We oppose deep well injection as a solution to chloride reduction anywhere in the Santa Clarita Valley, as deep well injection of large volumes of fluid has been scientifically linked to induced earthquakes.
This is compounded by the fact that the California Earthquake.
Authority insurance policy is written in such a way that it does not cover any earthquake damage initiated, even in part, by human activity.
The California Earthquake Authority states: “18. ‘Tectonic processes’ means natural adjustments of the earth’s crust that are wholly in response to regional stress conditions caused by natural dynamic forces within the earth’s interior, and not initiated, in whole or in any part, by any human activity.”)
This puts our earthquake insurance at risk in the event that the California Earthquake Authority considers earthquake damage to be caused, even partially, by deep well injection.
Will the Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District board indemnify all of the Santa Clarita Valley against deep-well-injection-induced earthquake damage?
If not, how will our homes be insured against earthquake damage “initiated in whole or in any part, by any human activity,” which clearly includes deep well injection?
Injection wells that deal with large volumes of fluid have been suspected of being linked to earthquakes since the 1960s, when fluids from the Rocky Mountain Arsenal were pumped deep underground. Scientific American notes,
“During four years of such disposal, the pumping triggered 16 earthquakes, even after the injection stopped”
(http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/drilling-and-pumping-wells-spawn-powerful-earthquakes/).
But it’s only within the last three years that a lot of the scientific evidence linking deep well injection to earthquakes has been brought to light.
This increase in scientific investigation, research and publications is due to the increased use of hydraulic fracturing (fracking) in the United States.
Contrary to what most people think, fracking does not increase the risk of seismic events in any substantial way. This comes as a surprise to many due to the fact that fracking uses highly pressurized liquid to intentionally crack open rock formations underground.
Rather than fracking itself, it’s the seemingly innocuous deep well injection of large amounts of waste water that increases the probability of seismic events.
This seems counter-intuitive to most people given that the pressures involved in the deep well injection of the waste water are much less than fracking.
The secret to this apparently bizarre contradiction was revealed in the highly respected 2012 National Academy of Sciences report on induced seismicity
(http://dels.nas.edu/Report/Induced-Seismicity-Potential-Energy-Technologies/13355).
The National Academy of Sciences states, “The factor that appears to have the most direct consequence in regard to induced seismicity is the net fluid balance (total balance of fluid introduced into or removed from the subsurface), although additional factors may influence the way fluids affect the subsurface.”
In other words, it’s not the high rock-splitting pressure of fracking that is linked to induced seismicity, but rather the injection of very large volumes of fluid, that is linked to induced earthquakes. Additionally, the National Academy of
Sciences goes on to say that the volume of fluid injected is also linked to the magnitude of induced earthquakes.
Why is this a concern?
It turns out that any deep well injection site planned for the Santa Clarita Valley area to deal with chloride compliance will have up to 500,000 gallons of brine waste injected into it per day.
This means that up to 182,500,000 gallons of brine waste will be injected deep under the Santa Clarita Valley each year.
That amount, 180 million gallons per year, makes it one of the largest deep well disposal sites of its kind in the nation.
Dr. Art McGarr, world-renowned geophysicist with the U.S. Geological Survey, provided computation for the maximum magnitude earthquakes that could be caused by injecting 180 million gallons of fluid per year.
This analysis was based on the equations in Dr. McGarr’s groundbreaking “Maximum magnitude earthquakes induced by fluid injection” paper published just last year
(http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2013JB010597/abstract).
The results are sobering.
With 180 million gallons of fluid injected per year, in one year the maximum magnitude of an induced earthquake would be 4.8; in 20 years, magnitude 5.7; and in 50 years, magnitude 6.0.
What is even more alarming is that these magnitudes do not include any natural seismic activity at all.
Oil wells are common in California, but these are not a real concern. The reason is that the typical amount of net fluid being injected or extracted from each of these oil wells is not anywhere near 180 million gallons per year.
As a comparison, one of Santa Clarita Valley’s most famous oil-field waste-injection wells, Sedlacek Well No. 8, only had 1.4 million gallons of fluid injected into it in all of 2014.
The volume of fluid being injected into this oil well is less than 1 percent of what would be injected into the Santa Clarita Valley deep well injection site for brine waste.
It’s important to note that the effects of deep well injection of fluids, and the link to potential seismic activity, are not always immediate.
Dr. Elizabeth Cochran, a highly respected geophysicist with the U.S. Geological Survey in Pasadena, pointed out that the deep well injection of fluid in Oklahoma that resulted in the magnitude 5.6 earthquake had been running fine for 20 years (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vFMoxx9ryCY).
Furthermore, over time, the injected brine will spread out over large distances, increasing the risk of earthquakes on faults as far as six miles away.
The U.S. Geological Survey states: “Induced earthquakes commonly occur several kilometers below the injection point.
In some cases, the induced earthquakes have been located as far as six miles from the injection well.”
How many major earthquake faults are within six miles of any point in the Santa Clarita Valley?
Too many (http://www.quake.ca.gov/gmaps/FAM/faultactivitymap.html).
The plan for the Santa Clarita Valley area deep well injection site is to use the site as long as the engineers believe the geology can handle it, and as long as there is a need to dispose of brine waste.
There will be a cost-saving incentive to inject brine waste into the Santa Clarita Valley area deep well injection site for as long as possible.
This does not bode well for the increased risk of seismic activity given that the National Academy of Sciences has warned us: “Net fluid balance appears to have the most direct correlation to the magnitude of induced seismic events.”
Do we want to risk a deep-well-injection-induced magnitude 5.7 earthquake in 20 years or a magnitude 6.0 earthquake in 50 years?
These magnitudes are completely independent of natural seismic activity. To exacerbate matters, the latest earthquake research from this year (2015) shows that faults are connected with each other in ways that we didn’t understand before
(http://www.usgs.gov/newsroom/article.asp?ID=4146).
If a natural earthquake triggers an earthquake on a fault that has already had its pore pressure increased by deep well injection, the combined effect could be catastrophic.
Where is all this brine waste going? Can the brine be stopped from spreading miles to significant earthquake faults?
When will there no longer be a need to dispose of brine waste? When will the farmers downstream in Ventura County start asking for higher chloride content in their water?
What happens when the underlying geology reacts badly to the large volume of injected brine waste? What is the maximum magnitude of an earthquake that could be caused solely by deep well injection?
What is the maximum magnitude of an earthquake that could be caused by a combination of natural seismic activity in conjunction with faults already lubricated by the spread of brine?
Will the Sanitation District board indemnify all of the Santa Clarita Valley against deep-well-injection-induced earthquake damage?
If not, who will help us to pick up the broken pieces after a major earthquake is caused, even partially, by deep well injection?
As a group, Stop the Deep Well Injection in SCV opposes deep well injection as a solution to the chloride reduction system anywhere in the Santa Clarita Valley.
And we urge our leaders to consider alternative solutions that do not put our entire valley at risk.
This column was submitted by Stop the Deep Well Injection in SCV, including Aimee Merrilees, Courtney Kang, Elliott O’Neil, Gary Morgan, Jared Schnackenberg, Jeff Greiner, Jennifer Owen, John Yoon, Karen Campbell, Keith Pritsker, Marilee Christofferson and Trevor Pooley.
