The other day one Signal Opinion section writer chastised another about whether same-gender attraction occurs by choice, insisting that it’s imprinted in the DNA. From what I’ve read, the idea of a DNA determinant is still being debated.
Personally, I think a host of very complex causes most likely lead to homosexuality, but I have a question about the DNA position.
DNA passes on specific traits in an organism. Those traits either maintain, enhance or detract from the survivability of that organism through natural selection.
Traits can change through mutation, either to the benefit or the detriment of the organism. But the organism will survive only if a favorable trait dominates and that trait is passed on to following generations.
A chromosomal abnormality that increases the possibility of birth defects, diseases, death, etc. would obviously be a non-desirable trait. Science is constantly looking for solutions to such abnormalities in the hope that we can change them and restore health, if not to the individual, then to the species in general.
If a chromosome were discovered that moved that species toward eventual extinction, I’m pretty sure science would be very concerned and look real hard for a solution.
So assuming homosexuality is strictly a DNA issue, here’s my question: If DNA traits can be passed on only through sexual reproduction, and a particular chromosome inhibits or discourages sexual reproduction, how does it get passed on?
We can discuss dominant and recessive genes passing across generations, but the fact is that even a recessive gene — like blue eyes, for example — can be passed on only if people reproduce.
On the other hand, if a trait develops randomly through mutation, how does it get passed on if that mutation compels that species to behavior that stops reproduction?
If it’s a widespread mutation, what is causing it? Either way, if sexual reproduction becomes genetically inhibited in a species, what does that mean for the eventual survivability of that species? Or at the very least, the continuation of that particular trait?
Now what about choice? Putting aside the possibility that whether choice or DNA, the end result would very likely be the same, it seems to me that simply saying it’s all choice is a gross oversimplification. Sort of like saying it’s a simple matter of deciding to stand or sit.
This doesn’t take into account all the potential factors affecting a choice, or the actual power to carry out the choice.
Using an extreme, and not necessarily parallel, example for illustration purposes, how much power does a severe heroin addict have to stop his addiction by himself?
Some may say the person gave up that power when he chose to use heroin, but what about the factors in that person’s life that compelled him to try it in the first place — perhaps in order to kill emotional, physical or spiritual pain — and he didn’t know where else to turn, irrespective of the real possibility that there was somewhere else to turn.
If we say that person just needs to use will power to stop, we have absolutely no understanding of addiction.
Choices can sometimes be extremely confusing, and determining which way to choose will be affected by lack of knowledge, popular opinion, cultural standards or myriad other social or physical forces.
Everyone has something in his or her life that he or she struggles with, and over which he or she feels no real control, whatever the reason.
If we don’t all of us exercise a high degree of tolerance, as Pastor David W. Hegg so clearly explained in his Saturday column “Ethically Speaking a few weeks ago, and we don’t strive united for truth about this condition, we will surely gnaw on each other till we’re consumed.
Gordon Risser is a resident of Canyon Country.
