LOS ANGELES — A Los Angeles Superior Court judge cleared the way Monday for cumulative voting — the practice of casting more than one ballot for a single candidate — to be employed in Santa Clarita City Council elections.
Judge Terry A. Green upheld the terms of a settlement agreement between the city and plaintiffs over a lawsuit alleging the city violated the California Voting Rights Act. Cumulative voting is one condition of the settlement.
Under that voting method, voters can cast multiple ballots for a single candidate. In elections for the five-member Santa Clarita City Council, voters could vote twice for a single candidate during years when two seats are up for grabs, and three times for a single candidate during years when three seats are being decided.
Though largely unknown in California, cumulative voting has been used in other states to settle lawsuits alleging violations of the federal Voting Rights Act.
The suit against Santa Clarita and two other local agencies claimed their election systems dilute the Latino vote. Santa Clarita officials proposed cumulative voting among a series of changes to avoid being forced into dividing into districts.
Both the city and the law firm that filed the lawsuit against it sought confirmation from the courts that cumulative voting would be a legal way to settle the lawsuit.
Arguments presented at Monday’s hearing largely hinged, not on whether cumulative voting itself was legal, but whether it could be legally adopted in this case in Santa Clarita.
Attorney Brian A. Pierik, representing the city, argued that, as a general law city, Santa Clarita is limited by state codes when it comes to its election system.
“The state is pervasive and all-consuming when it comes to elections, and we can’t do anything unless they say we can,” he said.
The plaintiff’s attorney, Kevin Shenkman of the Malibu-based firm Shenkman & Hughes, argued that such a system could be adopted in Santa Clarita, reasoning that it would be just a variation of the current voting system.
Shenkman’s firm is the one that filed the suit against Santa Clarita, along with two other local agencies: the Santa Clarita Community College District and Sulphur Spring School District.
In the end, Green ruled to uphold the terms of the settlement agreement.
“I clearly think that cumulative voting is legal,” he said Monday.
Another condition of the settlement agreement calls for Santa Clarita to change the dates of its City Council elections from April to November.
Santa Clarita was one of three local agencies sued last summer in suits claiming at-large voting systems — whereby voters can cast ballots for all open seats in an election — prevented Latinos from electing a candidate of their choice.
The Santa Clarita Community College District also entered into a settlement agreement that includes a move to cumulative voting and changing its election dates.
Sulphur Springs School District settled by agreeing to move to by-district elections, which was favored by plaintiffs.
Since at-large elections are conducted by nearly every public agency in the Santa Clarita Valley, other districts have prepared to adopt lawsuit-avoiding tactics.
Board members in the William S. Hart Union High School District signed off on a move to district-based elections, doing so before it was hit with a lawsuit.
Also ahead of a possible lawsuit, members of the Newhall School District board voted earlier this year to adopt cumulative voting — if doing so was deemed legal.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
