I must say that Gary Horton’s op-ed in the Feb. 18 issue of The Signal (“Hugs, not hate, to relate”) was an outstanding lesson in how not to write an op-ed piece and is an outstanding illustration of what is wrong with the dialog in America these days.
First of all, I want to commend Gary for taking on the hate-speak of the Westboro Baptist Church. His comments about them were exactly on point and were well articulated.
However, in doing so, Gary could not resist taking a shot at Karl Rove. He then diverted his commentary to an anti-right-wing media diatribe while ignoring the comparable sins of the left-wing media.
Maybe I should give him the benefit of doubt and conclude that he just needed to add words to fill up the remainder of the page.
Regardless of his motivation, the problem is that this took away from his main point about the Westboro people.
When you look at the online commentary in response to Gary’s article, virtually all of the commentary was about Karl Rove rather than on the real subject, the Westboro protests.
This is exactly the problem with America. We spend too much time arguing about the talking points of right- and left-wing media and very little time focusing on the real issues we face and how we can collaborate together to solve them.
Had Gary not brought Rove into the discussion, I think everyone on all sides would have commended Gary for an excellent op-ed piece. But instead, what he wrote was viewed as another in a long line of partisan hacks against Republicans and the right.
Gary, please do better next time!
