ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· signalscv.com, Wayback capture

Life without plastic bags

Signal readers address the issue of banning single-use plastic bags

When our story about Gov. Jerry Brown signing the plastic bag ban went up on The Signal’s website, poster “stevehw” raised the question “Is living without plastic bags such a burden?”

That touched off a discussion among our readers about adjustments required by the law.

My own experience spurning the single-use plastic bag was driven more by pragmatism than environmentalism.

About four years ago I moved from a three-bedroom place in Canyon Country to a compact condo in Valencia. The condo complex prides itself on its garden-like setting, with underground parking (stairs to climb) and meandering walkways to front doors among buildings set at different elevations (more stairs) to increase privacy. No ugly driveways outside the front door — hence no easy way to unload groceries.

After the first bag of plastic-clad groceries burst on the meander, scattering my groceries all over the lovely landscape, I switched to cloth bags.

Remember the bags

I found that remembering to bring the cloth bags into the supermarket was the first hurdle in changing my ways. Clearly, I wasn’t alone in that challenge.

“I carry my reusable bags in the back of my car. I try to remember to use them each time I shop,” writes Signal Facebook friend Pamela Spector Wosk. “I’m gradually getting better at remembering.”

“I prefer the cloth bags but occasionally forget to take them into the store with me,” says Signal Facebook friend Dorene Tapp.

That’s the idea, according to Signal website poster “Bobs.”

“This just stinks of another way to wring more money out of consumers, knowing full well that not everyone will remember every time to bring reusable (bags),” he says.

Cleanliness

Other readers raise issues about potential contamination with reusable bags.

Poster “tech” says the new law will mean new questions for shoppers: “Have you laundered them between use to mitigate food-borne pathogens? What if you make multiple trips a week?”

“Shall we start wasting water to wash out the reusables when we have dripping meat or fruit in them?” asks poster “missyJk.” “Just seems like a sneaky way to add a tax to a product (paper bags) we used to all use ‘til they switched us to plastic bags decades ago.”

Posters “chico” and “ricketzz” say they have solutions.

“I buy a box of 250 plastic bags at an office supply store,” writes “chico.” “Later, when I shop at the market, I stuff a few bags in my back pocket to bag my groceries at the check-out.”

“If I buy meat dripping with blood I’ll double bag it at the butcher counter,” writes “ricketzz.” “I can handle this by not bagging large items (jugs, large boxes) and bringing in a box for everything else.”

Lawmakers assure us that the small plastic bags available at the produce and meat counters are not part of the ban and will remain available. However, everyone knows those bags are subject to leaking, particularly since the handy little plastic clips that used to accompany them have mostly gone the way of the manual typewriter.

The only sure-fire way I can see to keep things from dripping is to bring in your own resealable plastic storage bags.

And laundering cloth bags isn’t desirable, from my experience. After one laundering they lose their shape and are harder to pack and unpack.

‘Single use’

Some of our readers challenge lawmakers’ assumption that the bags they currently use to carry their groceries home are, in fact, single use.

“I, like many people, have reused our plastic bags for all sorts of things,” writes newspaper reader Nancy Stern. “We have packed lunches, wet bathing suits and kid’s toys (in them).

“And a good many of us have used them when we scoop out our cats’ litter boxes and to carry our dog’s used poop bags. So the biggest impact for me has been having to buy plastic bags that I, like many, will only use once for some of the abovementioned.”

Facebook friend Dorene Tapp writes, “I do reuse the plastic to line my bathroom wastebaskets. My husband uses them when he cleans up the dog poop.”

Complains Signal Facebook friend Michael Pare: “I use them as trash bags so now I have to buy trash bags that end up in the same landfill. So where is the advantage here?”

His sentiment is echoed by Signal poster “johnnyrock”: “I use them for my litterbox and recycle what I don’t use.”

Nothing single-use about those handy “single-use bags,” our readers say.

Watch the loading

Another issue I’d like to note is that reusable cloth bags inevitably seem to tempt courtesy clerks to load all the heavy stuff into one bag.

I had a sturdy cloth bag rip out because I was chatting with the cashier and failed to notice the courtesy clerk’s flawed grasp of weight vs. weave principles. He loaded all the canned goods into the single bag.

Most of the time the clerks need to hear, “Please don’t load all the heavy things into one bag. I have to carry them up the stairs.”

Whatever household adjustments we have to make, it’s clear that by next summer we will have to answer poster “stevehw’s” question “Is living without plastic bags such a burden?” with at least a begrudging “No.”

← Back to 2014

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
128661
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
signalscv.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 876 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 6 (counted, not reproduced here); images 2.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_36_local
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/2 mentions: Valencia, Canyon Country]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By Lila Littlejohn]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 7, national 0