Editor's note: A shorter version of this story ran during Tuesday's news cycle.
Newhall School District board members voted this week to move forward with switching their election system to voting areas — making Newhall the third Santa Clarita Valley school district to do so.
The move means voters within voting area boundaries will have a choice among candidates running to represent their area of the district, rather than casting ballots for all open seats on the district bard.
School board members approved the shift 4-1 during their meeting Tuesday night.
Previously, Newhall school board members were elected at large, meaning registered voters within the school district had a voice in selecting all board members.
Moving to voting areas provides the district with a “safe harbor” of sorts against legal action brought under the California Voting Rights Act, according to Allison Deegan with the Los Angeles County Office of Education.
“The safe harbor is trustee areas, trustee-area voting,” she said during a presentation to board members Tuesday night.
The Newhall district, like others in the Santa Clarita Valley, faced the potential threat of a lawsuit over alleged violations of the California Voting Rights Act.
But, like other local school boards, the move seemed motivated more out of necessity than desire.
“I feel like the whole (Voting Rights) Act, the way it’s designed with only going to districts, disenfranchises voters of all types,” said board member Brian Walters.
“I reject the notion that voters are so shallow that they only care what someone’s surname looks like in determining whether or not somebody represents them,” Walters said, referring to the lawsuit brought against some other Santa Clarita Valley districts claiming at-large elections rob Latinos of a chance to have fair representation on elected boards.
Board member Sue Solomon called the act “flawed, and there’s no question about that.” She said she hopes board members in districts that have voting areas continue to represent their whole district, not just the areas that elected them.
Three local agencies — the city of Santa Clarita, Santa Clarita Community College District and Sulphur Springs School District — were hit with California Voting Rights Act lawsuits in 2013.
Those lawsuits alleged their at-large election systems diluted the power of Latino voters to elect candidates of their choice.
A collection of other local districts, including Newhall, received letters last year from one of the attorneys in the cases brought against the city, COC and Sulphur Springs. Kevin Shenkman of the Malibu-based law firm Shenkman & Hughes outlined similar allegations against the districts that received his letter.
Newhall district officials plan to have the voting-area system in place in time for the upcoming board election in November.
The Sulphur Springs School District and William S. Hart Union High School District are also shifting to voting-area elections.
The voting-area election systems are expected to be in place in those districts for this year’s elections, as well.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
