A piece of the Santa Clarita Valley’s oil history — gutted by a fire last year — now faces the wrecking ball.
Around the turn of the 20th century, the “Star Oil House” welcomed executives from the Star Oil Company who kept a watchful eye on the Santa Clarita Valley’s oil fields.
Now, the Newhall residence is a burned-out wreck that city officials say is a “complete loss.”
“The fire has made the structure a complete loss, and the historical integrity of the structure has been compromised,” said David Peterson, an assistant planner with the city of Santa Clarita.
The structure was red-tagged after the fire last November.
Santa Clarita City Council members voted June 23 to approves plans to demolish the Star Oil House, along with another house and a shed at 24148 Pine St. in Newhall. The council also voted to accept the quarter-acre property on Pine Street as a donation.
The Star Oil House is one of the 15 structures included in the city’s historic preservation ordinance when it was revised in 2013.
“The Star Oil House was built prior to 1900 and was determined to be historically significant because it served as a residence for executives of the Star Oil Company who were overseeing the operation of local oil fields near the turn of the century,” reads the City Council agenda report.
Given the damage caused by the fire, council members voted to remove the historical designation from the structure.
However, they also agreed at June 23 to allow a 30-day historical research period for the second house on the property before demolition can start.
“There seems to be a discrepancy in the historical record about the true identity of the house that’s remaining,” said Leon Worden, a past president of the Santa Clarita Valley Historical Society who spoke on the topic at the June 23 council meeting. “And so, together with the city, hopefully we can figure out exactly what it is and then determine whether there is any desire to save it and move it to Heritage Junction (Historic Park).”
Santa Clarita’s historic preservation ordinance was a controversial topic locally, as council members and city officials sought to strike a balance between the rights of property owners and the city’s desire to hold on to its history.
City Council members eventually settled on an “opt-in” ordinance, whereby most property owners could choose whether to enroll their properties.
But some properties, such as those at Heritage Junction Historic Park in Newhall, were designated as historic from the outset.
Though the city outlined some permitting and financial incentives to try to entice owners to seek historical designation for their properties, it’s still the owner’s decision on whether to do so.
As of last week, no property owner had elected to opt into the historic preservation ordinance since it was approved two years ago, according to city planning officials.
With the removal of historic designation from the Star Oil House, seven of the city’s historic properties are located at Heritage Junction, while another seven are located outside the park.
The city itself does not take over management of historic properties.
“You can still live in a property that’s historic or do business in a property that’s historic,” Peterson said. “You just can’t do things to damage or destroy the historic value of the property.”
City Councilwoman Laurene Weste said many properties that may carry historical significance in the Santa Clarita Valley are not designated as such.
Last year, for instance, a developer demolished the surviving half of the old Newhall School — which had stood at 24514 Kansas St. for a century — to make way for a planned townhouse development.
“Maybe it just takes time for people to see the benefits,” Weste said of the historic preservation ordinance. “We hope so.”
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney


