It was the worst man-made disaster in California history, yet its remnants lie neglected and crumbling in a Santa Clarita Valley canyon.
While the worst natural disaster in state history is the 1906 Great San Francisco Earthquake, the St. Francis Dam failure on March 12, 1928, was the direct result of mankind’s folly and arrogance.
Folly because dangerous risks were taken without understanding of consequences. Arrogance because those risks were assumed in a greedy rush to provide for developers of the greater Los Angeles basin – and only more water could meet human needs.
The consequences were an estimated 400-600 lives lost in the path of destruction, a swath of land from San Francisquito Canyon through the Santa Clarita and Santa Clara River valleys to the Pacific Ocean as the great dam built to supply Los Angeles’ water needs failed.
The exact number of dead will never be known — 12.4 billion gallons of water buried bodies under suddenly rearranged topography and carried others to the ocean; some were found in the Pacific near the Mexican border; some, no doubt, will never be found.
The catastrophe was painfully avoidable. The dam was deemed an immediate need by the precursor to the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power because of ongoing disputes with Owens Valley farmers who embraced guerilla warfare tactics to interrupt the flow of the Los Angeles Aqueduct.
The city to the south, its leaders determined, would not be left without sufficient water. And so the Los Angeles Bureau of Water Works and Supply turned to its water guru, William Mulholland, who had designed and built the L.A. Aqueduct.
It was bureau engineers led by Mulholland who chose the geologically flawed site for the St. Francis Dam; bureau engineers led by Mulholland who oversaw the dam construction; bureau engineers led by Mulholland who OK’d adding 10 feet to the dam’s height in 1925, the year after base construction had begun; and Mulholland himself who, with an associate, declared the dam safe not long before it failed.
It was Mulholland, too, who took the blame for the dam’s failure, which ruined him. That fact, however, most likely brought little comfort to survivors.
In some cases, entire families were wiped out. Through the horror of abruptly vanished family members, suddenly missing neighbors and friends, instantly leveled homes and ranches, stunned residents of the two valleys rebuilt and carried on. In those days, high-priced lawyers and massive lawsuits were not the first thought after grieving. Survival was.
Meanwhile, Los Angeles city officials quietly did what they could to obliterate the dam site. The “tombstone,” a massive section of the dam that remained standing after the flood, was pulled down and jack-hammered, along with other dam debris.
The location, extremely remote by 1920s standards, made it easier to overlook the devastation brought by human folly. Eighty-seven years of weathering have since taken their toll.
Today there’s one obscure plaque marking the disaster on the side of San Francisquito Canyon Road below the dam site. Nothing else marks the spot. No signs showing where to park to visit the dam site, no footpath indicators for hiking to the location, no identifiers to distinguish aged and crumbling concrete from the topography, no displays that would allow visitors to picture the then-powerful dam compared to its lowly present status, to point out the geology that may have laid the dam low.
No accounts of the heroism of men and women that night as black water swept through darkness to kill; no displays to illustrate what went wrong at St. Francis, prompting visitors to ponder man’s arrogant attempts to control nature; no discussions of the good that came from this disaster: dam safety legislation, civil engineer licensing and regulation requirements.
Congressman Steve Knight, R-Palmdale, has proposed legislation for a national memorial at the St. Francis Dam site, and we wholeheartedly agree.
We urge you to support Knight’s proposal HR3153, which is currently in the House Committee on Natural Resources, by writing or calling committee Chairman Rob Bishop at 123 Cannon Building, Washington, D.C. 20515; 202-225-0453; fax 202-225-5857. Or send an electronic message to Bishop at http://robbishop.house.gov/.
