When the devastating 7.8 magnitude earthquake rocked Nepal April 25, it also triggered a massive avalanche on Mount Everest leaving, at press time for this publication, at least 18 climbers dead, and many more injured, missing or stranded farther up the 29,029 foot mountain. And yet, at the base camp located 17,388 feet up the Nepal side of the mountain survivors began posting social media messages to alert friends and family thanks to a private telecom firm that connected the earth’s tallest mountain with 3G high speed Internet services in 2010.
Meanwhile, for at least a decade, Santa Clarita Valley businesses have groused about the lack of high-speed Internet access that exists regionally. And as solutions have been short in coming, demand for access has only increased dramatically. Each day that passes without a solution pushes the region farther back into 20th century technology with many businesses still operating via DSL lines – a technology that became widely available and affordable to consumers in the late 90s. Now fast forward nearly two decades.
Back in 2011, Creative Concepts Engineering Clay Kalhoun said he was surprised to find that even in the relatively newer areas of the Valencia Industrial Center the best he could find was a DSL connection. In an office off Westinghouse Place, he got a quote at the time from one provider to upgrade and found it would cost him $1,632 per month when his rent was only $1,178 per month. Today, many business owners report they often leave the office and go home to upload or download large files because they get much over 2011 better service as residential consumers, than as business customers. As of 2015 connections haven’t improved much and the need is only growing business owners say.
The Great Recession slowed momentum in connecting SCV businesses to modern technology, and yet, all the while technology continued to advance during the economic downturn. Discussions as to how to tackle the problem surfaced again after three business groups surveyed local companies last year and found the lack of high-speed access to be among the primary concerns of local firms. Huge investments in infrastructure will have to be made by all including service providers; business owners will have to allocate more money in their budgets for high-speed connections; and the community will need to actively work together with all stakeholders before resolutions are forthcoming. It appears that no one entity, business, association, city or county can solve the problem alone – success will most likely only come as a result of a collective strategy and methodical planning, business owners report.
Pursuit of speed
John Davidson, president of Magic Feather Inc., has moved his business three times in pursuit of higher speeds. Creating motion graphics, content, on-air promotions and more for networks and movie studios, he walked away from one office, leaving him to pay for leases on two offices simultaneously while he struggled to keep his business functioning on the lower level of connections that exit for most of the tenants in business centers around the valley. He said he struggled to provide basic services for clients that his counterpart agencies in surrounding cities could provide. Magic Feather has been located on Rye Canyon Road, The Old Road and is currently operating out of an office on Avenue Stanford.
“The Internet’s not going away,” said Jeremy Stepan, founder of Adage IT, an information technology service provider who says he knows where Internet connections are – and are not.
It seems that the providers are building fiber in the ground only because they know they have to, Stepan said. And yet in fact they do have a vested interest in expanding but there is a cost of doing business to build up the infrastructure for everyone involved – the providers and the businesses that need the upgraded services.
“Businesses have to realize there has to be a bigger IT budget today,” Stepan said. “The days of living on DSL and even T1 lines are gone; they’re no longer viable. The days of low-cost service are over. As bad as it is, we’ve positioned ourselves with a heavy reliance on the Internet.”
For smaller businesses, however, they say they can’t afford the high costs of upgrading alone. For others willing or able to make an investment, they can’t get a guarantee their investment wouldn’t then be siphoned off by other users in the area – thus slowing down their work flow again.
Cost of doing business
Every day between 3 p.m. and 6:30 p.m. Michael Weiss of Whitmor/Wirenetics on Avenue Hopkins in the older Valencia Industrial Center – built before the Internet even existed - says his Internet speed drops to a crawl. His firm operates on three T1 lines and that the majority of the employees in his company – which produces high-performance wire, cable and tubing to the military, aerospace and satellite industry – are on a dedicated DSL line. Only 40 percent of his people have Internet access on a daily basis. And Whitmor/Wirenetics pays $1,740 per month for those T1 connections, he said.
One provider promised to run fiber to his building, but told Weiss they would retain the right to go back and break into that new run to provide service to other companies nearby. He won’t invest the money to upgrade unless he can get a guarantee that no other company can tap into the fiber lest he risk reducing his Internet speed to a crawl again. Saying the park is cobbled together with an old copper cabling system that can’t handle the traffic, Weiss compares working in the area as conducting business using 21st century technology with 20th century infrastructure.
