While a recent bill to designate the site of the St. Francis Dam disaster a national memorial is drawing praise in the Santa Clarita Valley, some local cyclists and business owners are objecting to another provision of the bill that would designate tens of thousands of acres in the northern Santa Clarita Valley as a wilderness area.
The proposed Castaic Wilderness area, introduced as part of Congressman Steve Knight’s House Resolution 3153, would turn 69,812 acres into wilderness from San Francisquito Canyon in Saugus to wide swaths of land above Castaic Lake.
Though proponents say the wilderness will help preserve the ecology and heritage of the land, others claim the designation will weaken local control and bar bicyclists from the area.
“We all believe in preserving and saving land for our kids and our community, but you’ve got to do it right, and the way it’s being proposed now is not,” said Valencia resident Tony Arnold.
Arnold, president and CEO of SetPoint Medical Inc. in Valencia, said if the area becomes wilderness, it would fall under the jurisdiction of Congress for decision-making purposes.
Local residents “should help manage the land in our valley and not need a presidential signature and act of Congress to manage the land,” he said.
“As our community expands and existing private land is developed, I can imagine a time when we want a new park, campground or open space, and wilderness will not allow for SCV citizens to have adequate recreational opportunities,” he said.
The proposed wilderness has also drawn the ire of local cyclists. Activities involving mechanized or motorized equipment is forbidden in wilderness areas — a restriction that includes bicycles.
“It will be literally illegal for us to ride our bike on any part of the land,” said Valencia resident Ken Raleigh, an avid mountain biker.
Raleigh said a good deal of the land that would be covered under the Castaic Wilderness is already designated as “back country non-motorized” and therefore closed to things like motorcycles or off-road vehicles.
Expanding those restrictions to bicycles would be a huge blow to the Santa Clarita Valley’s cycling community, critics say.
“There are some folks who just believe that the natural resources can’t be trusted with anyone, so we have to lock them down, restrict them and not let anyone derive any benefit from them,” said Newhall resident Tim Burkhart. “And I don’t think that’s what we need to do.”
Burkhart said he’s gone biking, hiking and camping in the area for about 40 years.
“Let’s protect it without excluding people,” he said.
Critics of the wilderness area said they would like to speak more with Knight, R-Palmdale, to discuss their concerns.
Knight said Friday he’s already met with some people who objected to the wilderness designation and he anticipates meeting with other groups in the future.
“What we’ve done is, when people come forward with issues about something we’re doing, we want to work with those groups and make it as good as possible,” Knight said.
Though he said he wants “to keep the integrity of the bill” since “there’s an awful lot of people who support the wilderness area,” he’s confident concerns from both sides can be addressed.
“It’s a process, and I’m glad people have come forward to tell me about their concerns before we can’t do anything about it,” he said.
Though the wilderness proposal has been a topic of concern, those who spoke with The Signal said they support the other aspect of Knight’s bill — creating a national memorial to mark the site of the St. Francis Dam disaster.
Hundreds of residents were killed and business, ranches and homes were wiped out or seriously damaged after the dam collapsed in San Francisquito Canyon in 1928.
“I think that is a long time coming and something that should have been done years ago,” Burkhart said of a St. Francis Dam memorial. “I have no issues with that and support it 100 percent.”
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney

