CORONA — It couldn’t be. Not again.
Surely the Hart High girls soccer team had earned a better fate after overcoming a first-half, two-goal deficit and then a subsequent deficit by scoring in the 79th minute Tuesday night at Santiago High School.
Surely the Indians wouldn’t lose for the second-straight year deep in the CIF-Southern Section Division II playoffs in such heart-breaking fashion.
But the fact stands — much like their CIF title game from last year, the Indians roared back to fall painstakingly just short.
This time it was a 3-3 (4-2 in penalty kicks) setback at the hands of powerhouse Santiago High of Corona in the CIF-SS Division II semifinals.
“To lose against a team like this in PKs is indescribable, and it’s unfair,” said Hart senior Jenny Chavez, who was a member of the Hart team that closed a 2-0 deficit only to lose, 3-2, to Chino Hills in the Division II title game last year.
In its run at redemption, Hart (16-4-7) ran into a juggernaut Tuesday — a program with eight consecutive league titles (Big VIII and Mountain View) to its name, five straight trips to at least the Division II quarterfinals, and a No. 7 national ranking from MaxPreps.
Hart had Santiago (22-1-8) on the ropes, though.
Indians head coach Guilherme Mitrovitch moved Chavez from defender to forward in roughly the 68th minute. The Indians had struggled to create opportunities in the second half, and Chavez was to be the spark plug.
She delivered.
In the 79th minute, Hart’s Taylor Scott floated a pass toward Chavez deep in the Sharks’ 18-yard box. The senior leapt — higher than it seemed someone of her height should be able to — and headed the ball home.
Mitrovitch hopped nearly as high in the goal’s wake.
Two fairly uneventful overtime periods followed, and penalty kicks ensued.
Lindborg took Hart’s first kick. Her strike was denied by Paige Simoneau’s beautiful kick save.
The Indians made two of their next three. But the Sharks made all four of their kicks — including Maddy Haro’s game-winner.
Hart’s dream was over.
But it had seemed to end much earlier.
The Sharks jumped ahead of Hart, 2-0 by the 16th minute.
A blur of a counterattack led to a Valerie Santana goal in the eighth minute. And a Santiago set piece goal in the 16th seemed to take the air out of a Hart team that hadn’t lost since Dec. 13.
But Hart scrambled to its feet.
Taylor Moorehead scored in the 21st minute for the Indians.
Then Moorehead found Sarah Lindborg with a well-placed cross that Lindborg kicked in to tie the score, 2-2, in the 34th minute.
But Hart — which posted 17 shutouts this season — gave up another goal before half.
Haro hit a corner kick that found the head of towering Shark Raven Sweeney, who headed it to nearby Jill Olguin.
Olguin headed it into the net for a 3-2 Santiago lead at half.
“At half, we just told them it’s the semifinals of Division II. It’s not going to be easy,” said Santiago head coach Mike Fleming, who had witnessed Hart’s comeback against Chino Hills.
Hart’s second-year head coach made two key changes in the second half: he inserted Victoria Ryan at goalie. She made several key saves.
Then he put the team’s most dynamic player at forward. And Chavez put Hart on the cusp of a second straight title game.
“Just the way the girls fought back to get those two goals in the first half. And then to be down again in the second half and come back,” Mitrovitch said. “We definitely thought (the PKs) would swing our way.”
