The religious world was shaken Monday after the Vatican published a document concerning the Catholic Church’s position on the possible inclusion of gays.
The relatio post disceptationem is part of a preliminary report from the two week-long meeting at the Vatican focusing on family life. The document discuses a more inclusive attitude toward homosexuals, noting homosexuals had “gifts to offer the church.”
Gay rights groups are calling the document a seismic shift by the Catholic Church. Local religious leaders weighed in on the possible shift in policy and the overall controversy of the acceptance of gays and lesbians by religious groups.
Rev. Kelly O’Connell from St. Stephen’s Episcopal Church shared her excitement regarding the headlines.
“I hope this leads to a sense of being more inclusive,” she said. “The church is still behind the times, but it is the opening of a conversation, more than anything else.”
O’Connell explains the Episcopal denomination has faced similar internal struggles over inclusiveness of homosexuals. The church has been at the forefront of the issue.
“We have over the last several decades continued to push our understanding of where God is calling us, welcoming people to worship and sacrament,” said O’Connell.
Positive relationships
The papal document focused on nontraditional relationships of gay and lesbian couples, along with couples who cohabitate. It also concerned remarriage after divorce. In the Catholic Church remarriage requires a special annulment through the Vatican which includes paperwork and a lengthy process.
The document called on bishops to recognize the “positive” aspects of civil unions in less traditional relationships.
Rabbi Mark Blazer from Temple Beth Ami had a similarly positive outlook concerning the news and said many non-Orthodox Jewish synagogues tend to be more open and inclusive as well.
“We understand sexuality today has complexities that are often a problem from a biblical standpoint,” he said. “I find it striking, Christian communities that use the Old Testament pick and choose the laws they want to follow and which ones they don’t.”
Blazer explained he expects the same things from same-sex couples as he does from heterosexual couples–commitment, fidelity and monogamy.
“People who are not heterosexual can have relationships that are spiritually, physically and emotionally life affirming and positive.”
Monsignor Craig Cox, lead pastor of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, declined to comment on the Vatican document and deferred questions to Fr. Chris Ponnet, director of Gay and Lesbian Ministry of the Archdiocese in Los Angeles.
“The document indicates marriage is still affirmed between a man and a woman,” Ponnet said. “But it raises the question on how we move forward and pastorally affirm gifts of the gay and lesbian community while honoring the understanding of marriage.”
He said the main idea is that the Catholic Church welcomes every person to the church, without discriminating, but still stands firm on the doctrine that marriage can only be extended to heterosexual couples.
“It seems to me Pope Francis is really exploring the lives of regular Catholics – the people who are in the pews,” said O’Connell. “It may come to a greater understanding of what their real concerns are as opposed to theological issues.”
Pastor Melissa MacKinnon of Santa Clarita United Methodist Church commented that the issue can be complex for churches, and her denomination has continued dialoguing this topic for the past 15 years.
“We have always had an open heart, mind and open door kind of theology,” she said. “This begins to recognize the sacred worth of all human beings.”
Many other church leaders in Santa Clarita declined to comment on the document.
“I think it’s part of a movement towards acceptance,” said Blazer. “It may not be there yet, but it’s another step in that direction, a part of a progression.”

