ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· signalscv.com, Wayback capture

Democratic Voices

Charlie Vignola: Putting the blame on government

On Facebook last week, I happened upon a post in the SCV Forum that triggered a lively debate over the “threat” big government poses to American business.

A local conservative argued that big government is mainly responsible for lagging wages, anemic job growth and the slow recovery.

He also defended “supply side economics,” that dubious theory popularized by right-wing “economist” Arthur Laffer, who convinced Reagan that cutting taxes on rich people would promote broad-based economic prosperity and create jobs.

I couldn’t help jumping in. “Exactly how is ‘big government’ to blame for stagnating wages?” I asked.

After all, wages — except for the minimum wage — are set by the much-vaunted job creators through the divine and infallible free market.

Besides, everyone knows about the other big factors that have affected wages, namely globalization, tech-driven productivity gains and the weakening of unions.

But here’s the dirty little secret: These are little more than excuses used by big business to keep wages low. You see, it’s not that American corporations are suffering and having to tighten their belts; they are awash in capital, with the biggest profits, stock market and GDP ever.

So it’s not that there’s no money around. In fact, the country has never had more money.

Then why do wages suck? Because business owners are keeping more of the money and sharing less of it with their workers than at any time since the Gilded Age.

Why are they doing this? Because it’s legal and they can.

Moving on: why do I think Arthur Laffer’s supply side theories are wrong? Easy: because the post-World War II economic expansion — still unrivaled in U.S. history, an extended period when household income and savings were going up and a family could get by with only one breadwinner — occurred when top marginal tax rates where sky high relative to today.

There was a 91 percent top tax rate during the storied Eisenhower era that all of the conservatives long to return to, at least socially.

So when did the rising wages and single breadwinner households start trending downward in a spiral that they have yet to recover from?

Oh, around the early 1980s, which just happens to coincide with when Reaganomics took hold, thanks to Laffer’s snake-oil salesmanship of supply side economics.

So what happened after that? Lots of job creation, right? Also lots of national debt.

Under Reagan, national debt exploded from $930 billion to $2.7 trillion. Imagine if Obama was allowed to triple the national debt and use that to pump up his job creation numbers. The current economy would look pretty astounding, too, wouldn’t you say?

Reagan boldly slashed top marginal tax rates from 70 percent to 28 percent, but even he quickly realized Laffer’s forecasts didn’t match up with reality, so he had to raise taxes at least five times just to keep the national debt from only tripling.

Four years after Reagan, Bill Clinton came into office, and he did the unthinkable: he raised top marginal tax rates.

“We’re doomed! The economy will crash!” keened the Republicans, knowing that supply side doctrine was the truth and the light.

Except somehow the economy did the exact opposite of crashing, vexing supply-siders and flummoxing Laffer: 22.9 million jobs created under Clinton’s progressive economic policies vs. 16.1 million jobs under Reagan’s supply side “miracle.”

Oh, and the national debt under Clinton? Only went up 35.6 percent, whereas it shot up 188.6 percent under Reagan.

Well, Republicans knew that had to be a fluke, so when Bush Jr. squeaked into office, they decided to give supply side another spin — and guess what? The economy crashed.

Job creation under Bush? Disastrous. Only 1 million jobs total over eight years.

National debt? It nearly doubled, from $5.6 trillion to $10.7 trillion. So much for supply side tax cuts paying for themselves.

And the icing on the cake: when Bush left office, his feckless fiscal policies left the entire U.S. economy teetering on the brink of depression, our whole banking system about to collapse.

After Bush renders the Republican brand radioactive, Obama takes office and is faced with the miserable task of putting Humpty Dumpty back together again.

And what does he do as soon as he has the political leverage? Yep: turns his back on supply side and raises top marginal tax rates again.

“You can’t raise taxes in the middle of a recession! The economy is doomed!” shrieked Republicans. So what’s happened in the two years since Obama raised taxes?

Let’s see. Tax revenues went up 9 percent, the deficit was cut in half, and job creation? 2.3 million jobs created in 2013, and 2014 has seen the fastest rate of job growth since 1998 with more than 2.5 million jobs created thus far this year.

So for the Republicans who ask with a straight face why I believe that Arthur Laffer’s supply side theories are crackpot? Because I can follow the historical consequences of tax policy and draw obvious correlations without being blinded by ideology, that’s why.

Charlie Vignola is a former college Republican turned liberal Democrat. He lives in Fair Oaks Ranch, works in the motion picture industry and loves his wife and kids.

← Back to 2014

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
128039
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
signalscv.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 867 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • page:ad_target_section_33
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/2 mentions: SCV, Fair Oaks Ranch]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Charlie Vignola]
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [3 hits]
Scores
local 7, national 1