If you don’t want 6 giant digital billboards lighting up the sky 24/7 in Santa Clarita vote No on Measure S.
If you think that we should trade some older billboards for new digital billboards, vote No on measure S because this deal will leave 25 big billboards in our city.
If you think we should put in digital billboards so that the city can make money from them, vote No on Measure S because this deal doesn’t guarantee the city one penny, and gives away millions of taxpayer dollars for no good reason.
The people should first be asked if they want digital billboards, and then if they think they might, they should be told what the deal would be, to find out if they think it is a fair trade-off.
Measure S is a terrible deal that was negotiated by lobbyist Arthur Sohikian (who sits on a city sub-committee on transportation), Allvision, Metro, the prior city manager, and prior city director of development right before they left the city. It was done in secret, even though the city had the option to let the public know what they were planning.There was no competitive bidding, so other billboard companies did not have the opportunity to compete for a better deal. Our city council has done many great things over the years, but this is not one of them.
A fatal flaw in this deal is splitting the revenue four ways. There is no need to have Allvision, a middle man taking a cut, and there is no reason to have Metro take a cut. The city could simply do a deal with the billboard companies who have the existing signs. They would take down their signs, and according to our city attorney, Metro would not be able to put up new signs because state law would forbid it. The revenue pie could then be shared with just two parties.
In this terrible deal Allvision has a guaranteed option to receive 30 percent of the gross revenues for 30 years just to be the middle man. Using the proponent’s speculative city revenue of $1 million per year, Allvision would be taking approximately $50 million. In addition Metro would be getting $25 million that should go to the taxpayers. It becomes apparent why thugs were brought in to try to stop the signature gathering for the referendum to put this deal on the ballot.
After Allvision takes 30 percent of the gross revenues and the gross expenses are paid (which include entitlement expenses, removal costs, operational costs, capital expenses, and upgrade expenses), if there is anything left the city taxpayers get to split the net proceeds with Metro. One only has to look at Hollywood to see the folly of this type of deal, where a movie grosses hundreds of millions of dollars but never turns a net profit. We need to get a guaranteed income from the gross as other cities have negotiated.
This bad deal was made worse when the city decided (after doing the Metro deal) to pay the Edwards Company $1.3 million to take down 94 billboard faces, 44 of them which were part of the Metro deal. The Measure S deal is now for only 74 faces instead of 117. Instead of using the opportunity afforded by the referendum to renegotiate (37 percent less signs to be taken down without any more compensation) the city presses this give-away forward.
When the city’s own hired expert was asked whether we were getting the best deal compared to other cities, she told the council no. The written report that the proponents are touting as showing us getting a great deal was completed before the Edwards deal, and was based on 117 faces being removed as part of the deal, which is no longer true.
In addition, the locations for four of the digital faces are near citizen’s houses. Their property values will be negatively impacted. Two digital boards will be built on land that the city denied to a group who wanted to build a homeless shelter on. The city bought the property and told the citizens that it would be used as open space. If digital billboards are built, they should not be in open space or in citizens’ backyards. This is against everything that our city stands for.
There is only one solution to the Measure S mess. Vote No. Then if the city wants to reconsider, let’s do it in front of the public. It is why we formed our own city.
