The law firm that sued three Santa Clarita Valley government agencies over their election systems has threatened to also sue four local school districts unless they change their at-large balloting systems.
The letters urging board members to discuss ways of making voter representation fairer for Hispanics and avoid running afoul of the California Voting Rights Act were sent to representatives of the William S. Hart Union High School District and the Newhall, Saugus Union and Castaic Union elementary school districts.
Sent Saturday according to attorney Kevin Shenkman and received late Wednesday according to two district officials, the letters urge school district representatives to discuss a move toward district-based elections for their respective governing boards, rather than at-large elections.
At-large elections, favored by nearly all Santa Clarita Valley municipalities, allow all voters who live within a government agency’s boundaries to cast ballots for all seats that are up for election.
By-district elections allow voters to cast ballots only for one seat — the one representing the area of the agency in which they live.
A copy of the letter sent to the Hart district and obtained Thursday by The Signal contains allegations that the Hart district’s at-large system “dilutes the ability of minority residents — particularly Latinos — to elect candidates of their choice or otherwise influence the outcome” of board elections.
The Malibu-based law firm Shenkman & Hughes previously filed lawsuits against the city of Santa Clarita, the Santa Clarita Community College District and Sulphur Springs School District alleging violations of the California Voting Rights Act.
Settlements have been worked out with all three, although only one — Sulphur Springs — agreed to switch to by-district elections.
“Given the racially polarized elections in the (Willliam S. Hart Union High School District), we again urge WHSD to voluntarily change its at-large system of electing board members,” the letter reads. “Otherwise, on behalf of residents within the jurisdiction, we will be forced to seek judicial relief.”
At Wednesday night’s Hart district board meeting, members of the board announced they will consider moving to a by-district election system. The Hart school district is the Santa Clarita Valley’s largest.
‘Ruin community’
“Given that the lawsuits have become more frequent, we didn’t want to risk taxpayer money and our students’ educational funds for the purpose of legal fees,” said district board President Steve Sturgeon.
Sturgeon said he thinks voters benefit more when they can vote for each seat on a board.
“I think it’s much more beneficial to be able to vote across the valley for any and all board members running for election because they’re all going to represent all of the kids in the district,” Sturgeon said.
Another board member, Joe Messina, said he has concerns about subdividing the Hart district into separate voting districts.
“According to the law, the letter of the law, the only way to find safe harbor, if you will, is to go to districts,” Messina said. “So now we’re looking at going to districts and what that really would do.
“I think that will ruin this community,” Messina said. “It’ll make it exponentially harder in the education world.”
Do the right thing
The Saugus Union School District received its letter from Shenkman & Hughes late Wednesday afternoon, said board President Paul De La Cerda.
“We have not met as a board yet,” he said Thursday. “I’ll be speaking to the superintendent about it.”
De La Cerda said he will try to schedule a meeting of the district board in “a day or so” to discuss the law firm’s request.
A spokeswoman for the Newhall School District said all four districts received the California Voting Rights Act letters Wednesday, including Newhall.
Shenkman said earlier this week he remains “cautiously optimistic” the four Santa Clarita Valley school districts will “do the right thing.”
“I can confirm that I sent the letters out on Saturday,” he said. “My hope is that they will act on it.
“If these school districts do the right thing, great.”
If the districts do nothing, civil action initiated by Shenkman’s law firm will be considered, the attorney said.
Palmdale case
Shenkman cited his firm’s Voting Right Act lawsuit against the city of Palmdale, which lost its battle to hang on to at-large elections in Superior Court and appealed the decision.
Late last month, the 2nd District Court of Appeal rejected Palmdale’s assertion it is not subject to the California Voting Rights Act.
“Legal council led them down the wrong path,” Shenkman said. “It ended up being a waste of their time.”
The Shenkman & Hughes suits filed in the Santa Clarita Valley and against Palmdale all allege at-large election systems prevent Latino voters from electing candidates of their choice and that such systems violate the 2001 California Voting Rights Act.
The suits filed in the Santa Clarita Valley were on behalf of two local residents named as plaintiffs.
