When Cassandra Firemark’s father and mother were married nearly 50 years ago, her grandparents refused to attend the wedding for one simple reason. They were Catholic and their son was marrying a Protestant.
While times have changed since then, many couples struggle to blend different religious views and traditions.
And in some cases those views can turn to disagreement when children enter the picture.
Valencia residents Elizabeth and Mark Yost, now members of Congregation Beth Shalom, were married more than 18 years ago. Elizabeth was raised in the Jewish faith, and Mark was raised Catholic.
They had a Jewish Cantor from another synagogue and a Christian minister perform the wedding; it was important to them that both traditions were represented.
After undergoing interfaith counseling, they made a choice to bring their son up only in the Jewish tradition.
“What the Rabbi told us was that it was important for us to choose one or the other for the child,” recalled Elizabeth Yost.
Despite their decision, they also celebrate and honor Christian holidays and traditions.
Yost said blending the two faiths became difficult when her husband’s extended family attempted to convert her to Christianity.
“So much of it was learning about what the other culture was like,” Yost said. “It was uncomfortable at times, but I realized his family loved me and wanted the best for me.”
Family, faith, culture
April and Mike Schwartz also realized blending an interfaith family was no easy task. They decided to teach their children about both religions, Judaism and Christianity.
Mike often attends Congregation Beth Shalom with his family. April, raised Catholic, now attends North Park Community Church with their daughter.
“It really hasn’t been a problem,” Mike said. “I respect that she believes Jesus Christ is the Son of God. I just believe he was a great man. Every one of us has God inside of us.”
The family embraces both religions. Their oldest son is Christian, and Mike’s adopted daughter from his previous marriage had a bat mitzvah when she was younger.
April said it was a little awkward when Mike’s family realized she wasn’t planning to convert. They decided to stop coming to Shabbat at their house, instead hosting at another home.
She said it was easier for Mike and her because they were honest with each other from the beginning. Neither of them planned to convert, and they each respected that.
“Being Jewish is more than just a religion, it’s a culture,” April said. “I don’t want Mike to forget about his Jewish faith.”
Thomas and Ofra Naylor, 44 and 43 respectively, also raise their children under Jewish traditions, even though Thomas was raised Baptist.
The couple attends Temple Beth Ami.
“It was important to me that we be involved in the temple,” said Ofra, who was raised in an Orthodox Jewish home in Israel. “Our kids ask, ‘Are we half and half?’ I tell them we are more Jewish, but we are also Christian and when they are older they can make their own decision.”
The Naylors also observe Christian holidays and attend Christian church at least once a year.
“I always tell my kids there is only one God, there is just a different way to believe in him,” Ofra said.
Many roads to God
Gordon and Cassandra Firemark, 46 and 49 respectively, had a wedding 10 years ago that blended many faiths. It included Rumi, Sikh, Buddhist, Jewish and Christian readings.
The breaking of the glass was observed, and Cassandra wore her grandmother’s Catholic rosary beads. Gordon is Jewish, and Cassandra, raised Methodist, now attends the Unitarian Universalist Church of Santa Clarita.
“Gordon asked me how I would feel about exposing our children to Judaism,” Cassandra said. “I wouldn’t want to deprive them of their Jewish heritage anymore than I would want to deprive them of their Christian heritage.”
The Firemarks now have three children under the age of six. They observe shabbat and attend temple at Congregation Beth Shalom, as well as Christian services.
Cassandra admitted having an interfaith relationship can be challenging, but both families were very open and accepting.
She feels it is beneficial to the children because they are exposed to “more than one way to move through the world.” So far, mostly Jewish traditions have been observed, but the family always celebrates Easter and Christmas.
“I want our kids to be exposed to what we grew up with and more,” Firemark said. “I don’t want them growing up thinking there is only one tradition.”
Cassandra advises couples to maintain an open mind and be flexible with each other.
“There is a passage in the Bible that says, ‘There are many rooms in my Father’s house.’ I don’t think Christianity is the only path to God,” Cassandra said. “We are all just people trying to find our way. However we find our way to God, I don’t think there’s one way that’s better than another.”

