In the last five years, four schools have left the NAIA-affiliated Golden State Athletic Conference — home of The Master’s College — for the NCAA Division II PacWest Conference.
Another institution will take the same route after this school year. And it’s possible Biola University will do likewise in 2017.
The exodus ultimately means new opponents, longer drives to conference games, higher costs and arguably less competition for TMC.
What it does not mean is any change in affiliation for the Mustangs.
“For the size of our institution, we’re in the right place for us. To be in the NAIA with a 1,000 person college, we are where we should be,” said TMC Athletic Director Steve Waldeck.
A wide sweep of arguments exist on both sides of whether a school should jump to the NCAA or stay NAIA — ranging from the cost of hiring more staff necessary at NCAA programs to more postseason reimbursement and greater perceived branding for NCAA Division II schools.
But while the reasons for each school leaving may vary, the ripple effects of the moves are more concrete.
In light of the departures — of California Baptist University, Fresno Pacific University, Point Loma Nazarene University, Azusa Pacific University and (after this year) Concordia University, Irvine — GSAC school presidents opted to give the conference more options.
Last fall, they moved to allow — for the first time since its 1986 inception — schools that aren’t faith based.
“I think in the past there have been inquiries about coming into the GSAC (by non faith-based schools),” Waldeck said. “When (it) had 11 schools that were similar, (the GSAC was) content to keep the profile of schools the same. It became evident they needed to look at changing that.”
The first such school will be Menlo College of Atherton in July. The business school of roughly 750 students will keep the conference at nine institutions — TMC, Hope International University, Westmont College, Vanguard University, Biola (which was set to apply for NCAA acceptance in February according to a release), William Jessup University, Arizona Christian University and San Diego Christian College being the others.
William Jessup, located in the Sacramento suburb of Rocklin, joined before this school year. Arizona Christian in Phoenix joined in 2012.
So between the GSAC’s three most-recent members, that’s 1,127 miles of travel for TMC — mileage the Mustangs have felt in the pocketbook even before Menlo’s arrival.
“Our travel costs over a year have gone up tens of thousands of dollars to just get the same number of games,” Waldeck said.
While travel and costs have increased, competition has lessened — even if only a little.
“I don’t think that we can argue that the competitive level at every sport is still the same,” Waldeck said. “It’s down a little bit. (But) there is still great competition that remains.”
The departed schools have combined to win 20 conference titles in eight of the PacWest’s 13 sports the last four years.
The GSAC’s cupboard isn’t bear without them, though.
The NAIA women’s volleyball top 25 postseason poll this year had three GSAC teams in its top 15.
The same poll for women’s soccer had four GSAC teams in the top 25. The most recent men’s and women’s basketball polls have four each — including Hope International as the men’s No. 1 team.
“In some sports, in some ways, it was like next man up,” Waldeck said.

