Environmentalists are excited to see their ongoing fight to stop 21,000 homes being built on the banks of the Santa Clara River go all the way to the California Supreme Court.
On Sept. 2, the state’s top court will hear oral arguments in a case that pits environmentalists against Los Angeles County for having approved a plan by Newhall land Development Inc. to build Newhall Ranch west of Valencia.
Lynne Plambeck, president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment, called next week’s court review of the Newhall Ranch development timely.
“In this time of drought when water cutbacks of up to 32 percent are being imposed on residents in the Santa Clarita Valley, it is important that our planning agencies carefully review water supplies for this massive 21,000 unit project,” she told The Signal Wednesday.
“We applaud the Supreme Court for taking a closer look,” Plambeck said.
John Buse, an environmentalist representing the Center for Biological Diversity - one of the groups that filed the initial suit against Newhall Land in 2012 - said a favorable Supreme Court decision would likely affect the outcome of a separate lawsuit opposing the developer’s plans for the Landmark Village portion of the Newhall Ranch project.
“It is likely that the outcome in that case will determine the outcome in the Landmark Village case,” he told The Signal late Tuesday.
When asked Tuesday for response to news that the California Supreme Court had agreed to hear the case, Marlee Lauffer, vice president of marketing and communications for Newhall Land, said the company does not comment on pending litigation.
In March 2014, a California appellate court ruled in favor of developers planning to build 21,000 homes on the banks of the Santa Clara River and tossed out a 2012 court decision opposed to the project.
At that time, judges of the Second Appellate District Court announced a reversal of a court decision made in 2012 in favor of environmentalists who sued Newhall Land Development Inc. They argued the company’s Newhall Ranch housing development, which has yet to break ground though it’s been planned for some 20 years, would destroy natural habitat near the river.
Newhall Ranch would be a master-planned community from the same firm that planned and developed Valencia. After its projected 25- to 30-year construction period, it would include more than 20,000 residences west of Interstate 5.
Three years ago, officials representing the Center for Biological Diversity filed a lawsuit against the California Department of Fish & Wildlife and Newhall Land alleging Newhall Ranch would destroy natural habitat for native plants and animals along the banks of the Santa Clara River, among them the San Fernando Valley Spineflower and the Unarmored Threespine Stickleback fish.
On Oct. 15, 2012, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Ann Jones ruled in favor of the environmentalist groups’ challenge of the project.
She cited flaws in the Environmental Impact Report prepared for the development by Newhall Land in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act.
Newhall Land appealed the decision.
In February 2014, both sides presented their respective arguments before a panel of three Los Angeles appellate court judges.
A month later, those judges announced their decision in favor of the developer.
The previous court ruling made by Jones was rejected, or in the words of the Second Appellate District Court, “reversed with directions.”
“It’s a full reversal of the lower court ruling and firmly upholds our permits,” Lauffer said in March 2014.
One of the many environmental arguments made by Center for Biological Diversity officials in February 2014 was how a car parked in the driveway of every one of the 21,000 Newhall Ranch homes — an impact Buse says would contribute to greenhouse gas emissions.
The 112-page court decision released by the appellate judges and obtained by The Signal dismissed that argument and upheld the findings of the project’s 5,828-page Environmental Impact Report prepared by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.
On the specific issue of greenhouse gas, the court concluded the environmentalists’ contentions had no merit.
Nehwall Land officials argued that the Environmental Impact Report they prepared was sound and sensitive to the environment.
The first phase of Newhall Ranch was approved by Los Angeles County supervisors in February 2012 after exhaustive studies.
The project calls for developing 422 lots on about 295 acres. That would produce 270 single-family homes, 744 condominiums and 430 apartments, along with 16 commercial lots.
The plan for Landmark Village also calls for 119 lots for open space, plus at least one fire station, park and school.
661-287-5527
On Twitter @jamesarthurholt.com
