Jobless numbers were released by the state Friday showing Santa Clarita’s unemployment rate crept up from 6.5 percent in April to 6.7 percent in May – slightly higher than the state’s rate.
California’s jobless rate in May was 6.4 percent. Nationally, it was 5.5 percent.
Los Angeles County, however, remains unchanged month-to-month, standing at 7.6 percent.
The city’s jobless numbers jumped notably between December 2014 and January 2015, when the unemployment rate spiked from 4.5 percent to 7.5 percent.
At that time, adjustments were recorded in a number of cities around the state – some rates went higher while others were adjusted downward –without any reason announced by the state’s labor department for the changes.
The cities of Burbank, Lancaster, Los Angeles and the county of Los Angeles all saw decreases in their unemployment numbers, while Santa Clarita’s went up.
On May 6, City Manager Ken Striplin sent a letter to the state Employment Development Division asking for clarification.
Citing strong economic activity indicators – new jobs and companies - Striplin asked for an analysis of the calculation and description of any new methodology used to determine the rates.
The state has not responded to the city.
According to Michael Martinez, Research Manager, for the state’s labor department – and to whom the letter was addressed – numbers were revised when the state finally gained access to population numbers for individual cities – based on the 2010 census numbers.
Prior to this year, the state apparently had been calculating based on 2000 census numbers.
In theory, the data should now be improved, he said. But Martinez couldn’t explain that statement and referred The Signal to a Los Angeles information services manager.
Pending any error in the calculation rate, it appears that Santa Clarita’s higher unemployment rate may be the new normal.
As for the bump between April and May, that’s a seasonal trend, said Jason Crawford, economic development manager for the city of Santa Clarita.
Indeed, last year the number also increased between April and May going from 4.6 to 4.8 percent.
“We continue to see strong economic indicators such as retail sales increasing and number of businesses in SCV increasing, as well as long term we are seeing new office and industrial development moving forward which will house many future jobs,” Crawford said.
Santa Clarita’s WorkSource Center Director supports that report.
The center, which helps people find work, has seen a reduction in the number of new clients visiting the center, said Keri Aaver. Or, in other words, the newly unemployed.
As the unemployment rates have been declining across the board, however, WorkSource Centers everywhere are meeting with people who visited the centers in the past, she said.
As the jobless rates continued declining, people who had not used their job services for a while began returning to the center hoping to find work, or a better job, Aaver said.
Still the declining number of newly unemployed visitors isn’t enough to explain the steep rise in jobless numbers experienced by the city.
“The generally higher rate for the Santa Clarita Valley (than California or the nation) is the result of a legacy situation that prevailed at the last census, rather than any true survey conducted on Santa Clarita Valley households,” explained Mark Schniepp, director for the California Economic Forecast, in an e-mail to The Signal.
“An estimated unemployment rate from the 2013 census is used as the base rate, and estimates over time are calculated on how the estimated unemployment rate for the County of Los Angeles moves over time, not the cities themselves,” Schniepp said. “So as L.A. County goes, so go all city unemployment rates too regardless of what happens in the city.”
The true measure for the unemployment rate is only calculated for the county of Los Angeles and the state of California, and not for all other individual counties or cities, he said.
Because the rates are not precise counts, Schniepp said the best indicators of how a regional economy is behaving requires looking at quarterly retail sales growth, annual population growth, housing starts, existing home sales and prices, commercial vacancy and building rates, and jobs created each month.
“Clearly, job growth has been faster in the Santa Clarita Valley vis-a-vis the County of LA as we’ve been presenting in our annual publications and presentations the last few years,” he said.
