As of 2013, elections in the Santa Clarita Valley were a largely straightforward affair.
Three seats up for election on a school board? Vote for three candidates. Two spots open on the City Council? Put your mark next to two names.
At-large elections, in which eligible residents could vote for every seat up for election, were the norm.
Now? Not so much.
What used to be a uniform series of local elections is now a tangled web. Some agencies have changed their election dates, others their entire election systems. Some have attempted to do both.
The cause lies with the California Voting Rights Act.
The local election upheaval started in June 2013, when lawsuits alleging violations of the California Voting Rights Act were filed against the city of Santa Clarita, Sulphur Springs School District and the Santa Clarita Community College District, which oversees College of the Canyons.
Each of the lawsuits claimed the use of at-large elections violated voters’ rights by diluting the power of Latino voters to elect candidates of their choice or otherwise influence local elections.
All three of those lawsuits were settled last year — but not all in the same way.
Sulphur Springs settled its lawsuit by agreeing to change to voting-area elections starting this November.
In such a system, a district would be broken up into smaller sections called voting or trustee areas.
Voters within those areas would then elect someone to represent that area.
If there were two or three seats up for election, voters could cast ballots for only one seat — the seat for their area.
In the months since Sulphur Springs announced its settlement agreement, the William S. Hart Union High School District, Newhall School District and Saugus Union School District have all agreed to adopt voting areas.
Hart and Newhall officials say they plan to have their new systems in place this November. Saugus plans to hold at-large elections this year but have voting areas in place in 2017.
‘Safe harbor’
The switch in election systems is driven by the fact that the California Voting Rights Act itself says voting-area elections provide a remedy for claims that at-large voting dilutes minorities’ voices.
Many local officials, however, are making the change reluctantly. One is Saugus school board President Rose Koscielny.
“We’ve always thought about 10,000 students (in the district); none of us care what their surnames are,” Koscielny said. “Now, it’s almost like what they do in Congress — you’ve got to bring the pork home to your own little area instead of worrying about all the kids. That, to me, seems wrong.”
“I personally feel that it’s more appropriate, as a citizen, to be able to vote for all five board members,” said Bob Jensen, president of the Hart district board. “I strongly feel that way, but we have this thing called the California Voting Rights Act, and the only safe harbor for not getting sued relative to the CVRA is to go to trustee areas.”
Newhall school board member Brian Walters said last month he thinks the Voting Rights Act “disenfranchises voters of all types.”
“I reject the notion that voters are so shallow that they only care what someone’s surname looks like in determining whether or not somebody represents them,” Walters said.
Cumulative voting
Of the three local governments sued in 2013, the city and community college district decided to take the path less traveled to settle their lawsuits and adopted a system called cumulative voting.
Almost never used in California, cumulative voting gives each voter as many votes as there are seats up for election to be doled out however the voter chooses in an at-large election.
That includes voting multiple times for the same candidate.
The city and college district also agreed to switch their elections to November of even-numbered years, anticipating higher voter turnout at those times.
Consolidation
Both the city and college district also asked to consolidate their elections with the county’s ballot, hoping to increase voter turnout by joining high-interest races like those for governor or president.
To further tangle the election web, Santa Clarita received conditional approval to consolidate its election on the county ballot, while COC’s board did not.
Dean C. Logan, the county’s Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk has questioned whether the county’s balloting system would be able to accommodate cumulative voting and said he’s concerned that there’s no defined legal framework for what cumulative voting would look like on a ballot.
But the community college district plans to move ahead anyway, holding its election separate from the county’s if necessary, said spokesman Eric Harnish in an earlier interview.
In other words, voters could be called on to cast ballots in a county-run election and a separate COC election on the same day.
The Castaic Union School District has yet to officially change its election system and so is on track to hold an at-large election this November. Board President Steve Teeman said a meeting is scheduled May 19 to consider the issue.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney

