ArchiveSCV
SCV Talk · Archive
A decade of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015

April 18, 2012 · Wayback capture · 4 flags

The Follies of Patricia McKeon

Is it a good or bad thing when a candidate for high office says flat-out that she doesn’t know the answer to a voter’s question?

On the one hand, Patricia McKeon’s answer to a voter’s question last night about budgeting & initiatives shows remarkable honesty. It wasn’t just “I don’t know,” or even a Palin-esque, “I’ll check on that for you Katie and bring an answer right back to ya.” Rather it was, “I have no idea.” Utter, complete bewilderment. Like that’s what I would have said if someone asked me for my opinion on 17th century French literature.

An embedded YouTube video appeared here in the original post. View the original — embeds are preserved as links in this archive.

On the other hand, it was not a question about 17th Century French Literature. This was a soft-ball question, a gimmee. The voter wanted to know how Sacramento leaders will deal with the constant tug-of-war between what Californians want and what they are willing to pay for. This is a rich and juicy question, you can make of it whatever you want, really. Every two years, several propositions go on the ballot. Some are expensive. Many tie the legislator’s hands. And some we end up regretting. So how would Patricia McKeon, Assembly Member 38th District, handle such challenges in a state fallen from its former glory and scraping around for resources?

“I have no idea.”

Really? No idea? You couldn’t even toss in a “illegals are bankrupting us” or something about global warming being a fraud and AB32 or the bullet train initiative. Grocery bags, anyone? I mean come on, be creative!

Ouch.

But consider it could have been worse. As I saw Patricia’s confused look, I winced because I thought she might drift into Miss South Carolina 2007 territory, the pageant queen who should have said “I have no idea” rather than actually try to answer a question:

An embedded YouTube video appeared here in the original post. View the original — embeds are preserved as links in this archive.

Maybe her advisers, worried that Patricia might say something silly like that, just advised her to be honest. And so I find that somewhat refreshing.

What’s not refreshing at all, however, is the allegations fresh on Facebook last night that Patricia McKeon or her staff may have copied nearly verbatim from a State Senator’s website [Wayback copy, 9 April 2012] on the topic of pension reform. Check it out:

Image not recoveredmckeon-614x480.jpg

What is it with plagiarism in this town? Do we self-select for lazy half-wits, or what is it?

The Follies of Patricia McKeon

Comments

16 · as published
  1. KevitivityApril 18, 2012 at 1:17 pm
    She should have used Obama’s, “that question is above my pay grade” line.
  2. Buster BarnumApril 18, 2012 at 1:44 pm
    OMG this is too funny. I love it.
  3. LarMccApril 18, 2012 at 1:56 pm
    I am glad this was posted as it’s own item. I am just blown away that she could not formulate an answer.
  4. Timothy Myers SRApril 18, 2012 at 2:02 pm
    I don’t think she knew what the questioner was asking. Sad to say, it would probably also be news to Buck that initiatives have hamstrung the Cali budget process.
  5. Need for Involved CitizenryApril 18, 2012 at 2:06 pm
    Bond measures on ballot always sound great and exciting. Unfortunately, too many people do not connect the dots and realize that the bond repayments will come out of the state budget and without tax increases, other areas (like operating expenses for schools, roads and public safety) may get cut. I’m always amused at the Republican support or silence on bond measures while at the same time insisting on no new taxes. Pretty hard to have it both ways!
  6. Need for Involved CitizenryApril 18, 2012 at 2:20 pm
    And since Patricia has attached herself to the no new taxes bandwagon, she should have a very firm idea what will need to give to handle these bond payments. An “I don’t know” kind of answer just doesn’t cut it but the reality is that most of the other candidates only offer vague responses that in reality won’t come up with the money really needed. I’ve always wondered what percentage of the spending increases in California over the past 20 years can be attributed to bond repayments due to voter approved bond measures.
  7. NateApril 18, 2012 at 2:18 pm
    The color coded plagiarism chart brought great joy to my heart… Bravo #TeamWilk
  8. ToddApril 18, 2012 at 2:44 pm
    Our last candidate who was found to have plagiarized came in dead last in the city council election…. will the same hold true for assembly???
  9. SCV Republican SupporterApril 18, 2012 at 2:51 pm
    Someone should do some investigative look at this. I blieve that Emmerson has the same consultant as McKeon, who is also a consultant to Strickland. A connection? In regards to saying she doesn’t know, on one hand that is refreshing. However, not knowing that approve statewide GO Bonds have an impact on each year’s budget shows she is still not prepared to be our Assemblyperson. Back to school.
  10. David GaunyApril 18, 2012 at 4:09 pm
    Don’t forget that this woman is being coached by the Haueters who –either by choice or force– have definitely “self-selected for lazy half-wits” in this case. You’ll notice that the playbook doesn’t change much so plagiarism should be expected.
  11. Capt. GeneApril 18, 2012 at 4:59 pm
    Buck seems to be some sort of a blond dim-wit plagiarizer magnet!
  12. NateApril 18, 2012 at 9:14 pm
    He just believes we are stupid…
  13. kkorenthalApril 18, 2012 at 6:42 pm
    At some point they’ve got to realize that the train has already come into the station for Patricia and the destination is LOSERVILLE. We don’t want the kind of politics that McKeon and Haueter brought to this community.
  14. TroyApril 18, 2012 at 7:08 pm
    I’m beginning to see what Republican clubs have been so upset about. If this is how Buck’s team plays –taking loser candidates and force-feeding them to the masses– imagine how those who have fought for years to restore the party’s values must feel. This is everything I hate about politics and it’s right here in our own neighborhood…… coming from our own Congressman!
  15. scv RepublicanApril 18, 2012 at 8:16 pm
    Wait, now I’m no fan of the Mckeon clan, but what the post appears to say is that she’d support Senate Constitutional amendment 13, then details it. The language may be similar to Emmerson’s but they are also talking about the EXACT SAME plan. “I have no idea” is a pertinent thing to question a candidate over, but this is a bit of a stretch.
  16. MikeApril 18, 2012 at 8:59 pm
    These aren’t two people writing independently about the same plan, but one thing being written about a plan, then that thing being copied, modified slightly and put out under McKeon’s name, without attribution. The sentences follow in the same order and they share phrases that do not appear anywhere else on the whole Internet. Plagiarism, full stop. It’s quite similar to Lynn (Vakay) Hauteur’s piece that got her banned from the Signal and her archive of columns expunged from The Signal’s website. But I also find SCVRS’s guess equally as likely: the result of a common consultant who may also be the common author.