Santa Clarita Valley voters who cast ballots in the November election will have a chance to choose a successor for the man who has represented the 25th Congressional District for more than 20 years.
The choice is between two Republicans to replace outgoing Republican Howard “Buck” McKeon.
But while candidate Steve Knight, a sitting state senator and former Assembly member, and candidate Tony Strickland, a former state senator and former Assembly member, may appear too similar to make the choice meaningful, we believe each would take to Washington a different focus and a different set of priorities.
First, to their backgrounds. Knight is the son of a test pilot and an Army veteran himself. He served with the Los Angeles Police Department and on the Palmdale City Council before being elected to the state Assembly in 2008.
He lives in the Antelope Valley and within the 25th Congressional District, and his Senate district takes in much of the Santa Clarita Valley. Since being elected to the Senate two years ago, he has made frequent appearances at local events, talking to people and absorbing local issues.
Strickland is the son of an Army veteran but did not serve in the military. After college he went to work in politics and served as chief of staff to then-Assemblyman Tom McClintock before being elected to the Assembly in 1998.
He has run for and won — and occasionally run for and lost — public office in mostly coastal and near-coastal communities in Ventura County, as well as one bid for statewide office, which he did not win. His Senate district included a slice of western Santa Clarita Valley, but he was not much seen around the SCV until he announced his candidacy for the 25th District.
Strickland does not live within the 25th Congressional District and is not required to under federal law. His last bid for public office was a 2012 campaign for the 26th Congressional District in Ventura County, which he lost to Julia Brownley.
Both candidates have records of accomplishment in the state Legislature. Knight pushed the passage of bills establishing tax credits to get aerospace manufacturers to operate in California. He was also co-author on successful measures enticing film studios to do business in the state, bringing businesses and jobs back to California.
Strickland, while a legislator in the late ‘90s and last decade, pushed a state spending cap and pension reform. He made a name for himself in 2001 when he filed a lawsuit against then-Gov. Gray Davis on behalf of energy ratepayers, forcing Davis to reveal expensive energy contracts the state had negotiated with companies like Enron.
Neither man has a leg up in terms of experience at the federal level.
So what’s the difference?
Unlike Strickland, Knight is not a career politician. We don’t believe the next political campaign would constantly be on his mind. We like his unassuming but learned approach to issues and governing.
He is passionate about governing, less so about campaigning — and we believe that is a good thing.
Knight is a realist and pragmatist. He doesn’t like Obamacare but believes its repeal is unlikely — impossible in the near future. He’s willing to work within the framework of Obamacare to make it better.
Strickland, on the other hand, embraces the party line: Repeal Obamacare at any price. Whether voters see the stance as praise-worthy idealism or stubborn stupidity, most recognize it simply isn’t going to happen.
Health care experts say that train has left the station. We like Knight’s willingness to work with reality over Strickland’s party-line allegiance.
Similar independent-thinker vs. party-line stances can be seen in Knight’s and Strickland’s positions on illegal immigration and other issues.
We believe Knight would take an issue-by-issue approach to his work in Washington and be less strident on his party-line approach than Strickland.
There are enough immovable hard-liners in our nation’s capital in either party right now.
Under the circumstances, we believe Santa Clarita Valley residents would be better served with a congressman who is pragmatic and willing to talk, rather than another representative with a career commitment to toe the party line regardless.
Vote for Steve Knight for Congress.
