Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District board members have again approved a charter petition from the Albert Einstein Academy to operate a school within Newhall School District boundaries — a decision welcomed by Einstein officials but criticized by leaders in the Newhall district.
District board members voted Thursday night to sign off on a resubmitted charter from the Albert Einstein Academy for Letters, Arts and Sciences to operate its elementary school on Orchard Village Road in Valencia.
That school, which opened last year, is located within the Newhall district’s boundaries.
“Obviously we’re thrilled that we were approved,” said Jeffrey Shapiro, chief executive officer for the Einstein Academies, in an interview Friday. “We’re thankful that the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District board of directors continues to operate in good faith, and we look forward to our continued relationship and partnership with them.”
Officials from the Newhall district, however, criticized the decision, calling it “yet another abuse of California’s law governing charter schools.”
“We want to see this matter resolved in a way that abides by the letter and spirit of the Charter Schools Act and is in the best interests of students and families in both school districts,” reads a statement from the Newhall district.
Newhall Superintendent Marc Winger has said one of the district’s contentions is that there is room to house the Einstein school within the boundaries of the Acton-Agua Dulce district. But Acton-Agua Dulce district Superintendent Brent Woodard has said he does not know of any locations in his district that could fully cater to Einstein’s needs.
The Newhall district filed a lawsuit last year seeking to overturn the charter that had originally been approved by the Acton-Agua Dulce district board in 2013.
That lawsuit claimed the school was not legally allowed to operate at its location on Orchard Village Road.
In October, a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge set aside approval of the charter petition and directed Einstein to apply for a new charter from the Acton-Agua Dulce district. However, the school has been allowed to continue operating in the meantime.
“This board does a level of review and due diligence that is very extensive, more extensive than almost any authorizer we’ve been before,” Shapiro said after the charter was reapproved. “But I know that any authorizer that operates in good faith is going to authorize us because of the quality of our program.”
The parties are scheduled to return to court on Feb. 5.
Newhall district officials said they plan present their case and say that both the Acton-Agua Dulce district and Einstein “still have not complied with the law, and to seek answers to the larger questions of district jurisdiction and sovereignty that remain unanswered.”
Newhall district board members have already approved appealing the Superior Court ruling.
“The district believes the Superior Court erred by allowing the charter school to continue operations despite finding that it did not have a valid charter,” reads a statement from the district.
Shapiro declined to comment Friday on further possible legal action. He has said in an earlier interview that he thinks the Einstein elementary school serves a demand.
“I think that parents and students, just as we would, would like the local districts to really just let us educate the kids and meet the demand that is so clearly here,” he said last month.
Newhall district officials, however, said the issue at hand is not school choice, but adherence to the law.
“Many continue to frame this as a David-and-Goliath battle over ‘school choice,’ when in fact school choice has nothing to do with this continuing struggle,” reads the Newhall district’s statement. “Every member of the Newhall School District board is committed to serving the community for the benefit of its students and seeing that the law is upheld.
“We have no opposition to charter schools,” the statement continues, “but we are opposed to the actions of organizations that twist the law and its purpose in an effort to make money rather than to serve children.”
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
