California legislators are considering a pair of bills that, if approved, would set lofty future pollution reduction targets for the state.
Critics, though, claim the bills set the bar at a level that may be unattainable and that will further hamstring the Golden State’s ability to be economically competitive.
One of those pieces of legislation, Senate Bill 350, sets a trio of new clean energy goals for the state to reach by the year 2030: To reduce motor vehicle petroleum use by 50 percent, increase the energy efficiency of existing buildings by 50 percent and require that 50 percent of electricity come from renewable sources.
Supporters say the bill would complement existing statewide “green” efforts and push California toward a cleaner and more efficient future.
“The goals set forth in SB 350 are ambitious, and they will test our ingenuity and resolve, but we can, and must, accomplish them,” said Senate President pro Tem Kevin de Leon, the bill’s sponsor, in a statement. “We already have a successful framework in place to do so. We have the know-how, we have the means, and we have broad public support – the only remaining question is: do we have the will and the courage to act?”
Pavley bill
Another piece of legislation — Senate Bill 32, from Sen. Fran Pavley, D-Agoura Hills — would build upon previous legislation to limit greenhouse gas emissions.
SB 32 would require the California Air Resources Board to set new targets for greenhouse gas emissions that are 40 percent below 1990 levels by 2030, and that are 80 percent below 1990 levels by 2050.
The bill builds upon California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, AB32, which already requires the state’s emission of greenhouse gases to be reduced to 1990 levels by the year 2020.
“California is closing on its current goal,” Pavley said in a statement when her new bill passed the Senate in June. “SB 32 will keep that momentum going for another 30 years by building on progress we have made.”
The proposed legislation would set the bar high, but Pavley said California has both the ability, and the responsibility, to meet those standards.
“We know today we can do this,” she said in a statement last week. “And we have a moral imperative to do so.”
Criticism and questions
Opponents, though, say ratcheting up the standards will deal a huge blow to California’s economic competitiveness.
They also question whether the goals are even attainable — and what the bill would mean for taxpayers.
“We’ve done great things but now they just keep pushing and pushing and pushing to the point where energy is seen as the ‘Wicked Witch,’ when, quite frankly, it’s part of the economic engine of our entire state,” said Assemblyman Tom Lackey, R-Palmdale, of SB 350 during a recent town hall meeting in Canyon Country.
“I think that this is a another huge overreach that is not sustainable and will ruin our economic competitive nature as a state,” he added.
At that same town hall meeting, Assemblyman Scott Wilk, R-Santa Clarita, said voters should be concerned with the Legislature handing off policy-making power to the California Air Resources Board. The board, made up of appointed officials, would set new rules to meet higher pollution reduction targets under the legislation.
“The problem is we’re handing the reigns over to the California Air Resources Board to make those decisions for us,” Wilk said. The Legislature should make those decisions, he said, “because if you don’t like those decisions, you can fire us.”
Wilk added that, in terms of global pollution, California is only a small piece of the pie.
“California is the eighth-largest economy in the world, yet we produce less than 1 percent of all carbon emissions,” he said. “The problem is not California; the problem is China, India — all those other places, and we’re making ourselves less competitive economically.”
Status
Both SB 350 and SB 32 have passed the Senate and are under review in the state Assembly.
The last day for each house to pass bills to Gov. Jerry Brown’s desk is next Friday.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
