In reading in Jonathan Kraut’s previous biographies that he is a veteran and former Army Ranger, I am going to do my best to not personally insult him. I will not go into a long diatribe regarding his article “The price being paid for poor policy” (June 23 in The Signal), but there are three things Mr. Kraut wrote that I wanted to comment on.
First, “Many civilian deaths are justified, but many are not.” Mr. Kraut: you’re a private investigator, why is there not exact count or percentage?
I’m absolutely certain the majority of law enforcement-related deaths in the U.S. are justified.
Use of force is not pretty, and it is tragic for all sides, but American law enforcement officers are not execution squads who wantonly use deadly force.
Second, “My examples of police cowardice and poor training. ...” In your article, where does it mention law enforcement ran away or failed to confront danger?
In your nightclub shooting example and your other example regarding the teen armed with a knife, unless I’m reading it wrong, law enforcement ran toward, rather than away from, the sound of gunfire, and law enforcement engaged the teen armed with a knife after the teen’s own mother allowed the police to enter their home to deal with her son.
And in both of incidents you wrote a jury exonerated these officers, which I interpret that these officers courageously acted within the scope of the law, within their department’s policy and training practices.
So are you inferring juries are also inept?
Lastly, “Unnecessary use of deadly force ... is killing us all.” The one key thing you failed to mention, Mr. Kraut, is that in regards to the recent, media-driven deadly use of force incidents, if all these individuals would have complied with law enforcement during their contact they would all still be alive today.
I have not heard of a single incident where a compliant citizen was accidentally killed while a law enforcement officer was reaching for handcuffs to take that person into custody.
Whether it was in Ferguson, New York City, Oklahoma or Los Angeles, all of those individuals made the decision to resist, and their act of resistance instigated the chain reaction that led to tragic outcomes.
If an individual wants to fight/contest arrest, that is done in court, and that is their right.
Citizens do not have the right to fight the matter in the streets, and maybe its society who is in need of training when it comes to these matters.
