Last Saturday one individual was shot in the head and two police officers were wounded in an attack on a synagogue in central Copenhagen, Denmark.
Hours before, at a cafe nearby, one person was shot and killed and others were wounded. The Copenhagen café had hosted a debate on “freedom of speech.”
It is thought the shooting occurred because it was attended by Swedish artist Lars Vilks, who had depicted the Prophet Mohammad as a dog.
These attacks are reminiscent of the Paris massacre last month when 12 innocents were killed by Islamic terrorists at the Charlie Hebdo newspaper. Charlie Hebdo was targeted because it published cartoons of the Prophet Mohammad.
Clearly, many Muslims are deeply hurt by what is considered by them as insulting, demeaning and sacrilegious drawings. But even to many Muslims, the killing of those who disrespect the Prophet is a bit too extreme.
Of course, moderate behavior never gets international news coverage.
The argument is this: Is curbing the freedom of expression of someone permitted, although this freedom permits messages that are insulting, demeaning and sacrilegious to others?
You can easily answer this question by translating it into a quotient that is black and white.
Our sacred Constitution, which by the way only applies to 4.5 percent of the world’s humanity, says we are guaranteed freedom of speech and expression.
But nowhere in the Constitution are we guaranteed the right to be free from being insulted or demeaned.
So in black-and-white terms, anyone in this country has a legal right to disparage and insult anyone else, their beliefs, their customs, their language, nation of origin, and their faith.
There are civil laws that protect individuals from untrue statements, called slander and libel.
There are criminal laws making threats of harm a terrorist act. But I have not been able to find any laws that protect one from insults or disparagement.
However, there is the “hate crime” aspect as defined by federal law. But even if the killings in Copenhagen and Paris were instead in L.A. and Santa Clarita, being motivated by perceived insults does not constitute hate crime.
Should we consider it a hate crime if one’s actions create a violent response by an insulted community? Apparently it seems not. Taunting and bullying without physical contact appear permitted as freedoms under our Constitution.
Taunting Muslim fundamentalists, for example, is a guaranteed freedom, but is often an excuse that triggers horrific acts. While terrorist acts are deplorable, those who taunted and angered our Muslim communities seem free from culpability.
What is missing from our black-and-white analysis — comparing freedom of expression versus the right to be free from emotional damage — is compassion.
While we have a right to say, write and draw terrible and insulting things, our respect for one another and our compassion for how others feel should moderate our actions.
I suggest we offer care and consideration for the customs and beliefs that those different from ourselves hold.
In Norway you don’t say hello or even make eye contact with a co-worker unless you have been formally introduced to each other outside the work environment.
When walking into a Japanese household, we respect the household and the occupants by removing our soiled and bacteria-infested shoes at the door before entering.
In a Mexican home we open Christmas gifts at midnight on Dec. 24.
In France you don’t wear sweat pants and a tank-top in public unless you are jogging.
Americans have a series of customs, as well. We leave a tip for the food server, even if the service was not perfect.
We chat with people we don’t know in line at the supermarket. We stand for the national anthem.
It is not so hard to accept the customs of others instead of crying about having to offer respect to those different from ourselves.
Like burning the American flag in the street or desecrating a church pulpit with pentagrams, some actions really hit home and are deeply offensive. While we have the legal right to insult those of other faiths and belittle those with different customs, there is no upside to these insensitive quests.
As humans, we share in common the notion that our nation, our people, and our faiths are special. Respecting our differences, so long as these differences do not diminish the human spirit, is how we ourselves deserve respect.
In other words, just because we can doesn’t mean we should.
Jonathan Kraut serves in the Democratic Party of the Santa Clarita Valley, on the SCV Human Relations Forum and on the SCV Interfaith Council.