Although Landscape Development Inc. is in a relatively new business park on Witherspoon Parkway in the Valencia Commerce Center off Highway 126, owner Gary Horton also says he only has access to outdated technology – T1 lines. He has two T1 lines and one radar microwave as backup. “It’s very expensive and not all that fast. We pay $800 a line or so; it’s extremely expensive relative to home use,” Horton said. “We pay a couple thousand a month for Internet access.”
And the older Internet technology compromises his firm’s capabilities. Instead of using best work practices or all the features of software or other products he might buy, the settings on his systems are set to as low a threshold as possible to keep data usage as low as possible so that everything can operate simultaneously. Offerings are so poor locally, he said, that it “cramps business and may even cramp the effort to attract businesses to Valencia that might be more technology driven.”
Davidson with Magic Feather compared his home service with ridiculous speeds to what he gets in the office for only one-fourth of the upload speed and one-tenth of the download speed, but he pays nearly seven times more for service at the office - $450 a month, he said. One provider said they can double his speed for another few hundred dollars a month.
He has the option of connecting to fiber according to one provider he spoke with, but it cost $1,000 a month and the service is only comparable to what he’s already getting at the office, he said. When the Discovery channel sends him five high-res episodes at a time, Davidson always goes home to download them. “But for us the biggest issue is upload speeds. We’re sending commercials and trailers to networks and all of our clients have switched over to online delivery,” Davidson said.
For Quan Gan, owner of Gantom, a provider of micro spotlights for theme parks, museums and other entertainment venues, he said he didn’t find out about the Internet speed problem until after he signed a five-year lease on Avenue Hopkins in the Valencia Industrial Center – in the middle of Santa Clarita.
The building was advertised as saying a T1 line was included with the lease, but it only amounts to 25 megabits and it’s technology from 15 years ago. However, that T1 line is shared by all the tenants in the building leaving his firm with only about 1.5 megabits to use. So he contracted with an L.A. provider for Voice over Internet Protocol (VOIP) for his firm’s phone and Internet services at a cost of $400 a month to get 4 megabits up and downstream.
In contrast, the Federal Communications Commission set new broadband standards in January of 25 megabits/3 megabits to reflect advances in technology. And that benchmark was based on what the government deemed minimally necessary particularly for rural areas. But Santa Clarita is the third largest city in Los Angeles County. And L.A. County is considered to be the most populous county in the nation.
Gan compares the lack of speed he gets in his office to his home where he pays less than $50 a month for 20 megabits of bandwidth. To conduct business in the office, he has to ensure no one is streaming or downloading a file when he needs to video conference oversees. If he’s on a call when that happens, the call gets dropped or so terribly garbled he can’t understand what’s being said.
Tenants in his building have been in discussions with the landlord to see if they’re willing to bring in a company to provide everyone with Internet service, but the problem is many of the older more traditional businesses don’t need the bandwidth the newer companies need, he said.
“As a small business owner I’m caught in-between. I can’t pay several thousand dollars a month for Internet,” he said. “If everything is capital driven, there’s no financial incentive for telecommunication providers to come here if only a few tenants in each building might need high-speed.”
For Carl Kanowsky, of Kanowsky and Associates law firm, the only option available to his law firm is DSL despite his office being located on Summit Circle in the Centre Pointe business center which is fairly new. After spending nearly two years attempting to get cabling or fiber to the area, Kanowsky has no immediate hopes on the horizon, or at least anything that makes sense from a cost standpoint, he said.
Providers have pretty much saturated the residential market and it’s not really in their best interest to spend more time and money trying to coordinate with groups of businesses to pay for services at each building location, he said. Other providers are really more focused on wireless technology.
The lack of viable solutions frustrates the business groups as well who are attempting to piece it all together and find a solution.
Advocacy
The Valley Industry Association’s Advocacy Committee, which Kanowsky chairs, sat down with two sales engineers from Time Warner in mid-April to discuss options for closing the service gaps.
“It’s terrible for the area economically; we need high speed,” said Kathy Norris, president and CEO of VIA. “Folks understand there needs to be a return on investment. If we could put companies together to split the cost of the investment; or if a company makes the investment to bring high-speed to their building and then provides access to connect to other buildings, those are some of the options we’re looking at.”
Staying current with modern, up-to-date technology is going to be really critical for economic development in the long term as businesses are only going to use more data, said Holly Schroeder, president and CEO of the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corporation.
Together, the SCVEDC, VIA and the SCV Chamber of Commerce conducted a survey blitz of businesses last year when the issue surfaced. The city has more fiber than any other community, Schroeder said, but there are deficiencies in some of the areas and parts of the Valencia Industrial Center were built before the Internet was invented.
