I hadn't planned on responding to articles by local Democrats in my monthly commentary. However, the blatant misrepresentation made by some of these fellow activists has riled me to the point of response.
I don't mind being made fun of by Tim Myers, and I don't mind someone honestly disagreeing with me. I do mind that my fellow Republicans and I are often accused of actions and motives that are just not true.
Case in point: Gary Horton, in this week's commentary for the Democrats ("Honestly, we're socialists in the SCV," Democratic Voices, March 18), attempts to make the case that we Republicans in SCV enjoy a socialized lifestyle full of great "socialized" services and yet we still decry our great socialized system of government in exchange for a more capitalistic way of doing things.
He attempts to use the military, police and schools as perfect examples of why we are "honestly socialist" and should be glad for it.
He suggest that we Republicans are clueless to the fact that we are "socialized to the core" and need to "open our eyes" to this wonderful reality. We need to stop complaining about the growth of government and just admit that we all benefit by and enjoy it.
Mr. Horton attempts to paint a dramatic picture of the average SCV conservative Republican hypocritically enjoying this socialist utopia. He attacks Mr. and Mrs. SCV Republican with, "... You drive your big SUV down our wide, landscaped roads, dropping kids off at our well-managed public schools." OK, OK - let's stop there!
First, I don't drive an SUV (although I do not begrudge those who do) and I do care about the environment.
Second, I, along with many SCV Republicans (and Democrats for that matter), do not drop my kid off at a "well-managed" public school. I drop my daughter off at a well-managed private school that costs a fraction of what I pay in school tax and delivers many times more in value.
Interestingly, when it comes to public schools, the term "well-managed" is unarguably an oxymoron.
I work in the public school system and I can tell you first hand that it is not well managed. This is not because the excellent and highly qualified teachers and administrators do not do their jobs well ... they do. It is because the government (and union, I might add) system hinders the application of good management.
For example, local schools recently reported their annual cost per student spending.
Are you ready for this?
Taxpayers are currently spending approximately $15,000 per Santa Clarita Valley student - let me say that again - $15,000 for one student. Someone might rightly deduce this amount of money could easily pay for two students in a private school. This is true. I currently pay $6,000 per year for my daughter to attend a private school where students consistently score (on average) in the 90th percentile on standardized tests.
This school does not send out pink slips every March that leave hundreds of employees wondering if they will have a job. It does not "cut" library, P.E., art, music or any other extracurricular activity. It does not overstaff or under-staff classrooms in order to meet some bureaucratic policy requirement. It does not tell highly qualified aides, who are needed full time and who want to work full time, that they can only work part time because of union demands.
No. This private school, like every other, operates from a purely capitalistic, free-market advantage. It operates within budget and efficiently allocates resources as necessary. It does not have to wait for the NEA or the teacher's union to give it permission to do so. Because it has the incentive to retain its "customers," it gives them exactly what they want. If they do not like it nor want it anymore, they are free to go elsewhere.
Some choose other private schools. Some choose the ever-growing home-school option. The point is - some choose!
Unlike socialism, which takes choice out of the hands of individuals and puts it in the hands of an elite few (government), capitalism promotes choice. It is the essence of a free society. It is the essence of liberty.
This belief in liberty and choice is what SCV Republicans believe in, Mr. Horton. It is what I believe in. And yes, it is also why I will continue to decry socialism and all of its bloated, bureaucratic and wasteful tendencies.
Lynn Vakay lives in Acton and is a Santa Clarita Valley school teacher and a member of the 38th Assembly District's Republican Central Committee. Her column reflects her own views and not necessarily those of The Signal. "Right Here, Right Now" appears Fridays in The Signal and rotates among local Republican writers.
