As part of a settlement announced Thursday, the Santa Clarita Community College District has agreed to offer cumulative voting for board of trustees elections, pay $850,000 in plaintiffs’ legal fees and take several measures to address allegations that its voting system violates Latino voters rights.
Malibu law firm Shenkman and Hughes sued the college district last summer on behalf of local voters Jim Soliz and Rosemary Sanchez-Fraser, alleging the at-large voting methods, whereby voters can cast ballots for every seat up for election in a given year, violates the California Voting Rights Act by preventing Latino voters from electing candidates of their choice.
The firm also sued the city of Santa Clarita and the Sulphur Springs School District last year over their at-large election systems, also claiming that their voting methods violated the California Voting Rights Act. Earlier this year, Santa Clarita and Sulphur Springs School District announced settlements in their cases.
On Thursday, Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees President Michele Jenkins called the agreement fair.
“This is a fair settlement that addresses the concerns of Mr. Soliz and Ms. Sanchez-Fraser and promotes greater participation in Santa Clarita Community College District Board of Trustees elections,” Jenkins said in a joint statement announcing the agreement. “The board should be commended for their decision to work towards this resolution.”
“We are pleased that the Santa Clarita Community College District chose to resolve this matter in a way that brings the community together and allows minority voters to gain a voice in the governance of their community college,” attorney R. Rex Parris, also a party in the lawsuit, said in the statement. “The board should be commended for their decision to work towards this resolution.”
Along with paying $850,000 in the plaintiffs’ attorney fees, the district agreed to implement a cumulative voting system and to move its elections for trustees to November. In cumulative voting, voters in an election where more than one seat is on the ballot can cast multiple votes for a preferred candidate.
For example, if three seats were up for election, a voter could cast as many as three ballots for a single candidate. By concentrating their votes this way, minority voters increase their chances for obtaining representation.
As part of the settlement the district, which operates two campuses of College of the Canyons, also will pay for candidates’ Spanish-language ballot statements whenever English candidate statements are included on ballots; conduct campus voter registration drives “and take steps to facilitate” vote-by-mail balloting; and host candidate forms. In addition, the board will recommend that the district hold district-based elections following the next U.S. Census, if a district with a majority of Latinos can be drawn.
In the two previous settlement agreements reached with the Sulphur Springs district and the city, the school district agreed to conduct its elections by district, rather than at large, while the city agreed to hold its council elections in November and also to consider implementing cumulative voting.
Terms of the settlement with the college district were approved by a unanimous vote of the district’s board of trustees at a special meeting Wednesday but were not announced until Thursday evening, when the two sides issued their joint statement.
The agreement will be reduced to a stipulated judgment to be filed in court with Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf M. Treu, who will maintain jurisdiction to monitor implementation of the settlement terms, the statement said.
Indications that a settlement in the case was near came earlier this month, when attorney Margarette Leon, representing College of the Canyons and the district, told Treu that the COC Board of Trustees authorized her to proceed with a settlement.
The settlement process hit a temporary snag, however, when Leon requested the college chancellor be present at the proceedings.
