From toxic chemical disposal to touching off earthquakes, plans for a deep well injection site on the Santa Clarita Valley’s West Side has touched off fears among residents of the area for the safety of their families and the security of their homes.
The proposed deep well sites, where brine would be disposed of after it is removed from valley wastewater, is part of an elaborate system approved a year and a half ago by the Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District to reduce chloride in wastewater before it is released into the Santa Clara River. State water quality regulators have demanded that reduction.
Today The Signal takes a look at what experts say about some of the residents’ concerns.
Question 1: Can the proposed drilling at a deep well injection site trigger an earthquake?
“We don’t think it’s going to create an earthquake,” Dr. Egill Hauksson of the California Institute of Technology’s Seismological Laboratory said Wednesday.
Hauksson said he has studied oil wells dug to a depth greater than one mile throughout the Los Angeles Basin and found no effect on seismic activity.
“We can’t find any difference in the seismic activity within the oil fields and outside the oil fields,” he said.
About two miles north of the proposed deep well injection site is a natural gas operation on Newhall Ranch Road near Interstate 5 where more than 80 deep wells were dug without seismic consequence.
The Southern California Gas Company has at last 41 wells on the sprawling Honor Rancho site, including 23 wells that once produced oil for Texaco and an additional 18 wells drilled with its own rigs since then.
“The average natural gas storage well depth at SoCalGas’ Honor Rancho Storage Facility is about 10,000 feet,” company spokeswoman Denise King said Wednesday.
The deep well injection sites proposed for TPC Valencia would be about 5,000 to 10,000 feet deep.
The Gas Company also operates four brine-injection wells at the location, King said. “The brine injection wells are about 7,600 feet deep,” she said, adding that since those wells were sunk starting in 2009, they have caused no earthquakes.
Concerns about human activity trigging earthquakes have been most frequent in relation to fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, a process by which liquid is injected under high pressure into the ground with the purpose of breaking up subterranean geologic formations to extract oil or gas.
The purpose of the Santa Clarita Valley deep well injection site is to dispose of salt-laden water. Sanitation District officials have said the brine will go into a deep deposit of already-salty water far below the surface.
“Of the 47,000 injection wells in California, not one has ever caused any seismic-related property damage,” said Raymond Tremblay, head of the district’s Facilities Planning Department.
“An injection well would have to be drilled through an active fault, and it would take significant volumes of injected fluid to even have the remotest possibility of triggering small seismic events, let alone anything we could feel,” said Dan Masnada, general manager of the Castaic Lake Water Agency, which has drilled several water wells in the Santa Clarita Valley as deep or deeper than the proposed deep injection wells. “The short answer is this is not an issue.”
Question 2: Will West Side residents, including children, be exposed to toxic chemicals buried with the brine?
The brine line described in the district’s Draft Supplemental Environmental Impact Report for Alternate Deep Well Injection Site is permitted to carry only brine, which is the normal byproduct of reverse osmosis and has half the salt content of ocean water.
“The horizontal pipe and the vertical wells together will comprise a Class 1 nonhazardous liquid waste disposal system,” said Phil Friess, head of the district’s Technical Services.
Tremblay described the brine as: “Highly treated recycled wastewater with high concentrations of salt. It is completely safe. It’s just very salty.”
“All water supplies — surface and groundwater — have various dissolved minerals in it,” said Dirk Marks, water resources manager for the Castaic Lake Water Agency. “The federal and state government set very stringent standards to protect the public health.”
Masnada noted: “The (brine) water would be injected into zones that have no potable water and, as a practical matter, would not have any environmental impacts or consequences.”
A couple of citizens raised concerns that barium and chromium would be in the brine buried in the ground. Not so, said Friess.
Barium is a metal added in steel-making. Its compounds are added to fireworks to produce a green color and, in its soluble form, used to kill rodents. Chromium is an element also used in steel-making to make the metal less corrosive. Both are harmful to humans if ingested in large amounts.
“The barium level is projected as meeting the drinking water standard,” Friess said. “The chromium level was non-detect(able), according to the measurement method used.”
Question 3: Wouldn’t building a brine line to the ocean or to Carson be a viable, safer alternative to disposing of brine?
A brine line from the Santa Clarita Valley out the Santa Clara River Valley to the Pacific Ocean was considered in 2008-10 under a previous version of a chloride-reduction plan. That proposal was rejected as cost-prohibitive.
“Estimates ranged from $500 million to a billion (dollars),” said Marks, who was at the Sept. 3, 2008, meeting between local water officials and Ventura County farmers where the brine line was discussed.
Another plan, also rejected, proposed a brine line to a sewer tributary that connects to the Joint Water Pollution Control Plant in Carson.
That proposal would carry a price tag of about $85 million, Friess said.
But a bigger obstacle to the price would be the challenge of winning approval from all the municipalities and special districts that a brine line would have to cross, according to four district officials who met with The Signal on Monday.
Two years ago, when a plan to truck the Santa Clarita Valley’s brine to Carson came to the attention of the county supervisor representing that area, she immediately opposed it.
Former Supervisor Gloria Molina called on the county chief executive officer to review the draft environmental impact report for that to ensure it would not have a negative effect on areas in her district.
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

