The Santa Clarita billboard debate that has resulted in Measure S on the Nov. 4 ballot is hardly the biggest issue that has come before voters locally.
We think water is the biggest issue. Without it, we won’t survive in this valley to be further annoyed by our city officials’ pompous behavior or by residents who think a public vote on a public matter is a personal affront.
Measure S comes before us Nov. 4 because, once again, the majority of our City Council members have behaved in an imperialistic and condescending manner, apparently convinced they know better than the citizens who elected them. This attitude forced a referendum that resulted in this measure.
Measure S, if approved, would allow the city to enter into a contract with the county Metropolitan Transit Authority – which owns the land along the railroad tracks where the old-style billboards are located — to get rid of 40 of those old-style and unsightly billboards in exchange for the erection of three large electronic billboards along Santa Clarita Valley freeways.
Those billboards, one alongside Interstate 5 and two alongside Highway 14, wouldn’t be moving and flashing Las Vegas-type electronic billboards. They would advertise businesses in a digital format like the already-existing billboard on I-5 at Valencia Boulevard and also offer emergency messages for the public.
For the first couple years, small businesses that have taken advantage of the traditional billboards in their neighborhoods would get discounts on their electronic billboard advertisements as well as other financial help from the city in moving to the digital format.
It is estimated that the city initially would receive $400,000 to $500,000 per year for its general fund from the electronic billboard revenues, and higher income could follow later. The deal with Metro would not cost the city anything, and Metro would defend the city from claims arising from the construction and operation of the freeway digital billboards.
Since it was founded in 1987, the city has had the goal of getting rid of billboards. It’s a good goal, but its realization has been elusive until Metro approached the city with this deal. It’s logical that the city would go for it.
Critics say the Metro deal isn’t the best the city can make, but they offer no specifics for a better deal. We think it’s a good offer from Metro. Anytime you can bring money into the general fund in support of services to residents while beautifying the city that’s a good thing.
If you are absolutely opposed to electronic billboards, you should vote “no” on Measure S. But if you want to get rid of the billboard blight along city streets and can tolerate some electronic billboards along our freeways, then you should vote “yes.”
It’s regrettable that so much misinformation and just plain bad behavior on both sides has gotten in the way of clearly understanding this issue. The city started it all by ignoring the outpouring of opposition to the deal it had rightly delegated to staff to handle. Rather than putting the Metro deal on hold to hear out opposition, it rammed the deal through a council vote in an apparent effort to get then-Councilman Frank Ferry’s approval before he left the council earlier this year.
The city also promulgated misinformation with its alleged “impartial analysis” on the ballot stating that 62 – not the correct 40 – billboard structures would be removed along Railroad Avenue and Soledad Canyon Road if Measure S passes.
On the other side, the opposition has conducted a campaign fraught with rhetoric more characteristic of entitlement than reason. Perhaps the nadir was reached during the drive to collect signatures for the ballot measure, with signature gatherers providing misinformation and Allvision, the firm retained by Metro to negotiate the deal, hiring people whom it said were there to provide information but instead at times provided intimidation.
Many of those who oppose Measure S believe it should be voted down because they don’t believe the city truly tried to pursue other deals to get rid of billboards. They maintain the city should have negotiated with billboard owners themselves, who rent the land from Metro where the billboards are located. They don’t think money should also go to a third party, Allvison.
But so what? Metro owns the land where the billboards are erected. It is the one in control of whether there will be billboards there or not. We believe that the city should not be in the business of negotiating deals on someone else’s land.
One valid argument against Measure S is that it would deprive some local businesses of relatively inexpensive local advertising space. The argument that they could find a replacement on the digital billboards is specious. The potential customer base speeding by on the freeway is hardly the same as that driving down local streets.
After weighing both sides, we support the passage of Measure S. Let’s move forward and deal with more important issues.
