Following hours of testimony, most of it in opposition, the Santa Clarita City Council voted shortly before midnight Tuesday to approve the controversial billboard proposal to locate three electronic billboards on Santa Clarita Valley freeways in exchange for taking down 62 billboards within city limits.
Council members Bob Kellar, Frank Ferry and Marsha McLean voted in favor of the proposal, while Councilman TimBen Boydston voted against it.
“Granted, in a perfect world, we’d get rid of 118 billboards and not put up a single thing on the freeway,” Kellar said. But the benefits of ridding areas of the city of old billboards outweighs the disadvantages of locating electronic billboards in more outlying areas, he said.
“The project is what it is,” Councilwoman Marsha McLean summed up the situation shortly before the vote. “You either think the pros outweigh the cons, or you don’t.”
As with the first and second times the plan came before the council, Mayor Laurene Weste recused herself and left the room on the advice of the city attorney. Weste owns property within 500 feet of one of the boards that would come down under the agreement.
More than 30 members of the public went before the council during the open comment period, many of them calling on council members to delay their vote until more of the public’s questions had been answered or until after the April 8 election.
Tuesday night’s vote was the council’s second and final on the proposal. None of the council members changed their votes from the ones they cast in the February council meeting, which also ran into the early morning hours the next day.
Two separate approvals from the council were required because the deal involved changes in city ordinances.
The plan to eliminate old, so-called static billboards in the central city in exchange for locating three electronic billboards on Santa Clarita Valley freeways was presented to the city by the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transit Authority, which owns the railroad right-of-way through the city where most of the old-style billboards are located.
Metro negotiated an agreement with the city whereby 62 static billboards along Railroad Avenue and Soledad Canyon Road would come down in exchange for locating three double-sided electronic billboards on Highway 14 and Interstate 5.
The city would gain some $400,000 to $600,000 a year in revenue from the deal. Currently, Ferry noted, “We don’t get a penny” from existing billboards.
Metro’s proposal dovetailed nicely with a long-standing city plan to rid the area of old billboards, which it considers blight.
The deal offered a great opportunity, Ferry said.
The extra $400,000 to $600,000 a year, he said, “that’s future lit soccer fields. That’s hundreds of hot senior meals.”
“You can’t run city government if you’re not looking to ways to make money.”
“People take a vote on a referendum?” Ferry said of a Boydston suggestion that the issue be put to a vote.
“That’s how California got screwed up.”
The public should trust the leaders it elects to lead, he said, citing a time in the early ‘90s when a group of residents opposed construction of the cross-valley connector.
The council acted on their opposition, but later the road had to be finished at a much higher cost, he said.
