After months of silence or short prepared statements, Haggen filed its first counter-shot on Tuesday since it acquired dozens of stores – as ordered by the Federal Trade Commission – from Albertsons, which included two Santa Clarita grocery stores.
The grocery retailer, based in Bellingham, Washington, filed a $1 billion-plus lawsuit in federal court against Albertsons LLC, claiming Albertsons duped Haggen into buying 146 stores in five states and then set the small chain up to fail by violating terms of the FTC approval.
The complaint alleges Albertsons engaged in “coordinated and systematic efforts to eliminate competition and Haggen as a viable competitor,” as well as “made false representations to both Haggen and the FTC about Albertsons’ commitment to a seamless transformation of the stores under the Haggen banner.”
Painting a David vs. Goliath scenario in the lawsuit, Haggen claimed that in order for the merger between Albertsons and Safeway to proceed, creating one of the largest food retailers in the United States with over 2,200 stores and $61 billion in combined sales, Albertsons sought out Haggen to buy its stores and agreed to abide by all conditions of the sale – but didn’t.
Haggen listed 10 points in its complaint alleging Albertsons’ actions were anti-competitive, critically damaging Haggen’s operations, customer service, brand goodwill and profitability.
Among the points made, Haggen stated that it was “provided with misleading and incomplete retail pricing data, causing Haggen stores to unknowingly inflate prices.”
Indeed, shoppers have complained about prices at all Haggen-converted stores. Prices even vary between stores – even those operating within two miles of each other, such as in Santa Clarita.
Haggen also alleges that Albertsons deliberately understocked some inventory Haggen acquired, resulting in stock levels being so low as to negatively affect shoppers.
Albertsons also deliberately overstocked perishable inventory at the stores it acquired, according to Haggen, forcing it to throw away significant amounts of inventory it paid for – financially affecting the Pacific Northwest retailer in the midst of its conversion.
In late July, Albertsons sued Haggen for failing to pay for more than $36 million in inventory as part of the sale. In that complaint, Albertsons said Haggen paid for the stock in 108 stores, but failed to pay for the remaining 38.
In response at the time, Haggen stated in a low-key reply that it had notified Albertsons of “violations of its obligations” under the purchase agreement, possibly even the Federal Trade Commission consent decree, but had hoped to resolve them amicably.
By mid-August, a Haggen executive announced it was forced to shutter 27 stores in California, Nevada, Arizona, Oregon and Washington to “ensure a stable, healthy company.”
In Tuesday’s complaint, Haggen also accused Albertsons of removing store fixtures and inventory from Haggen-acquired stores that Haggen paid for; diverting Haggen inventory to Albertsons stores; and failing to perform routine maintenance on stores and equipment.
It also claims customer data was “illegally accessed” from Haggen to gain an unfair advantage. No specifics were provided to explain this point.
Lastly, Haggen claimed Albertsons used “proprietary and confidential conversion scheduling information to plan and execute aggressive marketing campaigns intended to undermine Haggen grand openings.”
When the Haggen deal was first announced in December, and awaiting FTC approval, one industry source predicted the move would not be good for Santa Clarita shoppers.
He questioned whether such a small regionalized grocery chain could manage growing from 18 stores to acquiring 146 more stores almost overnight; and whether they would have the logistics and management strength to manage a chain across five states growing so quickly. He also claimed Haggen was getting lesser performing stores from Albertsons.
But the source also questioned why the FTC was “so hot on Haggen,” putting some of the blame possibly on the federal agency’s shoulders.
Albertsons has not publically issued a statement yet, but in an email to The Signal, a spokesperson said the retailer disagreed with the claims made by Haggen.
“The allegations in the lawsuit are completely without merit,” said Carlos Illingworth, director of communications and government affairs for Albertsons, Vons and Pavilions.

