A group of 7-Eleven franchise owners in California filed suit against the convenience store chain alleging the company is targeting franchise owners who are South Asian immigrants with the intent of taking their stores away to re-sell the franchises at higher rates. The practice, claims The Franchise Owner’s Association of Greater Los Angeles, amounts to racial discrimination and civil rights violations.
Among the complaints, FOAGLA says the Dallas-based company, which is owned by Seven & Holding Co. in Tokyo, employs aggressive, intrusive “asset protection,” or anti-theft or loss prevention, programs and harasses franchise owners with a number of policies and controls that essentially relegates the franchise owners to the status of an employee, not an independent contractor.
FOAGLA points to an example in the complaint of the Patels accused of coupon fraud at their Riverside store when in the past, 7-Eleven managers had encouraged the Patels to use coupons liberally and give free merchandise to children in a nearby elementary school for getting good grades. The family says it was harassed and threatened until they agreed to terminate their franchise agreement.
The L.A. franchise association filed its complaint against the chain along with 12 of the 13 franchise associations located in the California, said Jas Dhillon, vice president of FOAGLA. Combined the groups say they represent 1,200 members.
“The control they exert over these stores is unbelievable,” Dhillon said, who also owns three 7-Eleven stores in the San Fernando Valley.
The group, which recently formed to represent the business interests of the franchise owners, says that 7-Eleven franchise owners do not even have control over the air conditioning or heat in their stores, they cannot control the volume on their televisions, and that all bookkeeping is handled by the chain – members cannot even withdraw money without 7-Eleven’s approval.
“I don’t even have a checkbook in my store, all of the money goes to a Bank of America account,” Dhillon said. “I have to request money to cover expenses like a business lunch.”
The chain also owns all of the equipment in the store, and the franchise owner is responsible for paying for maintenance but isn’t allowed to contract separately with a maintenance company, he said. Owners have to use 7-Eleven’s maintenance company but don’t have access to the maintenance agreement. As equipment ages, the costs become unbearable at times, he said.
The chain’s spokesperson points out that while franchise owners are responsible for maintenance costs, 7-Eleven bought and installed all of the equipment for the owners when they purchased a franchise. Franchise fees range between $50,000 to $750,000 depending on the region or gross profit of a previously operating franchise.
As for FOAGLA’s assertion that the chain targets owners who are mostly of Indian and Pakistani descent, Dhillon said the chain uses its surveillance systems to go after franchise owners.
“If your employee is not ringing up an item, instead of coming and telling me they’ll just watch for months and then they tell the owner ‘you’re in breach of the contract’ and terminate the franchise,” he said.
The surveillance system in the 7-Eleven stores used to be closed circuit, said John Ragsdale of Santa Clarita. At one time he oversaw installation of the loss prevention systems and they were originally intended to record and alert the police in the event of a robbery. Later interactive functionality was added so that the franchise owner could monitor the store from a home computer. But that all changed 180 degrees as he retired from the chain nearly 9 years ago, he said.
“If they had a theft problem in the store, we would help the franchise owner. We didn’t just go in and arbitrarily investigate the stores for theft problems,” Ragsdale said. “If it was clear that the franchisee was embezzling from the company, only then would we would help investigate.”
The convenience store chain has since hired more theft protection people than any other company in the industry, Dhillon said.
In a separate instance last year, long time Santa Clarita resident and 7-Eleven franchise owner Danny Manalastas lost the store that he bought into in 1986 when the chain said his store was not as profitable as the others in the area. And so, after 27 years operating a 7-11 store that helped put his children through college – one of which is a local school teacher – 7-11 did not renew the lease for his Valencia Blvd. store.
Unlike franchise owners filing the complaint, however, 7-Eleven offered Manalastas the opportunity to re-open a store anywhere in the world and to cover his franchise fee. He and his wife moved to Texas and reportedly opened two more 7-11 stores.
“I talked to his brother-in-law and he said Danny was able to franchise two stores, ran them for a while and then retired,” Ragsdale said.
As for the assertions made by the current group of claimants, however, 7-Eleven claims the allegations of harassment are false. The company points to being named as one of the Top 50 Franchises for Minorities in 2013 by USA Today, and has received recognition as one of the top franchisee opportunities by Professional Women’s Magazine, Hispanic Network Magazine and Black EOE Journal.
“The company has a very high retention rate for franchisees. In 2013, 7-Eleven Inc. had a less than 4 percent franchisee turnover rate nationwide. Contested terminations are rare, in fact, we currently are in litigation with less than 1 percent of our franchisees,” said a spokesperson for the company.
Saying “good, hardworking, independent franchisees are the backbone of the 7-Eleven brand,” the chain also says a few of the franchisees have been caught violating the law or the franchise agreement, the company said.
“This complaint is brought by a small number of individuals who are attempting to thwart 7-Eleven’s efforts to deal with these franchisees. The company has a solid record of prevailing in court on these matters because of its thorough investigations,” the spokesperson said.
As for allegations that 7-Eleven is overly controlling of its franchise owners, the company said it has a brand to protect and that protecting the reputation of the chain protects the value for every customer and every franchisee down the road.
Franchise ownership in 7-Eleven is a 50-50 partnership, said the spokesperson for the company. The company splits the profit with the franchisee and the benefit is that the store owner and customers all benefit from the lower rates the company secures for products sold.
“A franchisee buys a turnkey business, a fully operational store from day one without any of the hassles of getting started, and 7‑Eleven bears the costs of real estate and build-out. Our gross profit split model puts our interests in line with our franchisees, so our goal is to keep our franchisees' business moving forward. "
