A Los Angeles Superior Court judge this week denied an environmental group’s effort to halt the sale of Valencia Water Company to Castaic Lake Water Agency.
The Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment lawsuit against the water agency states that its purchase of Valencia Water violated state law.
But Judge Robert H. O’Brien sided with Castaic Lake and ruled the water wholesaler acted lawfully in its purchase of the water retailer.
The water agency is still facing a lawsuit from Newhall County Water District, another Santa Clarita Valley water retailer, regarding similar legal issues. Hearings in that case have not begun.
O’Brien found in his Tuesday-dated decision that state law allows Castaic Lake Water Agency “to acquire the shares of any type of corporation, including a mutual water company, for the purpose of providing water for public, municipal or government purposes.”
“The judge ruled totally in our favor,” Dan Masnada, general manger for Castaic Lake Water, said Friday after the decision was announced. “We’re very happy about that. The judge clearly recognized a legal right to acquire and own Valencia Water Company.”
Lynne Plambeck, president of SCOPE — the group that brought the lawsuit — said the organization will appeal the decision.
Plambeck argued Friday that guidelines laid out in Assembly Bill 134 and state statutes prohibit Castaic Lake from carrying out the 2012 purchase of Valencia Water.
“They are violating the law,” Plambeck said. “It was startling to me. ... I’ve never seen such a short decision on a matter of real public concern.”
Castaic Lake’s purchase of Valencia Water stock was processed under eminent domain, Masnada said. The deal, originally estimated at more the $70 million, ended up costing the agency $59 million, he said.
The acquisition gave the water agency control of 84 percent of the Santa Clarita Valley’s retail water connections. Castaic Lake had purchased another local water retailer, Santa Clarita Water Company, in 2000. That retailer is now a division of Castaic Lake Water.
Valencia Water still operates privately, but there are plans to convert it into a public agency, Masnada said.
The third major local water retailer is Newhall County Water District. It is a publicly elected agency, and Plambeck sits on its board of directors.
The longtime environmentalist said Castaic’s purchase of two out of three local retailers creates what she describes as a “vertical monopoly” of local water resources. That leaves water prices solely in Castaic Lake’s hands without oversight or recourse, she said.
“They can raise the rates and they won’t benefit the public,” Plambeck said. “They would benefit special interest.”
Castaic Lake ran into legal problems during its 2000 purchase of Santa Clarita Water. Plambeck said taxpayer-led lawsuits were successful in stopping the purchase, but state law was changed to allow it.
Valencia Water was a private company established by the Newhall Land and Farming Company, now called Newhall Land Development Inc., in the early 1950s for the purpose of bringing water to its Valencia master-planned community.
Valencia Water serves about 116,000 people, Masnada said.
