’s a vicious rumor.
  26. mikecJanuary 27, 2011 at 11:08 am
    Insurance would cover the medical cost ie. ambulance but not the cost for police to come out and take the report. However, if you filed a lawsuit, your insurance company would come in looking to be reimbursed for it’s out of pocket costs if you either settled your case or obtained a judgment against the defendant.