I have been closely following the happenings related to California high-speed rail since before it was passed in a voter referendum in 2008.
During this time, I have noted with growing annoyance as a bloated and over-empowered bureaucracy answerable only to the governor slowly but methodically undermined the will of the voters with a plan that no longer even remotely resembles the project voters approved with Proposition 1A by a mere 52 percent.
I should mention before I go any further that as I am writing this, I am traveling home from Sacramento in a luxury tour bus with about 50 other attendees of the 10th annual KHTS Sacramento lobbying tour.
This is important because Interstate 5 is a reliable and well-traveled route between Sacramento and Los Angeles.
The high-speed rail plan would have followed this same route — instead of meandering its way from San Francisco to Anaheim (Sacramento and San Diego are promised some time in the distant future in Phase 2) — if political pressure from legislators with a financial stake had not taken it out of consideration early in the process.
One of the most closely watched sessions during the lobbying tour was a series of presentations for and against the California high-speed rail.
Speaking on behalf of the plan was Jeff Morales, chief executive officer of the California High-Speed Rail Authority.
Mr. Morales reportedly receives $365,000 per year to, as one opponent of HSR pointed out, travel around the state selling an indefensible project using a PowerPoint Presentation filled with glossy promises and little substantiality. He spoke for about 35 minutes before taking a few quick questions.
Santa Clarita Mayor Marsha McLean lamented the potential negative effects on local communities, regardless of which of the three proposed alignments is chosen through the Santa Clarita Valley and over the pass into the Antelope Valley.
She asked Mr. Morales what was being done to substantially or totally remove the negative impacts the various alignments would have on Santa Clarita and communities in the San Fernando Valley.
The answer I heard amounted to a promise that ‘technical metrics” — rather than political positioning — will determine the alignment. Now you see why he makes the big bucks.
Next up was Kevin Dayton representing the Citizens for California High-Speed Rail Accountability. Mr. Dayton said this group is often referred to as the Kings County Farmers due to the fact that it was started by a group of Central Valley farmers whose properties were under the pressure of eminent domain because of their value to the project.
Mr. Dayton used the first 10 minutes of his truncated presentation (he noted half-seriously that again high-speed rail was running behind schedule) to bring the group up to date on a number of deficiencies of the project and to update on an ongoing lawsuit involving his group.
Dayton pointed out that few people know Proposition 1A included $995 million for “connectivity” projects such as new BART cars and the electrification of tracks for Caltrain — work completely unrelated to a connected high-speed rail system.
He then went on to talk about interest on the billions borrowed through bond sales. Aren’t there better things to spend tens of billions of dollars on?
He specifically mentioned the bill introduced by Assemblyman Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, that would terminate further issuance of high-speed rail bonds and use the remaining money to beef up school construction spending.
He also pointed out that Proposition 1A was so poorly written that the California High-Speed Rail Authority cannot comply with its requirements even if it wanted to.
The takeaway from the two presentations for me and a few others I spoke with centered on how disingenuous the California High-Speed Rail Authority has been when it comes to leveling with voters and stakeholders about the massive financial risks this incredibly complicated but poorly thought-out project poses to this and future generations of Californians.
Our friends in communities to the northeast of us, and also to the south of us, wait as eagerly and with just as much stake in the outcome of the Palmdale-to-Burbank alignment.
Regardless of which community comes out on top in this decision, the entire state and several generations who live here will be the big losers in this high-stakes boondoggle.
I continue to believe strongly that the more Californians learn about this project, the more they are against it.
Kevin D. Korenthal is a 33 year resident of the Santa Clarita Valley and is the President of KORE Communications, L.L.C. He consults for a number of groups opposed to the current high-speed rail plan.
