I am very torn by the current scandals rocking the National Football League. Besides the incredibly stupid rules change that makes every kickoff go out the back of the end zone, the behavior of several players has badly tarnished the NFL’s reputation.
Let me preface what follows by saying that I do not support domestic violence or child abuse in any way, shape, or form. Perpetrators must be swiftly and severely dealt with.
But it got me thinking. The NFL has taken an immense amount of grief for recent decisions regarding player discipline.
For example, Ray Rice was given a mere two-game suspension before the video tape of his elevator assault on his fiancee became public.
If this two-game suspension was reflective of how serious the NFL views domestic violence, this is disturbing indeed.
Let’s think of this a bit differently. Is there a reason that the NFL feels a need to “discipline” players? If Rice were a plumber, would his boss at ACME Plumbing Company suspend him from fixing pipes for the same offense?
What if he was an accountant? If he was an accountant who decked a woman, would that disqualify him from totaling a balance sheet?
My guess is, no.
The penalty that Rice pays should reside in the hands of criminal and civil penalties that our system should fairly administer.
But does it? Is that why the NFL feels a need to be involved in these matters?
Reports from organizations such as ESPN are now beginning to surface that Ravens management may have conducted a “public and private campaign” involving the judicial system in Atlantic County and the NFL corporate office to influence the outcome of Rice’s situation.
Is this really a disturbing revelation? Or is this simply a continuation of the culture of favoritism and tacit acceptance of poor behavior that seems to infect athletic activities at all levels?
I think we all realize that high school, college, and professional athletes often live by a different set of standards that foster incrementally worse behavior in some individuals.
Rice’s problem may be the last in a long history that was created by a lack of accountability for his transgressions.
The NFL is clearly part of this permissive culture. However, the NFL has more of a public relations problem than anything.
Unlike ACME Plumbing, the NFL is dependent upon public opinion to draw and retain customers/fans.
This may explain why the NFL needs to apply discipline “above and beyond” the typical criminal and civil sanctions that may come a player’s way. If the NFL appears to condone such behavior, much revenue can be lost.
But what about Adrian Peterson? Peterson was recently accused of disciplining his 4-year-old son so severely that he left welts and wounds upon the child’s body. He has been suspended indefinitely and his career may be over.
However, there are other factors to consider here. In Southern culture, the concept of a “whooping” using a switch from a tree is deeply ingrained. It is considered a standard and accepted form of child discipline.
Clearly, Peterson went too far. An extremely powerful professional football player must control his physical strength when dealing with a small child.
Once again, is this a matter for the NFL? What makes the NFL an expert on child abuse? Shouldn’t the authorities assess the situation, determine the crimes committed and act accordingly?
If Peterson is convicted of a crime (and I believe he has committed one), he should be placed in jail to serve whatever penalty is called for in this situation.
Back to the PR problem. If Peterson plays for the Vikings, many will view the NFL as being “soft” on an abuser of children. Some may even cancel their season tickets and refuse to buy NFL merchandise.
To the Vikings credit, the team suspended Peterson immediately. However, probably realizing that it would not win another game without him, it reinstated him the following week.
After a huge public outcry, the team suspended him indefinitely.
How will the NFL handle these cases in the future? There appear to be two separate approaches.
The first is to simply allow appropriate sanctions to occur through normal criminal and civil channels. The other is to evolve the NFL into some sort of agency that has expertise in domestic violence and abuse.
It appears that Commissioner Goddell has chosen the later. Time will tell if this is an effective approach.
Steve Lunetta is a resident of Placerita Canyon and an ardent Cowboy fan. He can be reached at [email protected].
