After having read and heard many arguments pro and con on this controversial issue, I have concluded that the entire thing is fishy at best. I am voting against it for several reasons, but my overriding reason is an aspect of the entire idea that I have not heard anyone address. As a retired businessman who operated a very successful manufacturing corporation in Valencia for 12 years, I have some credentials on the subject.
Let’s say for a moment that S passes. Local billboards are taken down, the digital ones are constructed, and the city prepares to collect the projected windfall of cash. But one thing has not been addressed — who will rent space on these digital wonders? Why will they rent space on them at all? From a small business point of view, they make no sense.
If as a small business owner, I currently rent one of the existing so called “unsightly billboards” (lets say I have a muffler shop), my message is on that sign 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. One hundred percent of the people who drive by that billboard see my message day after day. Guess who they will likely contact when they need a new muffler? At least they cannot forget that I am there for them. And remember, as a small business owner, my customers are overwhelmingly local residents who drive the surface streets in town.
OK, fast forward to the digital billboards. So I rent space there, and my message is, let’s say, one of 25 that flash by at some predetermined interval. Do the math. That says that my message is there 4 percent of the time, instead of 100 percent of the time as it used to be on the old billboard. Four percent of those drivers who dare take their eyes off the freeway while driving at 65-75 miles per hour in heavy traffic might see my message. How many will remember my business name, my address, or my phone number? Darned few. The other 96 percent won’t see it at all.
Now I ask you, as a potentially smart local small business person, would you be willing to rent space on such a sign under these circumstances? Not sure? Try the following simple test: Drive by the digital sign at Hart Park, where Newhall Avenue becomes Railroad Avenue, and try to read the flashing messages as you drive by. I dare you to take your eyes off moving traffic long enough to read the messages and get meaningful information. You will only be going 35 miles per hour!
Whether you like or do not like existing billboards, digital billboards, located on our adjacent freeways where many of the travelers do not live in the area, make no sense at all for local business who are being denied the opportunity to advertise locally to their most likely customers, local residents.
I’m voting no!
William L. Blowers is a Newhall resident
