“There ought to be a law.” These words are uttered so often these days among people who think their personal belief or preference on a matter constitutes creating another law to impose their will upon the entire population.
The problem with this mentality is that it sets in a stone a rule that is now enforceable by the government, taking power away from the individual.
One area where there seems to be a disturbing level of government and nanny-state interference is in the arena of parenting.
One of the hardest jobs a person can ever undertake is the role of becoming a parent; today it has reached a level of difficulty that our grandparents likely never could have imagined.
We have so much information coming at us from all directions regarding everything — from disciplinary techniques to diet, education, social and intellectual development, safety, medicine, the list goes on and on.
We have this study, that study, and all we want to do is the right thing for our children. The problem comes in when one person, or in some cases many people, decide that there ought to be a law enforcing the “right” thing.
A poll conducted in August showed that 82 percent of Americans believe it should be against the law for any child under the age of 9 to be allowed to play outside without supervision, and 63 percent think that even 12 years old is too young to be unsupervised.
I found this poll deeply unsettling. Some of my greatest adventures as a child were had in my front yard or around the neighborhood with friends while our parents were at home cooking, cleaning, doing yard work, or taking care of other responsibilities.
It was a win-win. We burned off our excess energy (not to mention calories) playing with friends and they got things done. Today, my fellow Americans would have parents arrested and have their children placed in foster care for allowing them the same freedom.
There is a perception today that children are under constant threat, even as crime rates drop to some of the lowest levels in decades.
And there is an inclination, unfortunately by many, to take their own determination of what’s best for children and codify it into law.
Even spanking children has rules, sometimes so confusing in nature that parents call law enforcement to supervise to be sure they’re within the law.
Each time a law is made, another decision is taken from parents and given over to the state, making it that much more difficult for the parents to do their jobs without fear of law enforcement or child welfare agencies becoming involved.
Unfortunately, even medical decisions aren’t safe from scrutiny. We’ve all heard of the case involving Justina Pelletier, but she is just one of many young people whose parents have seen their children taken away and medical decision-making turned over to government officials.
The most recent case comes from Connecticut, where a 17-year-old, known only as “Cassandra,” was diagnosed with Hodgkin’s lymphoma and wished to seek alternatives to chemotherapy for her cancer.
Her mother agreed with her decision and began looking for other treatment options, but doctors called child protective services, which then took legal action, forcing this young woman into chemotherapy against her will.
The mother initially complied with the order, but after unpleasant side effects from the first few treatments, Cassandra ran away. She is now under 24-hour guard in a medical facility that has continued her treatment.
It’s a complicated case, but one that could have serious implications for what should be private medical decisions made by families.
Most parents would be willing to do anything and everything they could to save their child and would find it easy to overrule a 7-year-old’s opposition to chemotherapy. However, a 17-year-old is quite different from a 7-year-old.
This is a person literally months away from legal adulthood and all of the rights and responsibilities of that.
Having one of my own this age, I can’t imagine being placed in that position, and I can’t say for certain which way I would go, but I do know one thing; I would want the decision to be ours and ours alone.
Parenting is hard. A blessing, but hard. As a society, we must learn the difference between protecting children from real abuse and neglect and just creating more laws that make a tough job harder.
Christine Korenthal is a Canyon Country resident. “Right Here, Right Now” runs Fridays in The Signal.