Business owners across the board also expressed high levels of frustration with the amount of disinformation that is available from some of the key service providers in the area. To that end the SCVEDC worked to at least identify the basic options available to businesses from each of several providers, as well as identify a single point of contact from each one.
The matrix of services available to SCV businesses is helpful to have, Norris said. By the same token it doesn’t really solve the problem of connecting for local businesses if solutions can’t be found. All of the tenants in VIA’s building on Avenue Tibbitts have enormous problems, she said.
The SCVEDC is focused on the business parks where demand is the highest, Schroeder said, and it wants to formulate broader strategies to become “tech forward” and put Santa Clarita at the forefront in its ability to move data. “It’s really important for our long term economic viability; we’re not going to use less, we’re only going to be using more,” she said.
As for the primary providers in the area, in fact they’ve already made huge investments in the SCV – particularly for residential users – but other than connecting individual companies the business parks have remained largely untouched as a whole.
Providers
As a region, much of the infrastructure is built underground making it much more costly for providers and companies alike to make wholesale upgrades. If fiber or cable were to be strung pole-to-pole, or overhead, it’s easier and much less costly, said Jason Price, sales engineer with Time Warner at a recent meeting with VIA’s advocacy committee.
There’s a better return on investment of the cost of going underground if there are multiple tenants in a building tapping into the service, he explained. The costs can be recouped by multiple users more easily than when only one tenant occupies a building. And the cable company isn’t the only provider to feel that way.
Time Warner would find it beneficial to work through the local business groups, Price said, so the company could focus on building a bigger strategic plan as opposed to working with one company at a time.
VIA offered to work with the provider and other businesses in the area to see what could be coordinated, building by building perhaps. Next steps include VIA sitting down with Time Warner’s market development group, sales team, construction, technical operations and government relations team to explore strategies.
As for AT&T, it has fiber and wireless infrastructure throughout the area, said Alexandra Krasov, director of communications and public affairs. But, like Time Warner it also looks at infrastructure already in a given area, as well as what would need to be built such as in the older business parks. And the number of tenants in a building is key to AT&T as well.
Businesses owners and property managers/owners can check online at corp.att.com/fiberreadybuilding/benefits/owners.html to see if their company is fiber-ready, Krasov said. If it isn’t, AT&T’s fiber building team can tell them what additional equipment installation would be needed to make it so.
In a check of the addresses of the eight business owners we spoke with in the various business centers and parks, however, none of their buildings were fiber-ready. Business owners have their own suggestions to tackle the problem.
Possible solutions
A building needs high-speed connections the same as it needs basic necessity like roads, lighting, electricity, and sewage, Gan said. In checking with the city of Santa Clarita and Los Angeles County’s planning department, however, there are no infrastructure requirements in place that would compel or incentivize builders to make those connections to a building in a region that is home to several growing industries such as digital media, biomed devices, and advanced manufacturing. And post-recession, much commercial development is now underway. Owner Weiss is critical of that approach asking “do you build the homes and then build the water pipes, or do you dig water pipes and then build homes?”
“If we’re going to maintain the region as a premier industrial area to bring businesses the people responsible have to bite the bullet – utility providers – the pressure has to be put on them that they have to do something – the pressure has to come from somewhere – the city or the customers,” Weiss said. And he volunteered to serve as contact point for other businesses to start the dialogue saying there’s a lack of a cohesive strategy to represent what business owners need to move forward with technology.
Gan believes that perhaps all technology-related companies, or those businesses in need of high-speed connections, might need to physically centralize together into one area – or at a set of buildings – to pay for infrastructure upgrades and offset the need to connect every single building in the business parks. And Horton wondered aloud if buying a satellite company would be a solution.
The city has fiber in its streets for traffic lights, said Jason Crawford, economic development manager for Santa Clarita. It’s looking at whether there’s a way to utilize existing fiber to improve the network but based on maps he’s seen and the businesses he’s spoken with he thinks the cost of connecting to individual buildings could be very expensive.
“Having high-speed for businesses is hugely important, it’s a frustration for our businesses now. It’s something that could hold up a new business from moving here. We’ve been working hand-in-hand with the EDC and VIA to identify solutions and be involved where it makes sense.”
As for going above ground, the less costly alternative, that isn’t likely to occur. Most of the city and all new projects involve building the infrastructure underground for safety and aesthetic reasons, he said. As it is, they’ve already had requests to put more above ground infrastructure underground along Soledad Canyon Road.
“The only thing I think we can do is to start researching and start our own municipal broadband,” business owner Davidson said. “That would shake up the players because they don’t want you do that.”
This story published in the May 2015 edition of the SCV Business Journal.

