American ideas about how to live and build communities have changed dramatically over time. For decades, families fled the dense urban grid for newer types of neighborhoods that felt safer, more private, even pastoral. Through their research, Garrick and colleague Wesley Marshall are now making the argument that we got it all wrong: Weve really been designing communities that make us drive more, make us less safe, keep us disconnected from one another, and that may even make us less healthy.
What's great about the SCV is that we have examples of both patterns. Newhall, which was built up before and during World War 2, is largely grid patterned, with straight streets intersecting others forming real city blocks. Parts of Canyon Country are like this too.
Valencia, built 30 years after World War 2 -and with the benefit of a new nearby highway & cheap gasoline- was constructed with meandering low-volume streets, cul-de-sacs, and huge artery roads designed to carry all the traffic.
The benefits of the former are pretty evident: it's easy to walk Newhall, it's easy to find your way around Newhall, things feel closer and traffic is relatively distributed among all the streets. Some of the drawbacks are that a home in Newhall might feel less private or secluded and your street is likely to have more traffic.
Valencia is attractive for different reasons. The street your house is on is almost private, with few people driving on it unless they are your neighbors. And because it's low traffic, the street becomes usable space to you and your family: I wonder how many kids of my generation got scrapes and bruises playing street hockey, basketball, or football in a cul-de-sac. But Valencia practically guarantees that you'll be dependent on cars: the street layout makes transit just about impossible, requiring you to hike a mile or more to the nearest bus stop. It also makes us dependent on gigantic arterials, like the superhighway that is Newhall Ranch Road. And finally, if any new developments come to your area, or a small neighborhood road is opened as a cut-through; watch out! Angry people will beat down the doors at City Hall.
All this dependency on cars and big streets makes us less safe as a whole compared to street grids:
A lot of people feel that they want to live in a cul-de-sac, they feel like its a safer place to be, Marshall says. The reality is yes, youre safer if you never leave your cul-de-sac. But if you actually move around town like a normal person, your town as a whole is much more dangerous.
Of course stuffy academics arguing about statistical likelihood of getting in a serious car accident isn't going to change consumer preference that much. That's why you see in renderings of Newhall Ranch, Newhall Land continues the same patterns it established in Valencia: winding, confusing streets that ensure privacy but make you dependent on cars. The irony is that we live in such communities to isolate ourselves from car traffic, but these communities make us more dependent on cars over all.
Hey, while we're questioning the underpinnings of American Suburbia, let's not let the color beige off without comment. Beige is not just the dominant color in men's closets in the SCV, it's also the dominant color of development. And Folks in Irvine -practically a twin of Valencia but much larger- are sick of it and have decided to challenge conformity [Wayback copy, 1 October 2011] and are even souring on big-box retail:
As desirable as Irvine is, it's safe to say the master-planned community isn't exactly known for avant-garde architecture, something that became clear earlier this year in reader responses to stories about the launching of a city motto contest.Yuck. Seriously why even bother with the fake windows on the "second" floor?Image not recoveredDSCN6843-300x225.jpg"Irvine: We Have 62 Different Words for Beige," one commenter suggested.
"Where Bland is in Demand," another offered.
"Sixteen Zip Codes, Six Floor Plans," a third said.
"Sorry, I Thought This Was My House," yet another reader replied.
You get the idea.
...
"Uninterrupted blank wall surfaces should be avoided along all building facades," the plans say, and design should discourage features that "hinder pedestrian activity, such as big box retail."
No dominant architectural style? No big box retailers? In Irvine?
I think this is one area where the SCV is actually ahead of the curve. As John Boston once wrote, in the SCV, you can visit Tuscany, a New England fishing village (Bridgeport) and the Old West (Newhall) all in one day! It can't be long now until we have some Asian-themed developments pop up.
But still, we could follow Irvine's lead at least insofar as our shopping centers are concerned. More developments like The Patios, less like Valencia Marketplace & Golden Valley shopping center, ok?

Comments
58 · as published