ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Democratic Voices

Carole Lutness: Is government really the problem?

Most Californians are aware that the reason we are experiencing this terrible state budget crisis is that Republican legislators vote in a block against any revenue increases. This is part of the national Americans for Tax Reform's campaign to "shrink government so small you can drown it in the bathtub," as proclaimed by the ATR's founder, Grover Norquest.

Judging from the last six budget cycles which have seen a $39 billion reduction in funding Health and Human Services, Republicans don't seem to care about the pain and suffering their actions are reaping upon the citizens of California.

You have to ask, just when is enough enough? When will the Republicans decide that our budget is small enough? When we totally dismantle public schools? When we have no nurses in public hospitals? When there are no DMV clerks to assist you to register your car? When there is no fireman or police to help you? When there are no services to keep your elderly mother at home instead of having to go to an expensive nursing home?

It seems that the only vision they have is a world without government. Yet, is government really the problem?

Government does what we, the people, want it to do; provide services that make our lives safer, more comfortable and orderly. Our collective quality of life is improved when we choose to collectively pay taxes which pay for the services we need or want.

We know when we pay for these services through our taxes they are delivered equitably, fairly and more cost efficiently and

effectively than when the private sector does them. We know when we pool our resources (taxes) for the common good we get a big bang for our buck.

Medicare is a great example of a government service that is both efficient and effective. Our elderly get complete, universal health care for a fraction of what people pay who have commercial health insurance.

Administration of Medicare is only 2 to 3 percent while administration of health insurance can be as high as 33 percent of the cost of your premium with a large part of that going into the corporate head's pockets.

Of course, it is widely recognized that our for-profit health insurance system is two to three times more expensive than any other system and is dead last in health care outcomes among the top six developed nations and ranks 37th when compared to all nations, right between Costa Rica and Slovenia.

And yet the American people are still falling for the giant corporate health insurance company's line that establishing a universal, single payer system such as Medicare for All is "socialism."

(Are you sufficiently terrified or should they rattle their sabers more with horror stories about Canadians having to wait for 20 years for some procedure or other?)

For the last 30 years the American public has been taught through a relentless barrage of corporate propaganda that "government is the problem."

Now because we are at a point of financial collapse, all of a sudden government is "in" again. But that hasn't stopped our Republican state Legislators to go about their mission of destroying state government. And our citizens are still falling for it.

On May 19 there will be a special election where the public will be asked to ratify a terrible budget deal that supposedly closes the $42 billion shortfall in this and next year's state budgets.

Among the six propositions, which are all odious except maybe 1F, is Proposition 1E, which will "borrow" about half a billion dollars over these next two budget cycles (2008-2009 and 2009-2010) from Proposition 63, the Mental Health Services ACT (MHSA) (2004), which taxes millionaire 1 percent of their taxable income above one million to provide mental health services.

You may remember that in the '70s then-Governor Reagan "deinstitutionalized," closing the mental hospitals and promising that the "money will follow."

The money never did follow and our local, county governments have hobbled on for nearly 40 years trying to pay for programs to help those with chronic mental illness.

They never could fund these services and that is why we have nearly 73,000 homeless, mostly mentally ill, people sleeping on our streets in Los Angeles every night.

MHSA funds are being used quite successfully in helping the chronically mentally ill stabilize and recover.

In Los Angeles County more than 39,000 chronically mentally ill people have been helped by the MHSA, but the need is greater.

Even with MHSA funds only 39 percent of the eligible mentally ill are being served.

In the Skid Row Homeless Mentally Ill program there has been an 83 percent decrease in homelessness and a 40 percent decrease in incarcerations for those treated in the MHSA program.

Also many former mental health clients have been helped to become peer advocates to work with the mentally ill ("If she was able to recover, I can too").

This raid on the MHSA funds is an example of being "penny wise and pound foolish" since cutting mental health services will result in an increase in costly hospitalizations and incarcerations ($74,000 a year to house someone in jail vs. $16,000 a year to provide the full range of mental health treatment).

The risk of more suicides and homicides increases in desperate times. People become desperate and need mental health services to help them not act out their desperation.

This is absolutely the worst time to be cutting mental health services. This is an issue of public safety.

The people spoke loudly in the November election that they did not want "business as usual." They want government to work for the people and not the super-rich and the corporations.

And yet that is what the Republicans always do. This crass ploy by the governor and the Republican legislators is cruel, manipulative and contrary to what the people want.

Many people's fear is that this "borrowing" from MHSA fund for general fund allocations is a slippery slope to dismantling a program that is proving to be so successful.

When is "enough enough?" Alas, I fear that only when the Republicans succeed in destroying government and leave us all to fend for ourselves will they and their corporate masters be happy.

That dog-eat-dog, survival-of-the-fittest world is not one I want to leave to our children and grandchildren.

Carole Lutness is a Valencia resident, a Democratic activist and chairwoman of Democratic Neighbors of the 38th Assembly District.

"Democratic Voices" appears Tuesdays in The Signal and rotates among local Democratic writers. Her column reflects her own views and not necessarily those of The Signal.

← Back to 2009

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
11296
System
/news/article/ pages
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,098 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
news_article:resizeabletext
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:local_contributor_marker [Democratic Voices; appears Tuesdays in The Signal]
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Valencia]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Carole Lutness]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0