Why didn’t the city attorney do as he said he would and tell the public the truth about the billboard deal on the November ballot?
The ballot statement on Measure S starts with an untruth, and the people need to ask why the city attorney has chosen to be misleading.
Ballot statements are required by state law to be true and impartial. But the proponents who want to build three double-sided giant digital billboards in Santa Clarita say that Measure S will remove 118 billboard faces on 62 structures.
That is not true. Right after the Santa Clarita City Council voted three to one to do a bad deal for removal of 62 billboard structures inside the city, we voted four to zero to pay Edwards Outdoor Advertising $1.3 million to remove 47 of its billboard structures. Twenty-two of those were among the 62 we had just voted to remove.
This left only 40 billboard structures, with 80 billboard faces, to be taken down as part of the digital billboard deal, making the initial bad deal even worse.
The City Council should have stopped right there and gone back to re-negotiate the deal; after all, we were getting 35 percent less boards taken down by Metro, but not getting anything more in return.
That would be like a business person considering a contract to pay $3,000 to have three dead trees removed, but before signing the contract, paying someone else $1,000 to take down one of the trees.
Would the business person then proceed to pay $3,000 to take down only two trees? It would make no sense to move forward with that deal.
But the council voted to move forward anyway and put the even lousier deal for 40 billboard structures on the ballot.
The least we could have done was to be straight with the people, told them what happened, and what deal they would actually be voting on. That did not happen.
At the June 24 City Council meeting, we were deciding if the ballot statement should say 62 structures or 40 structures, or not list the number at all, when City Attorney Joe Montes stated: “I think you’re better to delete the number.”
The majority of the council did not take that advice. Why?
Perhaps it was because they thought the Montes would do what he said he would do and clarify the actual number when he wrote the impartial analysis for the ballot materials.
Here is what the city attorney told the council; “Now all of the issues that you are talking about will have to be included in the impartial analysis that will be in the ballot materials.
“The fact that the agreement talks about 62, the City Council subsequently entered into an agreement with Edwards so 22 of them will be removed if Edwards performs, that’s all going to have to be in there because the impartial analysis has to talk about the effect of the ordinance on existing law and what the status of things are.
“You have to talk about what the ordinance is going to do, and so that will be in the impartial analysis.”
In reading the “impartial analysis,” you will see that he does not write about the Edwards deal or its impact at all.
Council members should be able to rely upon the city attorney for advice as they make their decisions, and the taxpayers of Santa Clarita who are paying for the work should get the whole story in their ballot materials.
We didn’t, and the question is why?
The only remedy is to vote “no” on Measure S and send this terrible deal back to the drawing board.
TimBen Boydston is a Santa Clarita resident and a member of the Santa Clarita City Council.
